OP
amberleaf
Split load board with RCBOs on critical circuits : ● ( PCA ) Partially Compliant Assembly : ←
By reviewing the wiring scheme employed with the split load assembly proposed the cost of the finished assembly can be reduced, and partial compliance with the regulations achieved. The split load board laid out here will meet the17th Edition requirements for the following:
● Socket outlets for general use in domestic installations must have the additional protection of an RCD not exceeding 30mA.
● All circuits in locations containing a bath or shower must be protected by an RCD not exceeding 30mA.
● Cables buried in a wall or partition at a depth of less than 50mm, and not mechanically protected by appropriate earthed metal, must be protected by an RCD not exceeding 30mA.:
However, depending on the installation design, it is unlikely to satisfy the regulations on:
* To prevent nuisance tripping, unnecessary hazards, and minimise inconvenience, circuits should not be connected to a single upstream RCD.
* Separate circuits shall not be affected by the failure of other circuits. :
there is still the risk of one circuit failure impacting on another (regulation 314.2); however the level of inconvenience could be considered to be acceptable (only the sockets and showers are affected ), and no hazard or safety issues are inherent. Again, the installer will need to consider the amount of leakage in the installation, due to electronic devices in the house, and it may be a consideration to split the power sockets and have one of them on an RCBO.
The end result is that no base consumer unit exists that complies with the 17th Edition. The choice of
consumer unit and the configuration of devices within it can only be made after the wiring scheme has been finalised. :
Key extracts from 17th Edition of the IEE Wiring Regulations BS 7671 : 2008
314 Division of Installation
314.1 Every installation shall be divided into circuits, as necessary, to (i) avoid hazards and minimize inconvenience in the event of a fault(iii) take account of danger that may arise from the failure of a single circuit such as a lighting circuit.314.2 Separate circuits shall be provided for parts of the installation which need to be separately controlled, in such a way that those circuits are not affected by the failure of other circuits, and due account shall be taken of the consequences of the operation of any single protective device.
411.3.3 Additional protection
In a.c. systems, additional protection by means of an RCD in accordance with Regulation 415.1 shall be provided fori) socket-outlets with a rated current not exceeding 20A that are for use by ordinary persons and are intended for general use.
531.2.4 An RCD shall be so selected and the electrical circuits so sub divided that any protective conductor current which may be expected to occur during normal operation of the connected load(s) will be unlikely to cause unnecessary tripping of the device.
Section 701 Locations containing a bath or shower
701.411.3.3 Additional protection by RCDs
Additional protection shall be provided for all circuits of the location, by the use of one or more RCDs having the characteristics specified in Regulation 415.1.1 (30mA RCD)
( Note: see regulations 314.1 and 531.2.4. )
Note: There are exceptions when the socket outlets are used by skilled or instructed persons, but not relevant in residential property. For example 411.3.3 relates to socket outlets located anywhere in a home, including the socket in the cooker outlet. However RCD protection for the cooker outlet is required if any of the cables are buried in the wall and not deeper than 50mm, as indicated in 522.6
Fire Alarms :
The entire system should be tested to ensure that it operates satisfactorily and that, in particular,
automatic fire detectors and any manual call points function correctly when tested. Smoke detectors should
be smoke tested with a simulated smoke aerosol that will not damage the detector. Heat detectors should be
tested by means of a suitable heat source unless detector damage would otherwise result. The heat
source should not have the ability to cause a fire. A live flame should not be used.
It should be established that any interlinking works and that sounders operate correctly.
Manufacturer’s tests should be carried out.
Certification :
A certificate should have been issued to the user and this should be available for inspection. For Grade F
systems a certificate should be issued if installed by a professional installer.
User instructions :
The supplier of the fire alarm system should provide the user with operating instructions, which should be
sufficient to enable a lay person to understand, operate and maintain the system. Silencing and disablement facilities should be explained but it should be stressed that system readiness must not be compromised. Recommended action in the event of a
fire must stress the importance of all occupants leaving the building as quickly as possible and that
the fire service is summoned immediately regardless
Routine testing and maintenance :
instructions to users must stress the importance of routine testing. The system should be tested weekly by
pushing the test button. If the dwelling has been unoccupied for a period during which the supply (yes)
could have failed, the occupier should check that the system has not suffered total power failure and is still operable.
Maintenance :
Smoke alarms in Grade D, E and F systems should be cleaned periodically in accordance with the
manufacturer’s instructions. Where experience shows that undue deposits of dust and dirt are likely to
accumulate, so affecting the performance of the system before detectors are cleaned or changed, more frequent
cleaning or changing should be carried out.
Commissioning :
The system should be inspected. Electrical tests made to the mains supply circuit
should include earth continuity, polarity, and earth fault loop impedance. Insulation tests should be made
of all installed cables as required by BS 7671. Electronic equipment should be disconnected to avoid damage.
Supply to a Grade E system where the installation forms part of a TT system.
The 100 mA time-delayed RCD provides protection for the fire alarm system ( and other circuits )
and operates independently of the RCD protection for the socket-outlets
main switch
( 100 mA time delayed RCD )
S-type, double pole to BS EN 61008 :
interconnected by wiring should be connected on a single final circuit. Note that certain alarms are radio linked and such alarms
need not be on the same final circuit ,
Wiring systems :
All cables should be selected and installed in accordance with the requirements of BS 7671 and the recommendations of BS 5839-6.
“ RCCB “
Residual Current Circuit Breaker (RCCB). This is a term that does not appear in the current wiring regs, and does not have a consistent definition or usage. Some manufacturers use it to differentiate RCDs without overcurrent protection from those with it ( i.e. RCBOs ).
Nuisance trips :
A Nuisance trip is an unexpected operation of a RCD that does not appear to be related to an immediately obvious fault. There can be many reasons that these trips occur, some indicate that there is a latent problem with the electrical installation, some may indicate the presence of a serious but as yet unobserved fault, and others may be the result of a minor fault that in itself poses little or no risk ,
Tracing the cause of nuisance tripping can prove to be very difficult and time consuming.
What causes nuisance trips :
Using the wrong busbar
If you have a new circuit that trips the moment you attempt to draw power from it, the most likely cause is common wiring mistake in the CU. Split load CUs will have two or more sections, with a dedicated neutral bus bar for each. If you connect the live of a circuit to a MCB on a section of the CU protected by an RCD, but return the neutral to a bus bar not associated with that RCD, you will get an immediate trip sine the RCD can only "see" one half of the current flow. The same logic applies if using a RCBO, then the neutral for the circuit must be returned to the neutral connection on the RCBO ( and the RCBO's flying neutral wire in turn connected to the appropriate neutral bus bar in the CU).
Excess earth leakage
The RCDs operating principle is to measure the current imbalance between that flowing into and out of a circuit down live and neutral wires. In an ideal world the current difference would be zero, however in the real world there are a various different types of equipment that will legitimately have a small amount of leakage to earth, even operating normally. If the RCD is protecting too many such devices then it is possible that the cumulative result of all these small leakages will be enough to either
● trip the RCD
● or by passing most of the RCD's trip threshold current, make the RCD excessively sensitive to any additional leakage currents
By reviewing the wiring scheme employed with the split load assembly proposed the cost of the finished assembly can be reduced, and partial compliance with the regulations achieved. The split load board laid out here will meet the17th Edition requirements for the following:
● Socket outlets for general use in domestic installations must have the additional protection of an RCD not exceeding 30mA.
● All circuits in locations containing a bath or shower must be protected by an RCD not exceeding 30mA.
● Cables buried in a wall or partition at a depth of less than 50mm, and not mechanically protected by appropriate earthed metal, must be protected by an RCD not exceeding 30mA.:
However, depending on the installation design, it is unlikely to satisfy the regulations on:
* To prevent nuisance tripping, unnecessary hazards, and minimise inconvenience, circuits should not be connected to a single upstream RCD.
* Separate circuits shall not be affected by the failure of other circuits. :
there is still the risk of one circuit failure impacting on another (regulation 314.2); however the level of inconvenience could be considered to be acceptable (only the sockets and showers are affected ), and no hazard or safety issues are inherent. Again, the installer will need to consider the amount of leakage in the installation, due to electronic devices in the house, and it may be a consideration to split the power sockets and have one of them on an RCBO.
The end result is that no base consumer unit exists that complies with the 17th Edition. The choice of
consumer unit and the configuration of devices within it can only be made after the wiring scheme has been finalised. :
Key extracts from 17th Edition of the IEE Wiring Regulations BS 7671 : 2008
314 Division of Installation
314.1 Every installation shall be divided into circuits, as necessary, to (i) avoid hazards and minimize inconvenience in the event of a fault(iii) take account of danger that may arise from the failure of a single circuit such as a lighting circuit.314.2 Separate circuits shall be provided for parts of the installation which need to be separately controlled, in such a way that those circuits are not affected by the failure of other circuits, and due account shall be taken of the consequences of the operation of any single protective device.
411.3.3 Additional protection
In a.c. systems, additional protection by means of an RCD in accordance with Regulation 415.1 shall be provided fori) socket-outlets with a rated current not exceeding 20A that are for use by ordinary persons and are intended for general use.
531.2.4 An RCD shall be so selected and the electrical circuits so sub divided that any protective conductor current which may be expected to occur during normal operation of the connected load(s) will be unlikely to cause unnecessary tripping of the device.
Section 701 Locations containing a bath or shower
701.411.3.3 Additional protection by RCDs
Additional protection shall be provided for all circuits of the location, by the use of one or more RCDs having the characteristics specified in Regulation 415.1.1 (30mA RCD)
( Note: see regulations 314.1 and 531.2.4. )
Note: There are exceptions when the socket outlets are used by skilled or instructed persons, but not relevant in residential property. For example 411.3.3 relates to socket outlets located anywhere in a home, including the socket in the cooker outlet. However RCD protection for the cooker outlet is required if any of the cables are buried in the wall and not deeper than 50mm, as indicated in 522.6
Fire Alarms :
The entire system should be tested to ensure that it operates satisfactorily and that, in particular,
automatic fire detectors and any manual call points function correctly when tested. Smoke detectors should
be smoke tested with a simulated smoke aerosol that will not damage the detector. Heat detectors should be
tested by means of a suitable heat source unless detector damage would otherwise result. The heat
source should not have the ability to cause a fire. A live flame should not be used.
It should be established that any interlinking works and that sounders operate correctly.
Manufacturer’s tests should be carried out.
Certification :
A certificate should have been issued to the user and this should be available for inspection. For Grade F
systems a certificate should be issued if installed by a professional installer.
User instructions :
The supplier of the fire alarm system should provide the user with operating instructions, which should be
sufficient to enable a lay person to understand, operate and maintain the system. Silencing and disablement facilities should be explained but it should be stressed that system readiness must not be compromised. Recommended action in the event of a
fire must stress the importance of all occupants leaving the building as quickly as possible and that
the fire service is summoned immediately regardless
Routine testing and maintenance :
instructions to users must stress the importance of routine testing. The system should be tested weekly by
pushing the test button. If the dwelling has been unoccupied for a period during which the supply (yes)
could have failed, the occupier should check that the system has not suffered total power failure and is still operable.
Maintenance :
Smoke alarms in Grade D, E and F systems should be cleaned periodically in accordance with the
manufacturer’s instructions. Where experience shows that undue deposits of dust and dirt are likely to
accumulate, so affecting the performance of the system before detectors are cleaned or changed, more frequent
cleaning or changing should be carried out.
Commissioning :
The system should be inspected. Electrical tests made to the mains supply circuit
should include earth continuity, polarity, and earth fault loop impedance. Insulation tests should be made
of all installed cables as required by BS 7671. Electronic equipment should be disconnected to avoid damage.
Supply to a Grade E system where the installation forms part of a TT system.
The 100 mA time-delayed RCD provides protection for the fire alarm system ( and other circuits )
and operates independently of the RCD protection for the socket-outlets
main switch
( 100 mA time delayed RCD )
S-type, double pole to BS EN 61008 :
interconnected by wiring should be connected on a single final circuit. Note that certain alarms are radio linked and such alarms
need not be on the same final circuit ,
Wiring systems :
All cables should be selected and installed in accordance with the requirements of BS 7671 and the recommendations of BS 5839-6.
“ RCCB “
Residual Current Circuit Breaker (RCCB). This is a term that does not appear in the current wiring regs, and does not have a consistent definition or usage. Some manufacturers use it to differentiate RCDs without overcurrent protection from those with it ( i.e. RCBOs ).
Nuisance trips :
A Nuisance trip is an unexpected operation of a RCD that does not appear to be related to an immediately obvious fault. There can be many reasons that these trips occur, some indicate that there is a latent problem with the electrical installation, some may indicate the presence of a serious but as yet unobserved fault, and others may be the result of a minor fault that in itself poses little or no risk ,
Tracing the cause of nuisance tripping can prove to be very difficult and time consuming.
What causes nuisance trips :
Using the wrong busbar
If you have a new circuit that trips the moment you attempt to draw power from it, the most likely cause is common wiring mistake in the CU. Split load CUs will have two or more sections, with a dedicated neutral bus bar for each. If you connect the live of a circuit to a MCB on a section of the CU protected by an RCD, but return the neutral to a bus bar not associated with that RCD, you will get an immediate trip sine the RCD can only "see" one half of the current flow. The same logic applies if using a RCBO, then the neutral for the circuit must be returned to the neutral connection on the RCBO ( and the RCBO's flying neutral wire in turn connected to the appropriate neutral bus bar in the CU).
Excess earth leakage
The RCDs operating principle is to measure the current imbalance between that flowing into and out of a circuit down live and neutral wires. In an ideal world the current difference would be zero, however in the real world there are a various different types of equipment that will legitimately have a small amount of leakage to earth, even operating normally. If the RCD is protecting too many such devices then it is possible that the cumulative result of all these small leakages will be enough to either
● trip the RCD
● or by passing most of the RCD's trip threshold current, make the RCD excessively sensitive to any additional leakage currents
Last edited by a moderator: