Discuss How to shield a live wire at 240V ? in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

Have you tried plenum rated cables
No and this is the first time I am hearing about them. I just look over some explanations about this plenum cable and from what i understand, the only difference between plenum and non-plenum is the fire hazard non-plenum are. So plenum is the same cable but with a self-extinguishing plastic/isolation cover. Its more about safety with them. But nothing about shielding. So it is not really helping me in my case here. Thank you for mentioning them, I learned something new.
 
Personally I would redesign the detector to work a different way, there are lots of options.
Give me all the options you can think of. As many as possible; all of them.
(i also have a backup plan for the sensing circuit as well, but I leave it as the very last alternative, in case everything else fails).
Thank you !
 
I don't have time to list all the options. I don't mind giving a few suggestions.

Idea #1. Reflective optical proximity detector with built-in synchronous demodulation e.g. Sharp IS471. Package contains an IR photodiode that is aimed at the detection area. A separate IR LED is also aimed at the detection area and connected to the LED output pin on the IS471. When an IR-reflective object enters the area it reflects pulses from the LED back to the photodiode, which enables the output. The key is in the synchronous demodulation, which rejects even strong IR interference e.g. from room lighting and hot objects, only responding when its own LED pulses are reflected. Obviously you can set the sensitivity by the LED current, beam angle etc.

Advantages - immune to electrical interference. Small and cheap. Easy to fine-tune response.
Disadvantages - Sensitivity depends on IR reflectivity of target. Might not work in direct sunlight.
 
Please help !
Another update, this time i made a very short video (2min) where I present the problem.
I inserted the 3'd relay inside the switch socket and I command it with 5V from the 2'd relay.
But the 2'd relay is vibrating like crazy when I power the board.

After that,
I tested it on my working bench and is doing the same. So, no mains interference at all. It is not influenced by the live wires this time.
If I disconnect the 3'd relay from circuit, everything works fine.
If I put 5V on the 3'd relay, is working fine.
My PSU is showing me 1A , sign that something is in short. But Nothing is in short. It behaves as is in short. Only when I connect that 3'd relay. It is weird as hell. I checked for short with my multimeter and nothing is in short. But once I power it up, it goes to 1A straight.
Actually I tested again and is not rising to 1A but to 1.44A ! Way over my custom limit that I set on my PSU . Very-very strange.
 
It was a logical error. Im too tired of it probably.
I solved the problem. It was a short after all, but a logical one. Eh... stuff happens.
 
-q12x- : good afternoon. What a nice little project. If you’d like I will try to help you produce a working design. What knowledge do you have of semiconductor electronic circuitry using bjts and fets? Or are you copying designs ( no shame in that) available on the internet?

To help me and you answer this question tell me what kind of transistor is the 2N7002? google and study its data sheet.

is it an enhancement or a depletion mosfet? What do these mean?

is it a p channel or an n channel?

which way around are it’s drain and source connected to the positive and negative rails of the dc supply?

is the way you have drawn the transistor connected for the sensing circuit correct?

Is this the way you have actually connected this mosfet?

There are some clues in my questions.
 
I have studied your circuitry and am clear on how it is meant to work in theory. There are some aspects of the design which we need to correct to account for contact bounce - the contacts connected to the 555 chip for example and there is no common ground/) 0Volt point for the LM3914. There are far too many long exposed interconnecting leads carrying low currents which are vulnerable to noise pick-up. The way the MOSFET is being used - common drain/source follower - is not suitable nor the lack of any fixed albeit variable bias on the gate of the MOSFET.

A clearly apparent problem is that this MOSFET is permanently 'on'. Not surprising since it is an enhancement mode FET and you have a resistor diode combination connecting its gate to the +5V rail. it takes very little current to charge up the MOSFET's internal gate source capacitance to such a voltage that the so-called gate thresheold voltage Vgs is exceeded which will change the state of the n channel between the drain and source from insulating to conducting. There is no resistor to the ground/0V rail to discharge this voltage. And there is no way to adjust the sensitivity/threshold to change when the MOSFET turns on and off.

The LM3914 is expecting a voltage at its pin 5 which as it rises from 0V to 5V switches its eight outputs on in sequence as the voltage crosses eight voltage values/references. Once can also adjust these voltage values/references by suitable circuitry at pin 8. To achieve the effect of the gradual LED illumination of the wings your sensing circuit is required to produce an output voltage which increases with the proximity of the hand to the antenna. Your sensing circuit is acting as the 0-5V signal source in Figure 1 of the attached datasheet.. but as currently wired your sensing circuit is more likely to just ramp up pin 5 between 0 and 5V and then stick at 5V - so all the LEDS stay on. (Did you check the 2N7002 was actually wired in correctly?)

https://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/lm3914.pdf

Anyway....let us proceed in steps. I do like the way you have constructed the circuit out of sub-systems - very intelligent and shows an engineer's approach to design - well done.

But first things first. We need to have a suitable and reliable power supply. I want you to estimate how much current this supply must deliver at 5V dc when all LEDs are off and then when all LEDs are on. Please show me your working. Also tell me about the power supply - what are you using?


THERE IS AN IMPORTANT CONDITION TO ME WORKING WITH YOU WHICH YOU MUST AGREE TO - YOU ONLY EVER WORK ON THE CIRCUITRY WHEN IT IS DISCONNECTED FROM THE 230v AC BY WHICH I MEAN THE WIRES BETWEEN YOUR CIRCUIT AND THE ORIGINAL SWITCH ARE COMPLETELY REMOVED - AGREED?

And which country or town are you in?


PS: For my own amusement I have ordered some components to attempt what you are doing in a different way in case we are unable to make your circuitry perform as desired.

So - 5Volts dc nice and safe. 230V ac DEADLY!!!!!!

Oh, if you don't already have one please buy a cheap digital voltmeter something like this one I use:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Compact-Digital-Multitester-Diode-Test/dp/B000L0RINQ
 
Mister @marconi , thank you for your kind answer and involvement.
I like your perseverance and I think you like this project as much as I do. Or at least is intriguing to you.
A little introduction first. I am an artist. I am from romania the awesome country where nothing is possible. But I believe things can be done, even if they look impossible. All we need is a bit of ambition. I am not an electronist or electrical guy. I made what I made because I want to make it and because I can. If I could not believe i can, I would not start it. You must understand something. Even if I am not a professional electronist, that doesnt mean I am automatically a rookie. I do electronics for about 30 years, but sporadically (not continuously). So I know something, and for sure I have some gaps, Im not afraid to say it.
You seem to know very good what you are saying. Is my impression. You seem to know more in depth the electronics in general. Probably because (i want to believe) you are doing it all the time. I like it very much and I would love to learn something from you.
There are so many things to cover... I am afraid you will get tired of it very quickly.
First of all, I work alone and simply by that, it is taking a lot of time to accomplish something. I work on this project for 7 months now, and also with any help I could find on internet. People in my country they only say they know, and I believe them, but nobody moved a finger. And is fine by me. People from america, on the other hand, they did got involved very nicely and I have a great deal of respect for them. Im talking about forums, like this one.
I will answer to your questions, indirectly, by giving you some links to my project.
I made a playlist in my youtube channel, where I put all my progress with this project.
How I started, the breadboard tests, failures, problems, finally some achievements, etc. Scroll fast through the movies to not get bored about their long --- content. I am not a good youtuber and I talk unnecessarily too much sometimes. It's also hard for me to translate it live, so that makes me look like an idiot. See the playlist here:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL6NJF1kQFOAImsLpNil3wNCb8POZQLYM0
Also, a text to read about this project. I have a description on the page how to download it. It is in a zip form.
q20210117 Led Wings Projekt by q12a on DeviantArt - https://www.deviantart.com/q12a/art/q20210117-Led-Wings-Projekt-867429226
You are welcomed and I also encourage you to browse in my account there, to see my glorious art. :) If you please.
Here is the online version of the same text to read. You dont have to download anything, but you have to scroll down ... a lot. There are currently 25 artpages.
https://www.artstation.com/artwork/zOBaED
You are welcomed and I also encourage you to browse in my account there, to see my glorious art. :) If you please. On deviantart I have everything, while on artstation I put only the good and important art.
If you are bored and start to hate my guts, don't tell me. I know. Hahaha.
I am also sorry to not respond to everything you asked me to. Usually I respond, but only to people that are close to me. I am very curious about your response now, after dealing with my mountain of information. Or maybe I am perceiving it as a mountain, because it took so long to make it all... who knows, it's all relative.
Another very important aspect. This project is nearly done. Very close to finish. I only have to discover the source of the interference in my circuit. I mean, I believe everything you said so far and I agree with your diagnostic. But you must understand, that this thing is tested and over-tested, and you come now, ta-da, ta-da, "change the circuit !". It's not easy for me to cut everything I done so far. I can not make any in depth operations for every suggestion I get. So I am patient and cut what I think is absolutly necesary to get as closer as I can to the result I want. If you argument it clear enough to make me believe it is absolutly necesary and it will indeed make it work, then I will listen to your advice. But until then, you are the new guy for me. I will try to make some of your rectifications, but only those that are not very damaging. And also because I work slowly, and Im afraid not to damage it as fragile as it is, it will take time anyway to make all the modifications you are suggesting. In the lack of better ideas, I will try everything I have on my plate, including your advices as well, but it will take time, so please understand. Insist on something that you are 100% it will work and I will give it priority if I believe you enough.
On a final note, All I needed from you here, is a way to stop that interference, to shield it, or to completely avoid it. Its my number one problem to resolve now.
Thank you very much for the support so far ! I will try what I can.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for your reply which I will read carefully tomorrow morning when I get up. Two of the nurses who attend my wife are Romanian. They are very professional and have kind happy personalities which are essential since they are in our home for 6 hours each day. So, helping you and your country will be some payback for that. They will be amused to know I am in contact with you.

I am cooking at the moment so I have to sign off for today. I will write again tomorrow.

:)
 
Last edited:
I have now read your note to me twice and I understand what you have said very clearly. Yes - I have come along as a 'clever dick' 'know-all' and you are nervous about making changes to your design and its construction because you have spent 7 months working on it. I suggest - so tell me if you agree - we do some simple tests on your circuitry first. They will involve disconnecting some wires but not dismantling any of the components. Depending on what we find you can then decide to make some changes or not. It would be really helpful to know if you have a digital or analogue multimeter so that we can take some voltage measurements.

To save time and assuming you agree to the approach I just mentioned please measure these voltages for me with respect to the 0V rail:

1. With all circuitry disconnected from 5V power supply the output voltage of this supply;
2a Now reconnect the circuitry. What is the supply voltage when all the LEDs and relays are off?
2b. What is the supply voltage when all the LEDs and relays are on?

Now disconnect the wire at pin 5 of the LM3914 which comes from the sensing circuit.

3. Using a short piece of wire - a jumper - connect pin 5 to 0V - all the LEDs should turn off - make solid connection do not just hold the wire;
4. Now move the jumper to connect pin 5 to the 5V rail - all the LEDs should turn on;
5. Make a potential divider from two resistors R1 and R2 say 10K and 10K and wire this across the 0 and 5V rails. If you have a small value capacitor - a few uF - please wire it across the resistor R2 which connects to the 0V rail. Connect pin 5 to the point the two resistors join together - approximately half the LEDS should light;
6. Now remove the resistor R1 which connects to the 5V rail so that there is only one resistor which connects pin 5 to 0V - all the LEDs should be off. Take a jumper wire and connect one end to the 5V rail. If your circuit (apart from the sensing circuit) is working as you want it to, if you repeatedly connect pin 5 to the 5V rail the LEDs should all turn on when raise pin 5 to 5V. If you repeatedly touch and then untouch pin 5 and touch and then untouch the LEDS should turn on and off and the relays should be turning on and off - toggling - as you want them to do - to eventually turn your room light on and off everytime the wings are illuminated. Everytime you touch pin 5 to 5V the capacitor will charge up - when you untouch 5V rail the capacitor will discharge through R2 - allow a little time for this to happen.

This is probably enough for now. Please let me know how what happens.

Regards

Marconi
 

Attachments

  • How to shield a live wire at 240V ? lm3914 - EletriciansForums.net
    lm3914.png
    6.3 KB · Views: 6
So far I have watched Led Wings Projekt 1, 2 3 and 4.
Thank you... as i mentioned, it's a lot of talking, it's probably better to move forward faster by scrolling.
I am just starting your experiments right now.
But pay attention to 1 very important thing. The circuit does work excellent when is on the workbench !
It only gets wierd on the wall, in the very close vecinity of the 50Hz. So your experiments are on a working circuit ! Ok?
I should probably mention this little detail as well, on the breadboard it worked in a way, after I assembled it on my modules boards, it worked totally different (it was my iron table that was ungrounded at that time) but still a big difference. Its because the breadboard have in it a lot of wires as well. So those were sensitizing the circuit. I was not aware at that time, I figure it out in time, after. Right now on the table I am working I have live wires but is a respectable distance, like 40cm to them from my circuit. But on the wall... is close as 5cm to working live wires, not standby ones.
Your experiments I presume, are to be taken on my workbench and not on the wall. The thing is on the wall, I have to keep everything in equilibrium, and is not optimal to work there, but is more advisable to do it there, I am aware.
After I will make your experiments, I plan to take out the sensing circuit module and mount the board on the wall, and make direct simple contact, without the sensing circuit involved. If everything goes to hell, then Im screwed. If everything works fine, then I will proceed to make another sensing circuit, with diferent technology (no field effect transistors). I am thinking on something capacitive like theremin circuit, I was suggested in another forum, not entirely my idea, but I love it. I already looked over those types of circuits and they are a bit complicated, but I put in my mind to try one, even if is a bit too complicated from my original plan.
But first, the experiments.
About multimeters, I have probably 6. One I use it exclusivly as ampmeter. I even managed in my youth to find an osciloscope but is so old and shitty... its a "transistorized osciloscope", is written on it. I dont use it though, i admit. :)
 
@marconi I made a part of your tests.
For 2a and 2b, the voltage is 5V everywhere. Im not sure what voltage are you reffering to measure. Instead, I measured circuit current, that is shown in my PSU (PowerSupplyUnit). When all is Off, is measuring 20mA. When all is On, is 60mA. But when I keep my hand over the sensing circuit to really keep everything ON including relay1, it goes to 100mA, and after I raise my hand, it goes back to 60mA.
2C- disconnect pin5. At this stage, pin1 and pin10 are ON. It should not stay on. Sign that the IC is damaged. Then I thought maybe is interfering with the other modules, so I disconected signal amplifier module, that also automatically disconected S (signal) track to the relays. So I have powered only the IC and the leds.
With pin5 in air, led1 and led10 is on.
But... If I keep with my hand a piece of metal wire on pin 5, unconected to anything, like an antena, all the leds are turned on but very dimmed.
If I connect pin5 to 0v, everything goes off - that is good.
If I connect pin5 to 5V,only pin1 is ON.
I remember in my breadboard experiments, it got me the same results (pin 1 was not litting back then), but pin5 was behaving as right now. I also tested back then with another IC and the same result. I can test it on the breadboard with a new IC and see how it will work, if is the same as now with this one here.
I also observed a slight current through all the leds, with pin5 in air, when I move my hand and body around. It is still interfering with the sensing circuit I guess. Very very strange.
 
Last edited:
I have now watched 5 and 6. Only when I have watched all your video clips will I reply.

I have some 2N7002 making there way to me in the post for me to replicate your sensing circuit ?.

What a wonderful experimenter you are!
 
I have now watched 5 and 6. Only when I have watched all your video clips will I reply.

I have some 2N7002 making there way to me in the post for me to replicate your sensing circuit ?.

What a wonderful experimenter you are!
I am very pleased you like it, really, but im a bit... sick of it. So many failures, one after another, literally. Please read my last reply, I put some modifications in it. My biggest problem is that I used the cardboard, and that is gathering some elecrostatic charge on it, i am aware, but i trade it for the maneuvrability and manufacturing ease I can achieve with it. Also very fast experimentation as you already are fascinated by it. Heh. It works for a large majority of circuits, but with this kind of sensing circuits, i suppose I push the limits with it. Eh well, I tried, right? :)
 
I am not allowed to edit my previous posts? What an imbecility.
I just tested on the breadboard the same circuit for LM3914. And I got the exact same results as with my mounted IC, except the led1 and 10 are staying off when pin5 is in air. That is the only fault I have on my board, and I bet it is some sort of interference for those leds/pins.
Pin5 on 0V, nothing happens, all leds are off.
Pin5 on 5V, again, nothing happens, all leds are off.
But, when pin5 is in air, and touch it with my hand, some leds are on, but barely, very dim.
 
I cannot spend much more time tonight because I am starting to cook. I would appreciate it very much if you did what I asked in my post from first thing this morning in order to establish which sub-systems do indeed function as desired. I suggested we first checked that everything from pin 5 to of LM3914 to the relay which switched the room lamp was operating as you wanted it to. If it does then we concentrate on the sensing circuit.

But it may well be that the sub-systems I have asked you to check are also subject to interference or disturbances which disrupts their reliable function.

To give you some idea of one of my lines of investigation you have 50 leds each of which consumes between 10 and 20mA say or in total between 0.5 and 1 Amp. The PURE power supply you showed in one of your YouTube clips outputs 5.5V and its rated output current is 1A. What current is required to operate the two relays which is extra to that for the leds? How well regulated or stable is the pure ‘s voltage output as the current supplied approaches its rated value - at the moment neither you or I know. Why does the voltage output of the pure matter? Because it may be affecting the operation of the sensing circuit.............
 
Last edited:

Reply to How to shield a live wire at 240V ? in the Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock