High Zs readings | on ElectriciansForums

Discuss High Zs readings in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

S

Spaced

Hi everyone

Apologies if this is a dim question.... I have just installed an exterior dusk till dawn lamp at home and all
was fine until I carried out the Zs test. I have a TN-S system with a Ze of 0.66ohms. The R1+R2 reading at the lamp was 0.58ohms. My Zs reading is however 2.88ohms. I tested both the ground floor ring circuit along with the 6mm cooker outlet and found readings similar to the lamp. I tested Zs pre & post the RCD and found the reading to be 2 ohms higher. Testing across the RCD there is no resistance across the live terminals or the neutrals. The pre RCD test was carried out using the Hi loop setting on my Megger 1553
and the post RCD was done using the no trip loop function. Could this be an anomaly with my meter or the RCD ( Hager 63A ) or a fault with the RCD itself perhaps? Any feed back will be gratefully received. Thanks.
 
'No trip' loop testing is not as accurate as a proper loop test, this is why it should only ever be used when absolutely necessary.
Use the alternative Zs test method and see what that gives you. You could also assess the resistance of the RCD under load from the volt drop across it.
 
Hi everyone

Apologies if this is a dim question.... I have just installed an exterior dusk till dawn lamp at home and all
was fine until I carried out the Zs test. I have a TN-S system with a Ze of 0.66ohms. The R1+R2 reading at the lamp was 0.58ohms. My Zs reading is however 2.88ohms. I tested both the ground floor ring circuit along with the 6mm cooker outlet and found readings similar to the lamp. I tested Zs pre & post the RCD and found the reading to be 2 ohms higher. Testing across the RCD there is no resistance across the live terminals or the neutrals. The pre RCD test was carried out using the Hi loop setting on my Megger 1553
and the post RCD was done using the no trip loop function. Could this be an anomaly with my meter or the RCD ( Hager 63A ) or a fault with the RCD itself perhaps? Any feed back will be gratefully received. Thanks.

I have had similar and found the issue to be the RCD. Swapped for a new one and got excellent results again even on the low current no trip loop setting.

It is easy enough to bypass the RCD to check the Zs (on Hi Loop) from the light fitting before you decide if it needs replacing.
 
I have had similar and found the issue to be the RCD. Swapped for a new one and got excellent results again even on the low current no trip loop setting.

It is easy enough to bypass the RCD to check the Zs (on Hi Loop) from the light fitting before you decide if it needs replacing.
no need to test though is there? he got a R1+R2 of 0.68 on the circuit and a ze of 0.6

faulty rcd will be the problem in this case
 
no need to test though is there? he got a R1+R2 of 0.68 on the circuit and a ze of 0.6

faulty rcd will be the problem in this case

Yep, he got decent Ze and r1r2 results. He stated that he got no/negligible resistance across the RCD also though. So it could possibly be due to the no trip loop test could it not.

If nothing else bypassing the RCD and doing a Hi Loop will help the OP to clarify in their own head what is going on IMO.

To the OP, are the RFC and cooker on the same RCD?
 
Last edited:
no need to test though is there? he got a R1+R2 of 0.68 on the circuit and a ze of 0.6

faulty rcd will be the problem in this case

He needs to test to confirm the diagnosis of a faulty RCD, you cannot just assume based on the symptoms described. There could be other reasons for the discrepancy, a poor connection will show up differently in a Zs test to a continuity test.

Making assumptions and changing parts without first proving that they are faulty shows a lack of ability or understanding, this is why most plumbers use this method of attempting to fix things.
 
Yep, he got decent Ze and r1r2 results. He stated that he got no/negligible resistance across the RCD also though. So it could possibly be due to the no trip loop test could it not.

If nothing else bypassing the RCD and doing a Hi Loop will help the OP to clarify in their own head what is going on IMO.

To the OP, are the RFC and cooker on the same RCD?

The consumer unit has one RCD with 4 circuits and a high integrity side with only 2 lighting circuits attached. (I will upgrade these to RCBO's when I get a moment)
I have loosened & re-tightened all terminals in the board also just in case a high resistance in the neutral
may have been causing problems for the no trip loop test but to no avail.

Thanks again for everyone's kind feedback.
 
He needs to test to confirm the diagnosis of a faulty RCD, you cannot just assume based on the symptoms described. There could be other reasons for the discrepancy, a poor connection will show up differently in a Zs test to a continuity test.

