Discuss How to report a bad electrician??? in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

Ok my twopennorth. Bad electrics and electricians have been with us since electricity was installed everywhere, can we do anything about that? In a word, no all we can do is do our jobs as best we can and try to encourage customers to educate themselves about A) The dangers inherent and B) What to expect from someone purporting to be an electrician because no one else is going to do it.
Should the CPS operators/LABC/trading standards be taking action against the cowboys? Hell yes but they either don't or can't for whatever reason, there's nothing we can do about it other than complain on sites like this because no one is listening guys. The scam operators have the ear of the government and they're being told that everything is hunky dory.
As I said, all we can do is to do our jobs to the best of our abilities
 
Quite frankly it's up to the aggrieved party to take action if they think thay have had unsatisfactory work....the aggrieved party being the person who authorised the original work....NOT the electrician called in to rectify it.
We are electricians,not the police....what others get up to is not our lookout.
 
I'm not sure if this is the right section??

I have just finished fixing a job that another electrician first started back late last year. Basically in a shortened version: A customer asked a British Gas Sub-contracted electrician to price for a Consumer Upgrade, which he did (and I have a copy of the estimate). He then came with his 'step daughter in-law' to do the works which also involved adding 4no Double Sockets, 1no Single Socket and a S.F Connection unit for Kitchen Lights. It then came to the end of the day when he turned round and said there is a fault on the ring main, I've wired it up so it won't trip and I'll come back to sort it out. He then got paid and has since, never been back! He ignores calls from the customer and so forth. I then got asked to go and have a look as they have had enough and want it sorted. I went as I was recommended to them by a previous customer. I found and rectified the fault as best as I can. It is not ideal but is now safe and protected by the RCD! I have urged them to have a full rewire at the soonest possible time. I also upgraded the bonding to the main gas and water pipes as they weren't up to scratch. I have logged my part with the BRCS and have provided a certificate where I have stated what I have done and what needs doing.

This really annoys me as I seem to be coming across this more and more of late and would like to know where to go if we wanted to log a complaint? I've tried the NIC and Chack a trade but they aren't on either.

Any help greatly appreciated.

Cheers
Joe

So what was the fault then? And what do you mean you rectified it best you can although not ideal? Surely you sorted it or didn't?
Howcome you urged them to have a FULL REWIRE as soo aas possible. Did you do a full EICR?
 
Good afternoon..

I’m having an issue with an Electrician who did some work in my kitchen conversion.
I had a total now kitchen refurb which required 5 new double sockets and 11 new Down lights.
The electrician told us we would need a whole new fuse board as the current one was only single RCD.
He said he could do the required work but would not be able to issue a certificate until I have a new board fitted at a cost of £550.
I was told by another electrician that was nonesense and he needs to issue a cert for the work undertaken so I can get a completion cert from building control.
He still maintained that he was not going to issue an installation cert.
I contacted NICEIC for advice and they confirmed what I was told that he has to issue an installation certificate with the advice that a double RCD board is fitted at a later date.
They said if he deemed it unsafe then he should not have started the work.
I’ve sent him the response from NICIEC but he is ignoring my calls and messages now.
What can I do to get him to issue me the installation cert for the work he undertook?

Thanks in advance.
 
Good afternoon..

I’m having an issue with an Electrician who did some work in my kitchen conversion.
I had a total now kitchen refurb which required 5 new double sockets and 11 new Down lights.
The electrician told us we would need a whole new fuse board as the current one was only single RCD.
He said he could do the required work but would not be able to issue a certificate until I have a new board fitted at a cost of £550.
I was told by another electrician that was nonesense and he needs to issue a cert for the work undertaken so I can get a completion cert from building control.
He still maintained that he was not going to issue an installation cert.
I contacted NICEIC for advice and they confirmed what I was told that he has to issue an installation certificate with the advice that a double RCD board is fitted at a later date.
They said if he deemed it unsafe then he should not have started the work.
I’ve sent him the response from NICIEC but he is ignoring my calls and messages now.
What can I do to get him to issue me the installation cert for the work he undertook?

Thanks in advance.
Is the electrician a member of one of the CPS schemes
 
Is the electrician a member of one of the CPS schemes
Thanks for the response.

I’m not sure to be honest..There is little or know info on his website and he won’t answer my calls.
I might see if building control can force the issue, if not I’ll take legal action, but I’d rather he just issued me what I’m entitled to and what I paid for.
 
Posting a picture of your consumer unit may answer a few questions.

