Spur off 32a house socket form garage for 20a supply.

[mainline]

This is the post I challenged, quoted below in its full glorious brevity.



You clearly feel it was an appropriate response to the OP's question or, more specifically, his later clarification.

I'm of a different opinion and no amount of arguing or attempting to change the facts is going to change that.

Feel free to continuing this argument as a solo endeavour as I've nothing more to add in response to you original comment, subsequent attempts at justifcation of it or defelction in various directions from it.

I've stated my case quite clearly. Several times.

Can you explain why he can't extend the ring to achieve what he wants to do ?

 

[mainline]

Leaving to one side any argument over how 'permanently connected equipment' should be defined, as I feel we're going to be of differing opinion on that, your post actually undermines the point you've been trying to defend.

You gave the nod to a "16A or 20A supply" which is at odds with what you've quoted above.

No, not at all, if he wants more than 16 then extend the ring.

Either way, my response was correct.

 

[nicebutdim]

Can you explain why he can't extend the ring to achieve what he wants to do ?

If you can't then my response to the Op is correct.

There's no reason that I know of why it couldn't be done, but it wasn't part of the proposal to which you initially responded and to which i felt the need to post a challenge.

No, not at all, if he wants more than 16 then extend the ring.

Either way, my response was correct.

Sure thing, bud

I'm done responding to spurious justifications in defence of a careless comment.

 

[Johnconnor]

Cheers guys, enjoyed reading all the responses. I'm an apprentice and it was a conversation that came up at work between two electricians. Basically I just wanted to know who was right. Thanks