Making assumptions and changing parts without first proving that they are faulty shows a lack of ability or understanding, this is why most plumbers use this method of attempting to fix things.
did i say replace rcd? no i was implying that he either swap it for an mcb or link it out and try the test again.

some devices especially overloads will cause the zs to skyrocket.

for example we were doing a boiler house in singles, overloads were in the panel.

ze ar board was within spec say 0.6 and the r1+r2 was say 0.3. the zs at the motor was say 16.

it might be a loose neutrel on the feed side though (personally i would test this using Rn+R2 at board
 
Last edited:
The consumer unit has one RCD with 4 circuits and a high integrity side with only 2 lighting circuits attached. (I will upgrade these to RCBO's when I get a moment)
I have loosened & re-tightened all terminals in the board also just in case a high resistance in the neutral
may have been causing problems for the no trip loop test but to no avail.

Thanks again for everyone's kind feedback.

Firstly I would check my meter on a non RCD protected circuit using both high and no trip Zs settings and compare readings. If the readings are way off the mark then I would get my meter calibrated. If both of the readings are similar then I would do the alternative high method Zs test to prove the wiring and if this reading is ok then you have a high resistance across your RCD.
 
did i say replace rcd? no i was implying that he either swap it for an mcb or link it out and try the test again.

some devices especially overloads will cause the zs to skyrocket.

for example we were doing a boiler house in singles, overloads were in the panel.

ze ar board was within spec say 0.6 and the r1+r2 was say 0.3. the zs at the motor was say 16.

it might be a loose neutrel on the feed side though (personally i would test this using Rn+R2 at board

You said categorically that a faulty RCD will be the problem, it's there in black and white in the quote
 
You said categorically that a faulty RCD will be the problem, it's there in black and white in the quote
i didnt say replace it though, just that its one of the first things i would check. if all the dead tests R1,R2 and Rn look ok and the ze is reading ok then i would link out the rcd. it didn't trip the rcd so the supply is balenced. rcd's work on balence afterall.


by no need to test i was implying through the rcd.

he did say later that he was getting a lot higher on the load side of the rcd compared with the supply side
 
Last edited:
I know low current no trip loop testing can throw up anomalies. But more often than not when testing Zs on a non RCD protected cct I have found both Hi Loop and No Trip give close readings. I often do this to see if there is much difference. Occasionally I get a bigish reading through No Trip. Meter I use is a 1552.
 

Reply to High Zs readings in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar threads

Yes, probably overthinkig, thanks.
Replies
6
Views
563
Good thinking - the other side of that is my garage and also where the gas comes in so probably quite a tidy solution if it comes to it!
2
Replies
22
Views
1K

Recommended Sponsor News

Quickwire Now Sponsor ElectriciansForums.net

I am sure you will join me in welcoming our newest sponsors of ElectriciansForums.net - Quickwire! They have decided to join us after seeing you guys discussing their products here. Now we have an expert on board that you can chat to @Quickwire-Sam who will be happy to answer your queries!

[ElectriciansForums.net] Quickwire Now Sponsor ElectriciansForums.net


@Quickwire-Sam said "At Quickwire, we're all about speed, safety, and reliability. We're a family-run business, and every Quickwire connector is proudly made right here in the UK, ensuring noticeable quality. In short, Quickwire is the fastest connection method on the market. Whether you're an experienced electrician or a DIY enthusiast, Quickwire makes electrical connections ridiculously quick and easy. We're passionate about blending British craftsmanship with innovation. If you have any questions or if there's any way we can help, please just ask me!"

Exclusive Forum Offer! Free euro 2024 wall chart for first 10 responses!

Hi everyone,

We have 10 exclusive Uheat EURO 2024 Wallcharts to giveaway for Electricians Forum Members! The first 10 people to reply YES to this thread - I will message and get them sent out to you just in time for this years tournament! GO GO GO

PCBWay Now Sponsor ElectriciansForums.net!!

I hope you will all join me in welcoming our newest sponsor to the forum PCBWay! You can contact their friendly people by sending a message to @PCBWay who will be happy to answer your queries.

Welcome to the community and thanks for your sponsorship!

[ElectriciansForums.net] PCBWay Now Sponsor ElectriciansForums.net!!

PCBWay provides services including PCB Prototype and batch Production, PCB Assembly (SMT), 3D Printing, CNC Machining, PCB Design, Electronics Modules Selling, etc. We are committed to meeting the needs of global makers from different industries in terms of quality, delivery, cost-effectiveness, and any other demanding requests in electronics.

[ElectriciansForums.net] PCBWay Now Sponsor ElectriciansForums.net!!

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top