USA HELLO

Discuss HELLO in the The Welcome Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

We ground everything and just how hard can that be. The USA is a lot more simple than the UK when it’s grounded it’s grounded and I stand by my work if you think we don’t know what we’re doing come on over and show us how

But when it is grounded how do you prove that it is grounded with a low enough resistance?
How do you know that there is no damage to cables which are hidden?
 
But when it is grounded how do you prove that it is grounded with a low enough resistance?
How do you know that there is no damage to cables which are hidden?
I take my meter and measure the incoming neutral wire and rods in the ohms setting and usually it’s less than 1 ohm
[automerge]1568466978[/automerge]
I take my meter and measure the incoming neutral wire and rods in the ohms setting and usually it’s less than 1 ohm
We are talking about really no resistance at all
 
I take my meter and measure the incoming neutral wire and rods in the ohms setting and usually it’s less than 1 ohm
[automerge]1568466978[/automerge]

We are talking about really no resistance at all

How do you measure the rods? Presumably the direct measurement method using another substantial piece of buried metal?

What is the limit of resistance permitted for your grounds in an installation?

For a circuit breaker or fuse to work properly on a fault then the ground must be of low enough resistance.
The higher the resistance of the ground the slower the circuit breaker will react to the fault.
We have rules on how fast we need a circuit breaker to operate, in the UK this is 0.4seconds for final circuits and 5seconds for distribution circuits (there's more to it than this but I'm keeping it simple here)
So we can calculate the maximum ground resistance permitted to achieve the required disconnection time.

From this we can calculate the size of ground needed and also test it after installation to ensure compliance.

You say we are talking about no resistance at all, but that's not true, every conductor has resistance. The resistances are very small, but so are the limits for correct operation of a circuit breaker.
The limits can be well below 1 ohm and so accurate calibrated testers are needed
 
How do you measure the rods? Presumably the direct measurement method using another substantial piece of buried metal?

What is the limit of resistance permitted for your grounds in an installation?

For a circuit breaker or fuse to work properly on a fault then the ground must be of low enough resistance.
The higher the resistance of the ground the slower the circuit breaker will react to the fault.
We have rules on how fast we need a circuit breaker to operate, in the UK this is 0.4seconds for final circuits and 5seconds for distribution circuits (there's more to it than this but I'm keeping it simple here)
So we can calculate the maximum ground resistance permitted to achieve the required disconnection time.

From this we can calculate the size of ground needed and also test it after installation to ensure compliance.

You say we are talking about no resistance at all, but that's not true, every conductor has resistance. The resistances are very small, but so are the limits for correct operation of a circuit breaker.
The limits can be well below 1 ohm and so accurate calibrated testers are needed
Dave it is not letting me post my reply but table 250.102(c)(1) is how we size our grounded conductor we don’t have to run all the test that y’all do. Our house breakers are 10 RMS and they trip less than 1 second. The NEC has done all the calculations that you are talking about. We have to go by the book. Maybe this will post
 
Dave it is not letting me post my reply but table 250.102(c)(1) is how we size our grounded conductor we don’t have to run all the test that y’all do. Our house breakers are 10 RMS and they trip less than 1 second. The NEC has done all the calculations that you are talking about. We have to go by the book. Maybe this will post

What do you mean by 10RMS?

Surely you are taught the theory and science behind the tables in the book? We also have tables for selecting the size of an earth but we also can calculate it instead. The tables often end up with an earth way bigger than it needs to be.
 
Dave it is not letting me post my reply but table 250.102(c)(1) is how we size our grounded conductor we don’t have to run all the test that y’all do. Our house breakers are 10 RMS and they trip less than 1 second. The NEC has done all the calculations that you are talking about. We have to go by the book. Maybe this will post
Dave the US and the UK have different rules and as much as I have read about the way y’all have to do things I’m great full to be in the USA. We have to follow the rules set by the NEC
What do you mean by 10RMS?

Surely you are taught the theory and science behind the tables in the book? We also have tables for selecting the size of an earth but we also can calculate it instead. The tables often end up with an earth way bigger than it needs to be.
RMS is the interruption rating of the breaker
[automerge]1568472930[/automerge]
Dave the US and the UK have different rules and as much as I have read about the way y’all have to do things I’m great full to be in the USA. We have to follow the rules set by the NEC

RMS is the interruption rating of the breaker
You stated that your tables give you a size that in your mind is bigger than you need. I believe that when it comes to grounded conductor I think that it should be the same size as the ungrounded conductors
[automerge]1568473100[/automerge]
Dave the US and the UK have different rules and as much as I have read about the way y’all have to do things I’m great full to be in the USA. We have to follow the rules set by the NEC

RMS is the interruption rating of the breaker
[automerge]1568472930[/automerge]

You stated that your tables give you a size that in your mind is bigger than you need. I believe that when it comes to grounded conductor I think that it should be the same size as the ungrounded conductors
Dave I give up I know you are smarter than me when it comes to the theory of electrical
 
Last edited:
You stated that your tables give you a size that in your mind is bigger than you need. I believe that when it comes to grounded conductor I think that it should be the same size as the ungrounded conductors

It's not bigger in my mind, it is bigger as is proven by science.