I'm wondering - Single RCD - meaning ALL circuits are protected by one RCD,
OR or a fairly typical split load board that has some RCD protected circuits and some non-RCD-protected circuits, typically lighting circuits?
Speculating - he might have a point if the latter, as new work has to done to current regs which requires RCD protection for lighting.
If the former he might also be concerned about a recent regulation requiring division of the installation so a fault doesn't trip the whole house (paraphrasing)
However this should have all be agreed before work starts and it's not totally clear at what point this requirement for a new CU was communicated.

I'd ask him to put in writing why the addition or alteration doesn't comply with the regulations (which is a direct reference to regulation 641.5 )

Do you know whether the kitchen refurb required new circuits, or were existing circuits extended? If new circuits were involved he should in theory be registered with a competent persons scheme.
 
Posting a picture of your consumer unit may answer a few questions.

I'm wondering - Single RCD - meaning ALL circuits are protected by one RCD,
OR or a fairly typical split load board that has some RCD protected circuits and some non-RCD-protected circuits, typically lighting circuits?
Speculating - he might have a point if the latter, as new work has to done to current regs which requires RCD protection for lighting.
If the former he might also be concerned about a recent regulation requiring division of the installation so a fault doesn't trip the whole house (paraphrasing)
However this should have all be agreed before work starts and it's not totally clear at what point this requirement for a new CU was communicated.

I'd ask him to put in writing why the addition or alteration doesn't comply with the regulations (which is a direct reference to regulation 641.5 )

Do you know whether the kitchen refurb required new circuits, or were existing circuits extended? If new circuits were involved he should in theory be registered with a competent persons scheme.
How to report a bad electrician??? thumbnail_IMG_2091 - EletriciansForums.net

The additional sockets are form a current circuit.
Just for the record, I never chose this electrician, he was supplied as part of the overall work by a building contractor.

Thank you for your advice and would appreciate anything else that may help me close this issue.
 
View attachment 88170

The additional sockets are form a current circuit.
Just for the record, I never chose this electrician, he was supplied as part of the overall work by a building contractor.

Thank you for your advice and would appreciate anything else that may help me close this issue.
There's a number of points here.

Regarding the consumer unit - As far as I can tell that's a Lewden unit, parts are available for it, and there is capacity.
I can't immediately see any reason it would need replacing. If a lighting circuit has been extended then the lighting should now have RCD protection (see below). There's also a locking pin missing but that is common and fixable.

Regarding Building Control - is anyone actually asking for an electrical installation certificate?
I'm doubting that there is any notifiable work here as it looks as though circuits have just been altered and the work isn't in a special location. If that is the case there is no requirement to notify building control unless they are aware of the work for other reasons and are asking for a certificate. So you may not actually need one. It would be the electrician notifying building control and not you in any case.

Regarding the electrician - he is supposed to issue a certificate for the work and you are entitled to one.
If the electrician is claiming the board needs changing because the new lighting isn't RCD protected, an RCBO unit can be fitted on the right hand side, and these are available new and 2nd hand.
If the electrician is claiming that the consumer unit doesn't meet the latest regs with regard to division of circuits to avoid nuisance tripping then the lighting is separate to the sockets and that is acceptable.
He also shouldn't have proceeded if there was an issue with the circuit he was altering.

Finally, the building contractor supplied the electrician. I'd imagine the building contractor has now been paid?
 
Not wanting to hijack the thread but it worries me that british gas are going into ev installs in a big way and will be subbing a lot of this work out. Expecting 2 + installs a day... The quality is going.to go downhill very quickly.
 
So it's the lights that are the problem.
Simple solution is to replace both of those 6A MCBs with 6A RCBOs (a combined RCD and MCB) which timhoward thinks are available. This will bring your CU up to modern standards from an electrical point of view.
That’s helpful.. thank you.

I’ll put this to the electrician and see what he thinks.. If he replies.
 
Plastic CU. I can see entirely both sides of this argument and it’s unlikely we’ll get to hear the electricians decision making process. I’m minded to think this isn’t a cowboy simply as if it were then they’d have taken the money and walked away with zero craps given.
 
Plastic CU. I can see entirely both sides of this argument and it’s unlikely we’ll get to hear the electricians decision making process. I’m minded to think this isn’t a cowboy simply as if it were then they’d have taken the money and walked away with zero craps given.

Thank you.

One question I have in relation to that observation.
If the Electrician deemed the CU to be unsuitable, should they have started the work?
It was explained that we needed an installation certificate to enable the project to be signed off by building control.
From what I’ve been told, and please correct me if this is incorrect, a certificate should be issued regardless.
If they had no intention of handing us a certificate they should not have done any work?
Is that a fair summary?
 

Reply to How to report a bad electrician??? in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock