Which Metrel?

[SparkyMarkie]

Hi Guys n Gals

I'm looking to buy my first tester and I've come up with two which fit the bill in the price range I'm looking at. The first is a Metrel instaltest 61557, the other is a Metrel easitest MI2087 AL2.

Which one would be best for domestic work? I'm sure they'd both do the job just fine, but is one easier to use or have any benefits over the other? As I understand it the easitest is newer and has triplock and auto rcd testing (as I believe do some of the newer versions of the 61557) the easitest seems to also be a bit cheaper second hand than the 61557, is this because it does not have as many functions as the older 61557?

Any comments from users of these testers would be most welcome, I'd also be interested to hear from any of you with one of these for sale.

Cheers!

 

[armbands0]

I have a 4 year old instaltest 61557. It has auto rcd which is great. It has trip lock but the readings tend to be a bit high in comparison to the calculated Zs but it works and better high than low??
It has a signal trace facility (detector £70).
The leads need to be treated with respect mine started showing high readings during my 2391 practical. Replacement set worked fine.
But if I was buying new I would go for the Megger 1552 or the newer 1700 series just because they both do auto reading of certain functions, so no need for a third hand.

 

[telectrix]

get the one that says "megger" on it

 

[SparkyMarkie]

LOL, I was waiting for all the Megger, Fluke etc fans to pipe up! Funds just don't allow at the moment unfortunately, so my choices are restricted to the above.

 

[telectrix]

now the new megger 1700 is out, there will be plenty of 1552's second hand. expect to pay around £250 - £300.

 

[Amp David]

get the one that says "megger" on it

Just what I thought as I read the OP.

 

[Amp David]

I have been told from a well known supplier of test gear, that the only downside to Metrel is if they need to be sent back to the manufacturer for fixing, they go abroad, so takes time where megger and fluke get sorted in the uk.

They basically hinted that if they could, they would advise customers to go down the megger or fluke route and stay clear of metrels

 

[SparkyMarkie]

Ok, so apart from the name, what benefits are there to a megger over and above what a cheaper tester does? Are they more user friendly, reliable, make the coffee for you? I don't doubt they are 'better', but how are they?

 

[Amp David]

You don't get much more simpler to use than the megger 1500 testers.

Mine doesn't make coffee but can just about manage to open a can of beer for me!

 

[Former Sponsor TM]

I have been told from a well known supplier of test gear, that the only downside to Metrel is if they need to be sent back to the manufacturer for fixing, they go abroad, so takes time where megger and fluke get sorted in the uk.

Hi David,
I'd highly recommend using a test equipment supplier that knows what they are talking about. Thats the biggest load of rubbish I've ever heard!

Obviously using scare tactics to try win a sale! Metrel have a very well respected calibration and repair lab, I know, I've being there and seen the calibration van!

Fluke and Megger are also very good brands but please don't let that silly remark dissuade you from choosing Metrel tester. If you would like some impartial and correct advice please feel free to give us a call: 0113 248 9966

Ps. I'd be very interested to hear who told you that in a PM

 

[MarkieSparkie]

Hi Sparky,
The best advice anyone could give you is to try the testers before you buy, it's a very personal choice a feature one person likes is often disliked by others. Ask for forum members in your area, I'm sure they would demonstrate their testers and possibly give you hands on time, even basic tests on a checkbox can help in the decision making.
The only down-side I know of Metrel is the instructional manuals which are pants and regularly moaned about by others on here, so not just my opinion. So if you are interested in Metrel, getting someone local with one can be worth it's weight in gold due to the poor manual.
Don't dismiss Martindale and Dilog brands as they are also cheaper than Megger/Fluke, but equally capable and with their supporters on here. Previously I would of included Kewtech in this group, but my local college still has on going reliability issues with their MFTs and until this is resolved I would avoid them.

 

[Phil]

just to echo what test meter has said, the repair team for metrel are in Castleford in the UK. I have sat there chatting to the guys in there for hours. what they told you was actually backwards as the faulty metrels from Europe actually come here to the UK for the repairs.

 

[durhamspark]

Don't worry about metrel, I have 3 installtest 61557 and have had no problems at all other than needing a new set of leads after about 7 years. I am looking at getting a 3125b now so may be selling one of my old meters if you would be interested. Whilst on the topic does anyone have any experience of the 3125 series?

 

[Phil]

Don't worry about metrel, I have 3 installtest 61557 and have had no problems at all other than needing a new set of leads after about 7 years. I am looking at getting a 3125b now so may be selling one of my old meters if you would be interested. Whilst on the topic does anyone have any experience of the 3125 series?

not too keen on them design wise. just my opinion though had a little go with one and they are ok its just the design that i don`t like

 

[Dcf]

Try 3125b good auto test for rcds, about 400& vat .good value IMO

 

[Deleted member 26818]

I've got a 300I, which I'm fairly happy with.
Never had any problems with the No Trip test giving high readings.
Only thing that bugs me, is the length of time it takes to do the Zs test.

 

[sparks_114]

I would have said go for MI3000. I've been using the best part of a year and never had problems but as Spin pointed out the Zs measurement on the no trip setting do tend to take forever. Like I said in other threads, there are only 2 testers for me: the Megger and the Metrel and the choice is made by your pocket.

 

[Former Sponsor TM]

Don't worry about metrel, I have 3 installtest 61557 and have had no problems at all other than needing a new set of leads after about 7 years. I am looking at getting a 3125b now so may be selling one of my old meters if you would be interested. Whilst on the topic does anyone have any experience of the 3125 series?

I have tried using the MI3125B quite a few times. I must admit that I do not test on a daily basis as my job is working at test-meter, but I normally try out new products that appear interesting. I know that the design is different from other well known testers (other Metrel testers, Meggers, Flukes, Kewtech etc..) and I guess personal preference always plays part, but I found to be easy to use. It has a magnet on the back of the meter meaning that it hangs from any magnetised surface which means that you have both hands free. The Easi Switch which was launched with the MI3101 EurotestAT also works with the MI3125B (please note that there are other Metrel meters with the same part number like ComboLite and MI3125 Combo T - these do NOT work with the EasiSwitch or store/download test results). This does take headache out of rings mains testing and makes the job a lot quicker, so that is in my opinion a welcome feature. The specifications of the MI3125B are quite good as well carrying out all the tests required for TN and TT systems and it includes the RCD test for type B RCD's. All in all I can't really fault the product from having used it.
If I could say anything negative it would be that there are too many Metrel testers or Multifunction tester kits with similar part numbers. I haven't often found customers confused by prices and differences when looking around. If anyone has any questions, please let us know. I think we have finally gotten our heads around all of them now ;-)

 

[Former Sponsor TM]

I have tried using the MI3125B quite a few times. I must admit that I do not test on a daily basis as my job is working at test-meter, but I normally try out new products that appear interesting. I know that the design is different from other well known testers (other Metrel testers, Meggers, Flukes, Kewtech etc..) and I guess personal preference always plays part, but I found to be easy to use. It has a magnet on the back of the meter meaning that it hangs from any magnetised surface which means that you have both hands free. The Easi Switch which was launched with the MI3101 EurotestAT also works with the MI3125B (please note that there are other Metrel meters with the same part number like ComboLite and MI3125 Combo T - these do NOT work with the EasiSwitch or store/download test results). This does take headache out of rings mains testing and makes the job a lot quicker, so that is in my opinion a welcome feature. The specifications of the MI3125B are quite good as well carrying out all the tests required for TN and TT systems and it includes the RCD test for type B RCD's. All in all I can't really fault the product from having used it.
If I could say anything negative it would be that there are too many Metrel testers or Multifunction tester kits with similar part numbers. I haven't often found customers confused by prices and differences when looking around. If anyone has any questions, please let us know. I think we have finally gotten our heads around all of them now ;-)

Sorry, the above meant to read that I HAVE often found customer confused by prices....that's what happens when you type away with out checking

 

[tommy76it]

Ive got a Metrel MI3000.Does the job just fine, £400 all in.