Two cables connected to mcb

[Darkwood]

Guys, there is clearly a conflict of opinions here which leads to hopefully a good debate and what the forum is about, but can we refrain from mocking comments and pictures, let's keep the discussion to a respectable level, mocking members be it seasoned or new is only going to promote replies that derail the thread and rubs everyone up the wrong way.

I would appreciate it if we all keep the debate on a professional and mature level and regardless who is right or wrong we refrain from lowering the tone with personal/character attacks on members.

Thanyou.

 

[DPG]

Is there an echo?

 

[Darkwood]

Sorry guys..not sure what happened there, software glitch posted my reply about 10times :O

 

[Anders]

Reg 999.888.777.666.555.444.333.222.111- common sense. If you are a grown up and a practising electrician sometimes you have to make a judgement call. Dearest customer- here is my the reason for my C3 based on guidelines (i.e. BS7671) and my experience. I have given this a C3 code because of an isolation issue. The safety device is protecting the cable and humans/animals etc fire and electrocution. However, an improvement could be made by providing individual switching for these two circuits thus limiting inconvenience during a fault or maintenance. This is why we wire upstairs sockets/downtairs lights etc, to limit inconvenience. Be try best you can be, give the customer the option to have the safest and best setup that you can provide, but ultimately it's their decision. Explain that there are no spare ways so a new board would need to be fitted and this is how much it would cost. 90% of this particular topic is common sense, 10% common sense. Sometimes it's the other way round, most of the time it's somewhere in between- never forget that my pedigree chums!

 

[Cadgey123]

Reg 999.888.777.666.555.444.333.222.111- common sense. If you are a grown up and a practising electrician sometimes you have to make a judgement call. Dearest customer- here is my the reason for my C3 based on guidelines (i.e. BS7671) and my experience. I have given this a C3 code because of an isolation issue. The safety device is protecting the cable and humans/animals etc fire and electrocution. However, an improvement could be made by providing individual switching for these two circuits thus limiting inconvenience during a fault or maintenance. This is why we wire upstairs sockets/downtairs lights etc, to limit inconvenience. Be try best you can be, give the customer the option to have the safest and best setup that you can provide, but ultimately it's their decision. Explain that there are no spare ways so a new board would need to be fitted and this is how much it would cost. 90% of this particular topic is common sense, 10% common sense. Sometimes it's the other way round, most of the time it's somewhere in between- never forget that my pedigree chums!

But it's one circuit though....... isolate from the 1 MCB

 

[Anders]

But it's one circuit though....... isolate from the 1 MCB[/QUOTE
IMHO and without having the advantage of seeing the job I would suspect the sockets/lights are in different areas of the building. Otherwise, why not extend? I.e. The last fitting or socket on the first radial is a long way from the next. If the board is closer to the next fitting/socket, start from there again. There may also be access issues so yes, start a new radial. But it could possibly inconvenience the customer when you need to isolate and you lose both radials. So the existing installation is safe and works fine, but I can make it better.

 

[wackyracer]

I've not read all the posts, but surely the fact that the cables are in one MCB makes it one circuit by definition. If a house was wired with an upstairs lighting circuit, and a downstairs lighting circuit, if both legs go to 1 MCB it then has one lighting circuit. Maybe I'm wrong but that's how I interpret it.

 

[delano]

Sounds a load of bs to me.

Need more information

And you could have 10 cables in a mcb ..,

I wouldn't advise anyone to install 10 load conductors into a single mcb.

 

[Lumie]

@westward10 if you don't know the definition of a circuit are you sure you should be doing EICR's?

 

[westward10]

@westward10 if you don't know the definition of a circuit are you sure you should be doing EICR's?

I need help getting off the floor after that