Discuss EICR for flat built in 2007: downlights deemed as C2 in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

Reaction score
0
Hello friendly electricians!

Just before the deadline (...) I commissioned an EICR report that came back as unsatisfactory. The only thing that I can see in the report that points to that is a C2 observation mentioning that "All lights need to be changed to fire rated". No specific regulation mentioned.
The electrician has quoted around £900 to replace 21 downlights.

I'm finding contradictory reports online around this and the quote seems pricey, but what do I know. The electrician said it'll take between half a day and a full day.

Do you have any feedback on whether this is would be likely to be a C2 and whether the quote is reasonable?

Thanks a lot in advance.
 
Hello friendly electricians!

Just before the deadline (...) I commissioned an EICR report that came back as unsatisfactory. The only thing that I can see in the report that points to that is a C2 observation mentioning that "All lights need to be changed to fire rated". No specific regulation mentioned.
The electrician has quoted around £900 to replace 21 downlights.

I'm finding contradictory reports online around this and the quote seems pricey, but what do I know. The electrician said it'll take between half a day and a full day.

Do you have any feedback on whether this is would be likely to be a C2 and whether the quote is reasonable?

Thanks a lot in advance.
Sounds pricey,if fittings are £10 that's nearly £700 labour inc vat if any.Some scheme/scam operators say C2 if there,s a room above the fittings and C3 if on a first floor with no room above.
Regards, S
 
Depends if it is a fire ceiling.
KSR cans are £6 and good lamps £4 so that is £210 half a day to fit, max £250 so £460 would be reasonable.
 
Hello friendly electricians!

Just before the deadline (...) I commissioned an EICR report that came back as unsatisfactory. The only thing that I can see in the report that points to that is a C2 observation mentioning that "All lights need to be changed to fire rated". No specific regulation mentioned.
The electrician has quoted around £900 to replace 21 downlights.

I'm finding contradictory reports online around this and the quote seems pricey, but what do I know. The electrician said it'll take between half a day and a full day.

Do you have any feedback on whether this is would be likely to be a C2 and whether the quote is reasonable?

Thanks a lot in advance.
Do you have any pics of the downlights you could post up please
 
Also remember the you don't have to get the same electrician in to do any remedial work. Though some of the less scrupulous companies play on that myth.

So if needed due to fire regs (don't know myself) you should at least ask for another electrician's quote to see what is the likely cost in your location, and if the existing quote is a bit over the top (which it is looking like from above estimates, but hard to price stuff without seeing the job).
 
if the room above is another flat, different tenant/owner, then fire rated downlights are required. C2 is the correct coding. however that quote is excessive. even for london.
 
Is this a purpose build block of flats and not a converted building then each flat is a fire compartment and fire rated is not required so it all depends on the Building construction.
As a note to the observations there is no such thing as an 18th Ed consumer unit.
 
I don't suppose there is any certificate from the build of the flat?

My understanding is that "Fire rated" downlights are only needed in a fire rated surface (normally a ceiling) to maintain the required fire rating of that surface.

Where there is a property above then the ceiling may be required to have a fire rating - in which case the lights must maintain that rating.

Many purpose build plats flats are built with concrete frames etc to avoid fire spread, so the plasterboard ceilings do not necessarily need to be fire rated - though it can be difficult to be sure.

If the flat was built to the building regulations at the time relating to fire, then I would assume that was considered when the original downlights were installed. Having said that, I'm not sure how wise it is to assume anything with flats and large builds, given more recent experiences...

Regardless, the quote sounds excessive, so I would be looking for quotes and second opinions. There are other options, such as fire hoods, (though they can take longer to install properly than new fittings...)
 
I’m surprised that the lights installed in a new flats just 13 year old are open back down lights. I stopped buying open backed lights around 2004/2005. Are you certain they aren’t can type downlights ?
 
Is this a purpose build block of flats and not a converted building then each flat is a fire compartment and fire rated is not required so it all depends on the Building construction.
As a note to the observations there is no such thing as an 18th Ed consumer unit.
Yes, purpose built and not converted.

The electrician is certain they need replacing:

Your lights are not fire rated
As per BS7671 you’ll need ip 20 fire rated ones.
Don’t have the book front of me but you can get one and check yourself
It’s called the 18th editor BS8671 book.
It’s in there.
 
F/R down lights £7 , Led lamp £3 x 21 = £210 (call it £250 if you buy dearer lamps)

£350 days Labour

£600 absolutely tops

even with London rate £900 is a rip off price
 
If that job was on my door step , I would do it £500

trouble is everyone is trying to get rich quick it seems and well over quoting on jobs , I did a small job the other day for someone changed an old pendant in an en-suite to 2 down lights. Charged £100 + materials.
they told me another electrician quoted them nearly 5 x that.

no wonder I got the job...
 
As per BS7671 you’ll need ip 20 fire rated ones.
Don’t have the book front of me but you can get one and check yourself
It’s called the 18th editor BS8671 book.
It’s in there.

Not a great sign that he tells you to buy a book but can't be bothered to find the regulation himself to justify his quote.

There may have been a requirements for fire rated ones when installed new in your case - (though the requirement for them would be Building Regulations Part B I believe, not BS7671). That would depend on the method of construction and fire containment used at the time.

The issue is whether they are now a C2 (required improvement) on an EICR.

The Best Practice Guide does list as a C2

"Fire Risk from incorrectly installed electrical equipment, including incorrectly selected or installed downlighters"

So a C2 may be appropriate - but if they are a purpose built block of flats, not just converted houses, then I suspect the ceiling may not be a fire barrier and the lights might be a C3 at worst.

But you should definitely be looking around for other quotes imo.

If the work is done, you do not need to get a new EICR done btw, though you will need to keep proof of the work (ideally a certificate for the installation) - to show that you've had the remedial work done.
 
If it is a block of flats then each dwelling is a fire compartment.
 
Again yous dont know company size and rate. There is always someone who will do it cheaper.
If you had problems do you trust youl get this guy again is the question?
 
Thank you all for your replies. I really appreciate it.

I've contacted a couple of landlord in the same block, and neither has mentioned that they had to change their spotlights. One invoice from them lists the faults below.

Now I am concerned that my report might have be done incorrectly. Is it possible for these faults to be unique to a specific flat or would they be related to the original installation?
C2 faults

RCBO does not trip within required time
Works required:
Replace RCBO and retest

(5.2 Sockets for kitchen appliances not fixed or supported
Works required:
To support sockets under kitchen units

5.3 Low insulation results
Works required:
To determine if fault is coming from an appliance or wiring and attempt to repair or provide further recommendations also to then allow appliances to pass PAT test

(5.7 Switch not earthed
Works required:
To reconnect earth and touch up decoration around switch

5.16 b)Spot lights incorrectly connected
Works required:
To reconnect spotlights so that the cable clamps are used and the single insulation is protected inside the enclosure.

FI Socket circuit resistances inconsistent
Works required:
Neutral conductors are not continuous to remove sockets and locate loose cable then touch up decoration if required

FI Hall lights have no power, to
Remove switches and trace source of fault we can not confirm if lights work until power is restored.
 

Reply to EICR for flat built in 2007: downlights deemed as C2 in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock