Discuss Goods Lift Brake Solenoid Not Operating Correctly in the Industrial Electrician Talk area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

Intoelectrics

-
Mentor
Esteemed
Arms
Reaction score
1,053
Hi all,

Just looking for some advice,

I've been asked to take a look at a brake system on a goods lift. The lift is very old and unreliable with many parts now discontinued.
Its a cable and pulley type OTIS lift.

The shaft between the motor and gear box has a simple solenoid operated braking device. The lift engineers have been out to investigate the brake as its binding on. They have taken the whole device away had it re-furbished and fitted it back in situ. The problem still persists, they have explained that the coil in the solenoid was re-wound and tested prior to re-instalment.
The I.d plate on the solenoid is a bit worn and very unclear but it appears to me to be rated at 185v dc. I tested the applied voltage and found it to be 170v ac. I'm now in a bit of dispute with the lift engineer's technical guy over this.
They tell me that they have exchanged a bridge rectifier at some point, I'm arguing that the problem lies with the wrong voltage.
Speaking to the employees who use the lift daily they say that you can hear the squeal from the brake and that its been like that for a while.

Have any of you guys come across this type of thing?

Thanks
 
If the solenoid has definitely been rewound for dc but the applied voltage is ac then it is highly possible the solenoid isn't pulling in enough.
 
Hi all,

Just looking for some advice,

I've been asked to take a look at a brake system on a goods lift. The lift is very old and unreliable with many parts now discontinued.
Its a cable and pulley type OTIS lift.

The shaft between the motor and gear box has a simple solenoid operated braking device. The lift engineers have been out to investigate the brake as its binding on. They have taken the whole device away had it re-furbished and fitted it back in situ. The problem still persists, they have explained that the coil in the solenoid was re-wound and tested prior to re-instalment.
The I.d plate on the solenoid is a bit worn and very unclear but it appears to me to be rated at 185v dc. I tested the applied voltage and found it to be 170v ac. I'm now in a bit of dispute with the lift engineer's technical guy over this.
They tell me that they have exchanged a bridge rectifier at some point, I'm arguing that the problem lies with the wrong voltage.
Speaking to the employees who use the lift daily they say that you can hear the squeal from the brake and that its been like that for a while.

Have any of you guys come across this type of thing?

Thanks
What voltage have you got across the solenoid?
 
I would change the rectifier and see if it improves
 
And is it definitely AC?
Where is the bridge rectifier mentioned connected? A 170 volt AC supply fed through a bridge rectifier, with an electrolytic capacitor connected across it's DC output will produce considerably more than 185 volts DC.
Well this is what is confusing me. The job is being done by the lift engineers, I was on site at the time and the company asked me to take a quick look as the lift engineers were scratching their heads. They (understandably) did not want me around and it was uncomfortable. So I checked the ID plate and tested across the solenoid terminals as the brake was dis-engaged. I got 169V AC, the I.D tag (though worn) looks to read 185V DC. I concluded that this was the problem, mentioned it to their tech guy and he began to waffle on about it, very annoyed at my presence there. He mentioned the bridge rectifier but did not give any details. I have now since left site and apparently the lift is now working. I'm not privy to what was done to sort it.
 
The solenoid, being an electromagnetic device, produces a force by the action of the current flowing through its coil. Being a coil wound on a metal former it has both resistance and inductance.

The current through the coil depends then on the waveform of the applied voltage V between A1 and A2. For a continuous unchanging voltage (cc in my attached diagram and in red) the current is only limited by the resistance of the coil R since there is no back emf produced by L.

For a pure alternating sinusoidal waveform (ac and in black) the current throught the coil is limited by the impedance of the coil viz Z = R + jXL or Z= sqrt(Rsq + XLsq); thus if the ac voltage has an rms voltage the same magnitude as the continuous applied voltage the current flowing through the solenoid Iac will be smaller than Icc and decrease further with increasing frequency.

For full wave rectified ac (no smoothing) energising voltage once again the solenoid will present an impedance (not pure resistance) and Ifw will be less than Icc and decrease with frequency.

The addition of a smoothing capacitor will filter out the ripple of the full wave rectified waveform meaning that the applied voltage too becomes more a like continuous unchanging voltage - the current through the solenoid will tend towards the same value as Icc as the ripple reduces since the impedance of the winding tends towards R as the harmonics of the rectified ac are filtered out.

In sum then a coil wound for dc will require a higher ac rms voltage energising voltage to produce the same force since I = V/Z for ac and V/R for pure dc.

As a thought experiment once could imagine an alternating voltage V being full wave rectifed and smoothed perfectly by a great amount of shunt capacitance so that 185V dc was produced as a continuous waveform. Now gradually reduce the shunt capacitance until none is in circuit - the current through the coil will decrease even though the applied ac voltage V of the source remains constant because Z increases. The solenoid become weaker.

(Actually you have to think of the Z of the circuit for each harmonic and Isol is the sum of all the harmonic currents)....

You get the gist...
 

Attachments

  • Goods Lift Brake Solenoid Not Operating Correctly solenoid current - EletriciansForums.net
    solenoid current.png
    41.7 KB · Views: 1
The solenoid, being an electromagnetic device, produces a force by the action of the current flowing through its coil. Being a coil wound on a metal former it has both resistance and inductance.

The current through the coil depends then on the waveform of the applied voltage V between A1 and A2. For a continuous unchanging voltage (cc in my attached diagram and in red) the current is only limited by the resistance of the coil R since there is no back emf produced by L.

For a pure alternating sinusoidal waveform (ac and in black) the current throught the coil is limited by the impedance of the coil viz Z = R + jXL or Z= sqrt(Rsq + XLsq); thus if the ac voltage has an rms voltage the same magnitude as the continuous applied voltage the current flowing through the solenoid Iac will be smaller than Icc and decrease further with increasing frequency.

For full wave rectified ac (no smoothing) energising voltage once again the solenoid will present an impedance (not pure resistance) and Ifw will be less than Icc and decrease with frequency.

The addition of a smoothing capacitor will filter out the ripple of the full wave rectified waveform meaning that the applied voltage too becomes more a like continuous unchanging voltage - the current through the solenoid will tend towards the same value as Icc as the ripple reduces since the impedance of the winding tends towards R as the harmonics of the rectified ac are filtered out.

In sum then a coil wound for dc will require a higher ac rms voltage energising voltage to produce the same force since I = V/Z for ac and V/R for pure dc.

As a thought experiment once could imagine an alternating voltage V being full wave rectifed and smoothed perfectly by a great amount of shunt capacitance so that 185V dc was produced as a continuous waveform. Now gradually reduce the shunt capacitance until none is in circuit - the current through the coil will decrease even though the applied ac voltage V of the source remains constant because Z increases. The solenoid become weaker.

(Actually you have to think of the Z of the circuit for each harmonic and Isol is the sum of all the harmonic currents)....

You get the gist...
Thanks, this makes sense
 
What we need to know is if this mysterious rectifier is present, is working, and connected so as to supply this solenoid.
I presume that, being a safety component, the solenoid's 'normal' position is that the brakes are engaged, and that energising the solenoid releases them (or should do).
 
Lift brake solenoids are normally DC, often energised from the control DC supply via contacts on the direction contactors. However the DC voltage does not need to be smooth so the output of a rectifier can be connected directly to the solenoid without a reservoir capacitor. The voltage is not then smooth but the current will be, due to the high inductance of the coil. If you connect a meter on an AC voltage range it might display an AC voltage due to the AC component of the unsmooth DC, the exact reading depending on both the meter and the rectifier circuit.

Energising a DC solenoid with AC will cause reduced operating force, chatter and hum and possibly heating of the magnetic circuit which will not necessarily be laminated. If the solenoid has an anti-parallel suppression diode, connecting AC will either destroy the diode or blow the fuse. Older units have a selenium rec or resistive suppression, which will respectively let out smoke or work fine on AC.

Can you post some pics? I'm passably familiar with older Otis gear.
 
Hi,in connection with the topic,might i suggest the OP ensures any possible future liability risks,in testing or altering this braking system.

Having had many involvements in similar devices,any issue or mishap,at any time in the future,will be firmly dropped in the lap of the last-to-touch.

It usually is not the 12 people hurtling via gravity to doom,in a goods lift they should not have entered....
...it will be the 1" misalignment or slip,which catches a toe or finger,followed by the wait in casualty,watching the waiting room TV,with it's blame hunting brief ad's...

Be 100% sure of two things...

1) The squealing you mention,is not a siezed or failing shaft/coupling,resonance on one or more reeving falls,or a sheaving fault.

2) It's not you who gets the curly finger ?
 
What we need to know is if this mysterious rectifier is present, is working, and connected so as to supply this solenoid.
I presume that, being a safety component, the solenoid's 'normal' position is that the brakes are engaged, and that energising the solenoid releases them (or should do).
Yes, this is exactly how it works. Regarding the rectifier, I have no details on his as the engineer attending site, who I was in discussion, with clearly did not want me involved. The client just asked me to take a quick look because the lift engineers were scratching their heads at the time. I didn't and could not spend a great deal of time investigating. But I'm intrigued on what the problem was and how it was rectified (no pun intended).
 
Lift brake solenoids are normally DC, often energised from the control DC supply via contacts on the direction contactors. However the DC voltage does not need to be smooth so the output of a rectifier can be connected directly to the solenoid without a reservoir capacitor. The voltage is not then smooth but the current will be, due to the high inductance of the coil. If you connect a meter on an AC voltage range it might display an AC voltage due to the AC component of the unsmooth DC, the exact reading depending on both the meter and the rectifier circuit.

Energising a DC solenoid with AC will cause reduced operating force, chatter and hum and possibly heating of the magnetic circuit which will not necessarily be laminated. If the solenoid has an anti-parallel suppression diode, connecting AC will either destroy the diode or blow the fuse. Older units have a selenium rec or resistive suppression, which will respectively let out smoke or work fine on AC.

Can you post some pics? I'm passably familiar with older Otis gear.
Thanks,
I'll see if I can get back in the lift control room and get some pictures next time I'm on site. It would be good to get and understanding of it, no matter how old I get I still enjoy learning!
 
Hi,in connection with the topic,might i suggest the OP ensures any possible future liability risks,in testing or altering this braking system.

Having had many involvements in similar devices,any issue or mishap,at any time in the future,will be firmly dropped in the lap of the last-to-touch.

It usually is not the 12 people hurtling via gravity to doom,in a goods lift they should not have entered....
...it will be the 1" misalignment or slip,which catches a toe or finger,followed by the wait in casualty,watching the waiting room TV,with it's blame hunting brief ad's...

Be 100% sure of two things...

1) The squealing you mention,is not a siezed or failing shaft/coupling,resonance on one or more reeving falls,or a sheaving fault.

2) It's not you who gets the curly finger ?
Thanks for the heads up,

Fortunately I'm not responsible for this repair, basically just an interested party. I wouldn't normally get involved with the control side of lifts as I have no experience at all in this field. Like I state, I was asked to have a quick look and you could clearly see the brake not disengaging properly causing the squeal as it bound on. You could see the armature move back to open the brake shoes but there appeared to be not enough clearance. It appeared as though the return spring was too strong and the armature shaft was not moving fully in position.

Since this brake system had been removed and fully re-furbished, my first question was regarding the adjustment, and the engineer told me that it was adjusted, set and tested as per design spec. Obviously I'm in no position to argue this. The cover was off to the terminals of the solenoid so as they tried the lift and the brake attempted to dis-engage I tested across the terminals a couple of times. This is when I got the 169/170V ac readings. The I.D plate though not clear appears to state 185V dc.

So, with no experience in these matters my assumption is/was that the applied voltage was firstly ac not dc and secondly too low to operate the solenoid as it was designed to do, thus causing the brake to bind on.

The lift is now back in operation, so I assume the problem sorted, though I have no details on what was done to achieve this.
 

Reply to Goods Lift Brake Solenoid Not Operating Correctly in the Industrial Electrician Talk area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock