Discuss RCD protection for PV? in the Solar PV Forum | Solar Panels Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

A

ak492158

Does a PV system have to be RCD protected?

I did a number of PV installations with a very experianced electrician who said that the PV system had to be RCD protected, but I'm not sure. The AC cable will not be burried in a wall and it's not going into a bathroom, or outside, or suppling a socket. Also putting the PV system on a shared RCD could cause problems if the RCD trips and the Solar is still live for a few seconds.
 
sacked a 'very experienced' sparky off a load of jobs we had because of this. he swore blind that under 17th edition ALL circuits had to be RCD protected and insisted that PV could be put on the same RCD as other household circuits. He said he had done loads of PV installs for other local companies. INteresting as his knowledge of the 17th ed means he shouldn't even be doing general electrics, never mind PV!
 
Does a PV system have to be RCD protected?

I did a number of PV installations with a very experianced electrician who said that the PV system had to be RCD protected, but I'm not sure. The AC cable will not be burried in a wall and it's not going into a bathroom, or outside, or suppling a socket. Also putting the PV system on a shared RCD could cause problems if the RCD trips and the Solar is still live for a few seconds.

Yes it should be RCD/RCBO protected (DTI guide) (but there are execptions) but definitely not on a shared RCD.


We firstly try to use a 2 way RCD CCU off a henley block.

Failing that we try to use an RCBO on the non RCD protected side of customers CCU.

An inverter can continue to supply voltage into the grid even after the mcb/rcbo/rcd has tripped which (for what its worth) is why we try to use RCD protection in every instal.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yes it should be RCD/RCBO protected (DTI guide) (but there are execptions) but definitely not on a shared RCD.


We firstly try to use a 2 way RCD CCU off a henley block.

Failing that we try to use an RCBO on the non RCD protected side of customers CCU.

An inverter can continue to supply voltage into the grid even after the mcb/rcbo/rcd has tripped which (for what its worth) is why we try to use RCD protection in every instal.


How can it supply the grid once the mcb has tripped?
 
DTI Guide does not recommend rcd/rcbo, just makes some recommendations about type in those cases where an rcd is required
 
I don't understand the need to fit rcds regardless. I would prefer to do the install knowing that it doesn't require one.
As we generally do an install a day I never ever chase in an inverter feed and in the cases where we have had to run cables through voids within 50mm of the surface of the wall we always use armoured cable. TT systems obviously require them but generally you need to fit a separate consumer unit as most TT systems
around that haven't been changed to pme down our way are seriously old!
 
Because it is allowed up to 5s in most cases to shut down on loss of mains.

(which I know is not supplying the grid, but is energising the installation)

Thanks Brucey baby thats what i meant LOL
 
An inverter supplied from a PV array must preferably be installed in adedicated circuit in which:​

no current-using equipment is connected, andno provision is made for the connection of current-using equipment,andno socket-outlets are permitted.An inverter must not be connected by means of a plug with contactswhich may be live when exposed.Where an electrical installation includes a PV power supply systemwithout at least simple separation between the a.c. side and the d.c.side, an RCD installed to provide fault protection by automaticdisconnection of supply must be type B RCD according to BS EN 60898(IEC 60755, amendment 2).
Ah yes, thanks Bruce,

Sorry i knew it said something about TL inverters.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
we discussed this at length on here before, as my understanding was that transformerless inverters needed RCD protection, but it was pointed out that most transformerless inverters (SMA, FRONIUS etc) have inbuilt protection that meets the need for automatic disconestion that would require the need of an RCD.
 
There is no regulation to my knowledge that requires transformerless inverters to be on an rcd.

However if they are on an rcd for ADS reasons then type b rcd is required by 712.411.3.2.1.2

Except (second para of that reg) if the manufacturer says they are not by design able to feed in dc fault currents then type b not required by the reg.

You could then go on to debate type A or AC by that is not the subject of that reg.

So that's simple then.
 
An inverter supplied from a PV array must preferably be installed in adedicated circuit in which:​

no current-using equipment is connected, andno provision is made for the connection of current-using equipment,andno socket-outlets are permitted.An inverter must not be connected by means of a plug with contactswhich may be live when exposed.Where an electrical installation includes a PV power supply systemwithout at least simple separation between the a.c. side and the d.c.side, an RCD installed to provide fault protection by automaticdisconnection of supply must be type B RCD according to BS EN 60898(IEC 60755, amendment 2).
Ah yes, thanks Bruce,

Sorry i knew it said something about TL inverters.

It kind of depends on your interpretation.
Does this mean an RCD must be fitted to TL inverters, or just that if one is fitted it must be a type B? My interpretation is the latter.
 
It kind of depends on your interpretation.
Does this mean an RCD must be fitted to TL inverters, or just that if one is fitted it must be a type B? My interpretation is the latter.

Transformerless inverters mean they dont have galvanic isolation between ac and dc so i would say that you should provide rcd protection and bond the array for TL inverters
 
You can debate whether you should have an rcd with transformerless and I would be interested in the reasons. I am not sure I know enough about the internals to argue from a position of strength though.

What I can say, I think authoritatively, is that there is no regulation requiring an rcd with transformerless. The requirement in 712.411.3.2.1.2 refers to 'rcd to provide fault protection by ADS' which would apply for:
- TT
- Zs too large at inverter (unlikely for voltage drop reasons on non-TT)
 
The DTI guide as moggy says can sometimes be open to interpretation.

In fact so can the regs LOL

And my misssus come to think of it...........

She says dont touch but i know what she really means :53:

PMSL
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The excerpt from the DTI guide assumes that you are assessing the need for and RCD for ADS. If you do, and IF you do not have galvanic isolation (simple separation) between the DC and AC circuits, then you should choose a Type-B RCD. It is not a definitive "you must use a Type-B RCD for any TL inverter installation". I believe Bruce has it right in his post above. The debate starts from there really as to whether the TL inverter manufacturer's statements regarding the need for a Type-B RCD or not are all-encompassing or not..... the outcome of such debate can have an impact on the general use of Type-B RCDs for all TL inverter installations, regardless of the need for ADS or otherwise.
 

Reply to RCD protection for PV? in the Solar PV Forum | Solar Panels Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock