Discuss How to shield a live wire at 240V ? in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

_q12x_

DIY
Reaction score
212
I have a electronic board with leds (made by me) that is driving a relay. When that relay is closing it’s contacts, is actually switching the 240V for the light bulb switch in my room. This board is quite long, like 50cm (half a meter). The relay is in the left corner, and the live wires from it goes in behind the board to the hole in the wall for the mains switch. I also have a mild steel sheet behind my board that is grounded. It is shielding the interference of the 50Hz from the live wires from the wall to my sensitive circuit. But even If I have this grounded metal shield behind my board, the live wires from the relay are still affecting my entire circuit board, keeping it ON all the time. If I am disconecting the live wires from the relay, the board is functioning very well. Another IF, is if I disconnect the ground from the metal shield, the circuit board goes nuts. So the shield is doing it's job fine, but only for the live wires inside the wall !!! But not for the wires from the relay to the live switch.
- I want a way to shield these wires !
Thank you !
 
could you fit the relay in the switch box so it's behind the sheet metal shield?
 
There seems to be a problem with your electronic design that is making the circuit too sensitive to interference. Let's see the circuit.

Also, you give your location as New York but speak of 240V 50Hz lighting. Where are you?
 
could you fit the relay in the switch box so it's behind the sheet metal shield?
@telectrix - Thank you for your good answer!
Yes, that is my plan as well. But until I will make this operation, I was thinking maybe I can shield those wires, with all the components on my board as they are now, without any other modification. I will modify it in the end, exactly as you say, but... I wanted a more convenient way.

There seems to be a problem with your electronic design that is making the circuit too sensitive to interference. Let's see the circuit.

Also, you give your location as New York but speak of 240V 50Hz lighting. Where are you?
- Thank you. Yes, you guessed right. The board contains a presence sensing module, meaning, when my hand is in vicinity to that module, it will output high +5V to the next module. It is very sensitive module indeed. And without the metal shield behind it, the entire board will just stay ON all the time, having erroneous behavior. Exactly because of this sensibility of it. And my guess is that 50Hz from the wall wires are not interfering with only the sensing module, but with the entire circuit board, which is quite large and spread. And yes, I like New York but im in Europe.

So tell me straight. Those wires can not be shielded at all ? I am discussing this problem on other forum but for electronics and not electrical like this one here and they got silent about this part. So I figure out to ask more around.
Thank you so much for the direct answers so far !
 
Tel has the right answer. Put the relay in a box, separate it from the main PCB and just run the DC coil circuit to the box. Ensure that the 230V AC and ELV DC circuits are properly insulated from one another, so that in the event of accidental damage, the DC circuit is not likely to become live. If you are making this part of your electrical installation, there are constructional standards that you should adhere to, in order not to invalidate the electrical installation certificate on your house.

But, as I said earlier, an electronic device that doesn't work correctly near ordinary domestic power cables is not a practical device because that's a very severe limitation on its usage envelope, like a phone that doesn't work in the dark or an electric toothbrush that must not be used in the bathroom. A significant amount of R&D is often needed to overcome issues of this kind, over and above what is needed to make it carry out its basic functions.
 
So tell me straight. Those wires can not be shielded at all ? I am discussing this problem on other forum but for electronics and not electrical like this one here and they got silent about this part.
You can get shielded power cables, examples include SWA (steel wired armour) and Flexishield or similar cables to BS 8436 (UK standard) or IS 273 (Republic of Ireland standard). But they are not commonly used for indoor wiring.

As Lucian explained above, you have to design something to work in the typical environment it will be used. Working is a restricted environment is fine for laboratory and other specialised cases when you can arrange it, but not as a general product for home use.
 
You can get shielded power cables, examples include SWA (steel wired armour) and Flexishield or similar cables to BS 8436 (UK standard) or IS 273 (Republic of Ireland standard). But they are not commonly used for indoor wiring.
Then... can you explain why the metal shield is shielding the live wires in the wall and not the ones outside the wall? By the way, the wall wires are thick and my outside wires are thin in diameter. Probably it will be the same intensity of the field on both. I imagine. I really don't know.
As Lucian explained above, you have to design something to work in the typical environment it will be used. Working is a restricted environment is fine for laboratory and other specialised cases when you can arrange it, but not as a general product for home use.
Oh, this is just a personal project. Not a public or commercial one. Don't worry. It's destination is only to my room use. And is very experimental as well, with exposed circuits and components. I would not trust to mount it on other places than mine. Haha. But is a good point you bring and and a fear for "some" out there doing too weird things.Interesting indeed.
 
You can get shielded power cables, examples include SWA (steel wired armour) and Flexishield or similar cables to BS 8436 (UK standard) or IS 273 (Republic of Ireland standard). But they are not commonly used for indoor wiring.
Excellent answer ! I mean I know the general term of coaxial, triaxial, and another 2. But that is just theory that I happen to read about in my research. And actually plan to shield my cable in a very short time, just as a test. Just to see if it will affect in any way. It will be awesome to tell me now, before doing anything if its worth to try or not.
 
You can use a shielded cable for the power but that is not dealing with the root cause of the problem. It's a kludge like attaching a light to the phone that won't work in the dark.

If you show the circuit, we might be able to suggest some tweaks.
 