Why do you think that it should be the same size? The science doesn't back this up.
 
It's not bigger in my mind, it is bigger as is proven by science.

Why do you think that it should be the same size? The science doesn't back this up.
Harmonics- I believe that eventually the grounded conductor will be the same size as ungrounded conductors. I did not go college like you and sometimes the theory is over my head. Why are you pressing this matter so much, you win you are smarter than me
 
Harmonics- I believe that eventually the grounded conductor will be the same size as ungrounded conductors. I did not go college like you and sometimes the theory is over my head. Why are you pressing this matter so much, you win you are smarter than me

I'm not pressing the matter, just trying to discuss it.

Now I'm getting confused, you moved from ground to grounded which I understand to be two different things in the USA?

I'm talking about earth wires (ground) where the required size is calculated.

I thought that in the USA grounded conductor is what we call the neutral conductor?
 
Harmonics- I believe that eventually the grounded conductor will be the same size as ungrounded conductors. I did not go college like you and sometimes the theory is over my head. Why are you pressing this matter so much, you win you are smarter than me
We have gone way off topic of the original thread, which I would get in trouble w
I'm not pressing the matter, just trying to discuss it.

Now I'm getting confused, you moved from ground to grounded which I understand to be two different things in the USA?

I'm talking about earth wires (ground) where the required size is calculated.

I thought that in the USA grounded conductor is what we call the neutral conductor?
You are right the grounded conductor is what we are talking about not the grounding conductor
[automerge]1568474240[/automerge]
I'm not pressing the matter, just trying to discuss it.

Now I'm getting confused, you moved from ground to grounded which I understand to be two different things in the USA?

I'm talking about earth wires (ground) where the required size is calculated.

I thought that in the USA grounded conductor is what we call the neutral conductor?
I read this whole thread today and I don’t see where I stated grounding instead of grounded
[automerge]1568474720[/automerge]
We have gone way off topic of the original thread, which I would get in trouble w

You are right the grounded conductor is what we are talking about not the grounding conductor
[automerge]1568474240[/automerge]

I read this whole thread today and I don’t see where I stated grounding instead of grounded
I feel like lm in school again and this is making me look bad to all the others in this forum
 
Last edited:
You are right the grounded conductor is what we are talking about not the grounding conductor

I read this whole thread today and I don’t see where I stated grounding instead of grounded

Then I apologise as I may have confused the issue completely.
Its hard to get used to your use of grounded and grounding as the names for two different conductors. Especially when you talk about connecting the grounded conductor to earth rods.
 
Then I apologise as I may have confused the issue completely.
Its hard to get used to your use of grounded and grounding as the names for two different conductors. Especially when you talk about connecting the grounded conductor to earth rods.
Dave I have a 9th grade education and I took ac-dc theory but most of it was over my head. I’ve got the upmost respect for you and your knowledge of the electrical system. I guess the way we do things could be confusing but I know my job and it seems like you are going back to Tesla days which I get lost
[automerge]1568481721[/automerge]
Dave the US and the UK have different rules and as much as I have read about the way y’all have to do things I’m great full to be in the USA. We have to follow the rules set by the NEC

RMS is the interruption rating of the breaker
[automerge]1568472930[/automerge]

You stated that your tables give you a size that in your mind is bigger than you need. I believe that when it comes to grounded conductor I think that it should be the same size as the ungrounded conductors
Dave I give up I know you are smarter than me when it comes to the theory of electrical
Dave the US and the UK have different rules and as much as I have read about the way y’all have to do things I’m great full to be in the USA. We have to follow the rules set by the NEC

RMS is the interruption rating of the breaker
[automerge]1568472930[/automerge]

You stated that your tables give you a size that in your mind is bigger than you need. I believe that when it comes to grounded conductor I think that it should be the same size as the ungrounded conductors
[automerge]1568473100[/automerge]

Dave I give up I know you are smarter than me when it comes to the theory of electrical
Dave I misquoted about the 10 RMS it should be 10k RMS interrupting rating
 
Last edited:

Reply to HELLO in the The Welcome Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock