P

p11jor

Had a call out late last night, everytime the shower comes in it's blows the whole house.

The set up of the board is duel rcd. 2 mcb either side.

Cooker/shower on left

Lights/sockets on right



So the power to the shower switch is fine, again this can function fine and send power to the shower, bit as soon as the shower is pressed is wipes both rcds straight out after 2seconds.

I did a insulation resistance test, was getting 0.25megohms.
Removed tge switch and was getting 459megohms. So thought new switch, put new switch on and still wiping the whole board out, but obviously were not getting a dead short as the power to the shower is fine untill pressed.

Quite interesting this one. But such a obvious one which I will always look out for on my future PIRs
 
I agree topquark, makes me wonder how some people became electricians or more worryingly let loose in domestic dwellings with some comments ive seen on the forum as of late
 
With it being dark they may have been a small raggy stray bit of copper which you overlooked ( been late and dark etc... ), busbars were close enough for a little peice to touch the other, you snipped the bar back and its solved the problem
 
Lol, but soon as that shower draws it's power then surely this would be able to cause say a 2nm jump to the next bus bar? Or would it! I don't kno, I bin at it for only 7 years, but my mate i work with has been at it 49 years and he gas never saw this, he couldn't even explain why.
It would only jump if there's a PD to make it.
 
p11jor, luckily i'm not let loose near domestic dwellings, but i would guess 250V, the elements would be the next electrical component energised after your switch is pressed and the rcds trip
 
To be fair vernam I think there's a big divide in electricians.

There are people who have completed 2330, 2382, 2391 and become part p registered due to carrying out work all to regs and can test and certify it ,

Then there are other sparks who have all this but are very switched on and can pick faults out in a instant, there the engineers, there are some very good ones on here that's have helped me massively,

Others on here are really helpful and are good enough to offer some help (right or wrong) and I bet from a installation point of view they are good.
 
Haha you seem to know your onions
I have a basic food hygiene certificate, "I'm just a cook".

Must admit it would be good to ascertain exactly why that causes a trip. I would guess that as the one RCD is shutting down the busbar for that RCD approaches zero and that causes a jump from the Other RCD's busbar to the first (causing another imbalance in that 2nd RCD).
 
Last edited:
But if thr help is wrong theres a major flaw, someone advises you its ok to do something and it clearly is a ill fated comment, you are then risking your own working practices, i agree there is a lot of people on here who know their stuff, unfortunatley there is also the opposite, i dont mind helping anyone with the knowledge/experiences that i know but i wouldnt say anything unless i was absoutley certain it was correct
 
That's were the likes of yourself comment in and its great because your helping them aswell as the original post. Ok there may break into a row etc but 9 times out of 10 the correct advice would be posted on
Here from a member who is more in the "kno"!! I can't think of the members I have had good advice from from top of my head but certainly "telextric" if thats how he spells it is very good.
 
Surely power`s got nowt to do with it ("jumping across") it would be force (pressure) wouldn`t it....: voltage...and as for arcing....isn`t that a EMF caused when an inductive load is suddenly disconnected from its supply...isn`t this based on one of michael faraday`s great discoveries.....
 
There was no continuity between neutral & earth and untill the shower is switched on from the body of the shower not the iso switch then we are all good and no tripping. But when the shower was activated both rcds and all 4 mcbs blew.

I think you may need to explain this. Two neutral bars are placed together 6mm apart. Unfortunately there is a bloke on the TV with a converted gas mask into a bong... impressive ! (Knocked up)
The obvious fault is a crossed neutral (neutrals in the wrong bars). But this gets more interesting when not only both rcds trip but all 4 mcbs go as well! Did you get a good deal on ebay?
One other suggestion, use a bit of outer sheathing between the bars, don't bother to cut the neutral bars
 
Just thinking about this.... the shower load is inductive (mostly), so when the circuit collapses there's a whole load of back EMF happens, disproportional to the original supply load. Now, when it hits the Neutral bar it's then also looking at another magnet (the balance coil inside the RCD) which is (probably) still experiencing it's own collapsing field and associated EMF going the other way (see Flemings Left and Right hand rules)....so...what we have is a whole load of inductive energy looking for a place to hide. Introduce another conductor a bit too close, also connected to a coil (the other RCD) which is energised normally, and it's going to try to join the party. Second RCD then gets inbalanced and trips also.

Just a guess.....think I'm going to retrain as a hairdresser or cook or something.
 
Just thinking about this.... the shower load is inductive (mostly), so when the circuit collapses there's a whole load of back EMF happens, disproportional to the original supply load. Now, when it hits the Neutral bar it's then also looking at another magnet (the balance coil inside the RCD) which is (probably) still experiencing it's own collapsing field and associated EMF going the other way (see Flemings Left and Right hand rules)....so...what we have is a whole load of inductive energy looking for a place to hide. Introduce another conductor a bit too close, also connected to a coil (the other RCD) which is energised normally, and it's going to try to join the party. Second RCD then gets inbalanced and trips also.

Just a guess.....think I'm going to retrain as a hairdresser or cook or something.

Hairdressers couldn't provide that explanation, even for their curling tongs but nevertheless a nice explanation... if it were an inductive load, but I think you will find that it is purely resistive, even though its coiled up, remember all of the conductors (phase neutral and earth are coiled together, like an ext. lead).
The problem still exists why does everything go Pe-tong when the shower switch is pressed?
 
Just thinking about this.... the shower load is inductive (mostly), so when the circuit collapses there's a whole load of back EMF happens, disproportional to the original supply load. Now, when it hits the Neutral bar it's then also looking at another magnet (the balance coil inside the RCD) which is (probably) still experiencing it's own collapsing field and associated EMF going the other way (see Flemings Left and Right hand rules)....so...what we have is a whole load of inductive energy looking for a place to hide. Introduce another conductor a bit too close, also connected to a coil (the other RCD) which is energised normally, and it's going to try to join the party. Second RCD then gets inbalanced and trips also.

Just a guess.....think I'm going to retrain as a hairdresser or cook or something.
Heating loads are resistive mate...That is to say both voltage and current can be said to be IN PHASE with each other....
 
Heating loads are resistive mate...That is to say both voltage and current can be said to be IN PHASE with each other....
Unless you're an induction heater!! But fair enough, like I said, was only a guess. Right - where's my scisssors??!
 
Akabarthesta I didn't buy, nor fit the board, I'm just the guy who was called to sort the issue.

Also the nuetrals were fine, it's the live that was tge problem with the arc from the bus bar.
 
having given the matter considerable thought, i think an analogy would best explain the phenomenon, something similar to comparing electricals with water. the pressure is the voltage or potential difference, and the flow is current or electron movement.

so... say that the one busbar is the entrance to harrods, and the other to harvey nicholls. the current ( women shoppers ) moving in and out of both entrances is steady and continuous. now : harrods announce a sale. ( switching the shower on ). suddenly the flow of electrons through harrods door becomes a mad rush, and seeing this, the women ( electrons) going into harvey nicholls sees the rush and jump across to the harrods entrance. this causes a massive inbalance in both sets of customer ( electron) flow causing the revolving doors to come off their hinges ( RCD s trip).

hope the above clarifies the situation.
 
having given the matter considerable thought, i think an analogy would best explain the phenomenon, something similar to comparing electricals with water. the pressure is the voltage or potential difference, and the flow is current or electron movement.

so... say that the one busbar is the entrance to harrods, and the other to harvey nicholls. the current ( women shoppers ) moving in and out of both entrances is steady and continuous. now : harrods announce a sale. ( switching the shower on ). suddenly the flow of electrons through harrods door becomes a mad rush, and seeing this, the women ( electrons) going into harvey nicholls sees the rush and jump across to the harrods entrance. this causes a massive inbalance in both sets of customer ( electron) flow causing the revolving doors to come off their hinges ( RCD s trip).

hope the above clarifies the situation.

Gosh, things must be going well in Cheshire if Harrods and Harvey Nichols are at the fore front of your mind! LOL
 
having given the matter considerable thought, i think an analogy would best explain the phenomenon, something similar to comparing electricals with water. the pressure is the voltage or potential difference, and the flow is current or electron movement.

so... say that the one busbar is the entrance to harrods, and the other to harvey nicholls. the current ( women shoppers ) moving in and out of both entrances is steady and continuous. now : harrods announce a sale. ( switching the shower on ). suddenly the flow of electrons through harrods door becomes a mad rush, and seeing this, the women ( electrons) going into harvey nicholls sees the rush and jump across to the harrods entrance. this causes a massive inbalance in both sets of customer ( electron) flow causing the revolving doors to come off their hinges ( RCD s trip).

hope the above clarifies the situation.

Not if they have just popped out from Ascot to load up with extra shampoo (resistance to current flow caused by large brimmed hats and the blocked revolving doors) :alucard: :jester: :indian_chief: :party:
 

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Green 2 Go Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses Heating 2 Go Electrician Workwear Supplier
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Advert

Daily, weekly or monthly email

Thread Information

Title
Guess the fault
Prefix
N/A
Forum
Australia
Start date
Last reply date
Replies
63
Unsolved
--

Advert

Thread statistics

Created
p11jor,
Last reply from
ackbarthestar,
Replies
63
Views
6,650

Advert

Back
Top