Excellent answer ! I mean I know the general term of coaxial, triaxial, and another 2. But that is just theory that I happen to read about in my research. And actually plan to shield my cable in a very short time, just as a test. Just to see if it will affect in any way. It will be awesome to tell me now, before doing anything if its worth to try or not.
I see you are down as NY in the USA, their electrical codes are very different to ours (UK) so I have no idea if they permit the equivalent of Flexishield for power.

Here it is used for indoor wiring where you can't have RCD protection for any reason, but it might get damaged (e.g. DIY person putting a nail through it). It has aluminium foil and a drain wire for earth designed to open a typical MCB safely on fault current. It also gets used a lot on farms as rats seem not to like chewing it and safer for livestock. They also make a cat-urine flavoured version to further deter rodent damage:

@Megawatt might have ideas on what it allowable for shielded style wiring in the USA. I think the USA goes in for a lot more conduit systems (EMT) and that provide similar benefits to Flexishield as well as higher fire protection, but with a much higher installation skill/cost.
 
I really tried my best to keep it simple.
But if you insist, yes I can show you the circuit, no problem, but im afraid it will add more unnecessary problems to you to resolve (that are already tested and solved).
This circuit is on my deviantart account.
Click on the image to zoom in. It is at full rezolution so you will be able to see the tiniest text on it.
Link here: Q20201219 Led Wings Projekt Circuit by q12a on DeviantArt - https://www.deviantart.com/q12a/art/Q20201219-Led-Wings-Projekt-Circuit-864540519
 
Last edited:
You can get shielded power cables, examples include SWA (steel wired armour) and Flexishield or similar cables to BS 8436 (UK standard) or IS 273 (Republic of Ireland standard). But they are not commonly used for indoor wiring.
Give me more examples or names like these. I dont know them.
My suggestion is to also give me the names for the most powerful Electric field shielded cables there are. I probably dont have the money to buy them but is a good introduction for me, and a bit of practice to you. In time is fine, if you cant right now. I am very patient.
Thank you for the formidable answers so far. I really like them.
 
It seems you are relying on that unscreend supply noise to trigger it when you move close to the antenna!

Also that input MOSFET has little protection so a bit too much charge and you can blow the gate insulator. Having a 10V zener to 0V might be enough to protect it.

Why not have adjustable sensitivity. You could replace the lower 10K off the MOSFET (and some arrangement for driving the LM3914) with a potentiometer so you can set what it needs to trigger?
 
It seems you are relying on that unscreend supply noise to trigger it when you move close to the antenna!

Also that input MOSFET has little protection so a bit too much charge and you can blow the gate insulator. Having a 10V zener to 0V might be enough to protect it.

Why not have adjustable sensitivity. You could replace the lower 10K off the MOSFET (and some arrangement for driving the LM3914) with a potentiometer so you can set what it needs to trigger?
Where to put the zenner more precisely? (A zener must have a resistor in series for its protection as well). Can you be kind and make a screenshot on the area of the circuit and draw over it for me, please? Thank you. I really like the protection idea.
I can change little things, but not much. I will try the best I can to change anything I can.
But you see how quickly you defocused from the main issue ? I get that you are refering to the circuit sensitivity... but right now it is a very strong interference I have to keep it out. Not sensitivity. It is working excelent on my table, now I manage it to make it work on my wall as well, but now this problem with wires.
I plan to shield the wires.
Can you give me some advice on properly shield them? Thank you ! I also have an idea, using grounded aluminium foil and a grounded wire inside. Also twisting the the wires I see it is more efficient for shielding. But this is all I got so far.
 
it is a very strong interference I have to keep it out.

No, it's just normal house wiring. My electronics lab has unshielded power cables all around it, there is a 3-phase electrical panel with unshielded cables at the end of my workbench and transformers underneath it, there are variable-speed inverter drives in the next room, but everything here works perfectly including studio-grade analogue audio equipment with its covers off.

Personally I would redesign the detector to work a different way, there are lots of options. But at least do something about that floating gate. The diode rectifies stray capacitively coupled noise and charges the gate. But then what? How does the gate discharge? Just leakage? That will vary with temperature and humidity. The Fostex G24S was a 24-track 1" tape deck that had some JFET gates connected directly to diodes, in the monitoring signal switching. These were still showing up as a fault some 30 years after the unit was launched.

Also twisting the the wires I see it is more efficient for shielding.

It's helpful against against electromagnetic coupling, won't make much difference to electrostatic coupling on a screened cable.
 
I have a electronic board with leds (made by me) that is driving a relay. When that relay is closing it’s contacts, is actually switching the 240V for the light bulb switch in my room. This board is quite long, like 50cm (half a meter). The relay is in the left corner, and the live wires from it goes in behind the board to the hole in the wall for the mains switch. I also have a mild steel sheet behind my board that is grounded. It is shielding the interference of the 50Hz from the live wires from the wall to my sensitive circuit. But even If I have this grounded metal shield behind my board, the live wires from the relay are still affecting my entire circuit board, keeping it ON all the time. If I am disconecting the live wires from the relay, the board is functioning very well. Another IF, is if I disconnect the ground from the metal shield, the circuit board goes nuts. So the shield is doing it's job fine, but only for the live wires inside the wall !!! But not for the wires from the relay to the live switch.
- I want a way to shield these wires !
Thank you !
Have you tried plenum rated cables
 
New posts

Reply to How to shield a live wire at 240V ? in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock