Discuss Why wouldn't a volt pen pick up voltage? in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

Reaction score
186
Well I'm confused ! 🤔

Just went to isolate some kind of antique shower pump thingy in a bathroom for a plumber mate but the switch to it in the bathroom was painted over several times so I couldn't get my voltage tester with probes on it. So I used my non touch volt pen on the switch and the cable going into the switch which showed 230v power.

I isolated what I suspected was the power supply in the basement - an old wylex isolator. Tested the bathroom switch again with my volt pen and 0 volts - Fair enough. That would suggest the isolator was the right call.

Thing is though, When I tried my volt pen at the cable at the isolator (as a whole and also each individual conductor in the isolator) I got no voltage displaying on my pen - with the isolator energised or not. I checked the fuse in the isolator which is fine.
I retried my voltage pen on the switch in the bathroom with the isolator energised / not energised, with the same results.

SO, why am getting a reading with my voltage pen from the bathroom switch and cable at the bathroom switch, but not getting a reading at the isolator outgoing cable??

I'm going to have to return when I have more time to smash open the switch and do more substantial tests cos I like this plumber but I'm still at a loss on why this be...

Why wouldn't a volt pen pick up voltage? IMG_20220616_171834 - EletriciansForums.net
 
Last edited:
Well I'm confused ! 🤔

Just went to isolate some kind of antique shower pump thingy in a bathroom for a plumber mate but the switch to it in the bathroom was painted over several times so I couldn't get my voltage tester with probes on it. So I used my non touch volt pen which showed 230v power.
Isolated what I suspected was the power supply in the basement - an old wylex isolator. Tested the bathroom switch again with my volt pen - 0v. Fair enough. That would suggest the isolator was the right call.
Thing is though, When I tried my volt pen on the cable (as a whole and also each individual conductor in the isolator - again, no test points for my voltage tester with probes) and I got no voltage displaying on my pen - with the isolator energised or not. I checked the fuse in the isolator which is fine.
I retried my voltage pen on the switch in the bathroom with it energised / not energised, with the same results.

So why am I not getting a reading from my voltage pen at the isolator??

I'm going to have to return when I have more time to smash open the switch and do more substantial tests cos I like this plumber but I'm still at a loss on why this be...

View attachment 98641

I may not have fully understood because I've had a few beers, but cross polarity at source?
 
They do not work with any sort of shielded cable such as FP200, SWA, MICC etc.
They are best used with these types of cables at the very ends where the outer insulation has been stripped off

You might get one to work on a FCU from the outside by the fuse holder for example or even the outside of a socket but if the accessory has been painted then it's another layer for it to go through (or not)

Voltage pens should never be relied on at all and especially to test for dead
 
Surely

Surely I'd still have got a reading from the cable though even with reverse polarity. Point is I was getting a reading at the terminal but not the source. I need a beer now lol.

Probably a fair point yes.

Bottle of St Peter's Cream Stout about to be opened
 
They can be highly unreliable.

The must work on induction or magnetic fields, and the slightest thing could cause interference.

Some times they pick up power at a switch a good foot away from the wall. Take the switch off the wall and stick the tip in, and you can’t get a thing.

I’ve had a whole brick wall light up my stick, on both sides… all down to a cooker hood fixing screw being inbetween the neutral and earth of the supply cable. (Running diagonally up to the hood)
 
So that visible red wire in the fused switch was not activating a voltage pen? As much as I agree that they are hit and miss, and vary in detection quality, I'm a bit surprised.
I'd remove the fuse and fuse carrier and use a 2-pole on it to be sure it's actually energised.

Other than that you have had indication of voltage present and no voltage present in the bathroom. While it seems highly likely you have correctly found the right isolator I wouldn't base the entire conclusion on tests from a non contact tester.
Are there any terminals accessible at the shower pump?
 
So that visible red wire in the fused switch was not activating a voltage pen? As much as I agree that they are hit and miss, and vary in detection quality, I'm a bit surprised.
I'd remove the fuse and fuse carrier and use a 2-pole on it to be sure it's actually energised.

Other than that you have had indication of voltage present and no voltage present in the bathroom. While it seems highly likely you have correctly found the right isolator I wouldn't base the entire conclusion on tests from a non contact tester.
Are there any terminals accessible at the shower pump?
That's just it. I'm surprised also. the tails going into the isolator were lighting up my pen no problem. It's just the cable coming out that doesn't and I can't understand why.
The switch in the bathroom was "sealed" permanently off by paint so I will have to break the switch open with a hammer (which I've left at another job 😳) to test it properly.
It was a last minute job which I was hoping to quickly do in passing at 5pm as a favour cos I'm booked up but didn't want to start construction work at that time of the evening. I will have to go back to ensure it's deenergised I know but just don't understand why I wasn't getting a reading coming out of the isolator. Especially as I was getting readings from the tails going in
 
What is that between the fuse & switch sticking out? Is it some sort of fail-safe which isolates when cover removed?

When you go back can you remove fuse/cover to expose terminals? I'm sure the problem is probably obvious but you just cannot see it in current state
mechanical interlock. cannot flick the switch on unless cover is in place.... or you push it in with your finger
 
It's a Memspan switchfuse, they were very popular in the 50s & 60s. IIRC Memspan was the metal version and Memspel was the all-insulated one. Or was it the other way round? As above the switch is interlocked with the cover. The slot in the cover for the switch lever is narrower towards the on position which prevents the user removing it with the switch on. Then, once the cover is off, the interlock plunger springs out and should prevent the switch being turned on unless it is manually held in.

Volt sticks detect electric fields. The probe contains a piece of metal that forms one plate of a capacitor, the other plate is the target you are sensing and / or anything else conductive around it. The same thing happens at the body of the stick, the innards are one plate and whatever surrounds it (typically your hand) is another. Between the two is a voltage sensing circuit with a such a high input resistance that just a few picofarads of capacitance between the parts under test and the probe tip will pass enough current at 50Hz to trigger it.

The art and skill of using a stick comes from understanding how electric fields and potential gradients behave in space, and how they are modified by the proximity of other conductors and conductive objects. If you can visualise these, you can get much more out of a stick. People often voice an opinion that they are unreliable and unpredictable, but most of the time what that means is that the stick is behaving in a way they cannot account for, because they don't have a clear mental picture of the electric field that the stick is detecting.

Naturally these extra variables make the stick an unsuitable tool for testing for dead. Not because the stick is unreliable or unpredictable in itself, rather that due to its complex behaviour there are too many ways to accidentally misread its indications, as with a multimeter. I have been using the same volt stick for the best part of 20 years and it has never done anything unexpected or that didn't agree with other tests. Even when on one occasion (in Russia) it was lighting when probing a good neutral, more so than when probing an energised line, there was a perfectly rational explanation. Answers to that one on a postcard.
 
Last edited:
Even when on one occasion (in Russia) it was lighting when probing a good neutral, more so than when probing an energised line, there was a perfectly rational explanation. Answers to that one on a postcard.
My best guess: You, as the user, were somehow more closely coupled to line potential than earth potential? Perhaps standing over cables such as those to light switches, whilst a long way from anything 'earthy'?
 
Correct in principle but the cause was rather more blatant. I was standing next to the metal cabinet of a display fridge that was fully live at 220V to earth. It had been temporarily installed in a conference centre in a room with a wooden floor, far enough away from any radiators etc that no-one had got a shock off it yet. This was nearly 30 years ago and TBH I cannot now remember the exact cause of it being live. It was something like being plugged into an extension lead with two white cores that had been TN-C'd i.e. appliance earth and neutral commoned to one of the cores, but then connected to the supply the wrong way round so that the appliance earth was actually connected to the line.

Needless to say the behaviour of the voltstick made me immediately wary of my surroundings and the problem with the fridge was not far to seek.
 
Last edited:

Reply to Why wouldn't a volt pen pick up voltage? in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock