G

Garethspur

Good morning. Apologies to begin with if this isn't the right place for this post, but I'm in need of advice from people who know what they are talking about.

We bought a house in Lancashire a few months ago and it quickly became apparent that, among with a load of other problems, there were serious issues with the electrics. I called an electrician (the no. 1 rated electrician in our area on Checkatrade) and he and his son came to the house. He immediately spotted there were problems and, after checking the house more carefully, said we would need a total rewire. He made a good impression and the price seemed good so I agreed.

We planned to get the whole house replastered and then decorated so the plan was for the electrician to come in before the plasterer, do most of the work up until the point of finishing the plugs, switches and light fixtures, then come back when the painting was finished. That was his suggestion (he said it would avoid getting paint on the lights, etc) and it made sense.

So he started the initial work. It seemed to be going okay but then one day we came to the house and he had cut two large hatches in the oak flooring in the kitchen. He said it was necessary to do the electrics, but he hadn't informed us before, as our preferred option would have been to remove the floor boards and replace them with some from under the stairs.

Anyway, he said the first part of the job was finished. It had taken a couple of weeks and he had asked for two payments during that time (the only tradesman who had asked for payment before the work was done). The payments added up to the estimate for the job as a whole. He said he would come back once the other work was done and quickly finish up.

The other work took about a month. A week or so before it was due to be finished I informed the electrician so he could fit us in. He said he wanted to come to the house to remind him of what needed to be done. When he did go round he said he couldn't start for a few days because the paint on the doors needed to dry. A few days later I rang him and he said he couldn't do that week because his son was on a course. However, he would speak to another electrician he knew and get back to me.

He didn't. I called again at the end of the week and he said the guy wasn't available and his son was still on a course. It would be at least another week, he said. I said I felt like I was being fobbed off because he had said previously that finishing the work would be straightforward. Then his tone changed and he said the job had been a 'total nightmare' and 'disorganised'. He rang back a few hours later to say the guy he knew could do the work and would be there with him at 8am on Saturday.

He went to the house to do some work that Friday night then he and his contact spent most of the day there on Saturday. I got an email to say 'electrics complete, tested and certified'. I went to the house to check and was totally shocked by what I what I found.

1) There was no electricity to the outbuilding (he had re-wired it and installed new lights inside and on outside). When confronted he said he had forgotten to do.

2) Turning on one of the lights in the bedroom tripped most of the lights in the house. When asked about this, he admitted he probably hadn't tested the light

3) Most of the light fixtures I had paid him to fit had not been installed. The one that had was in the wrong place (despite the boxes being left underneath the corresponding wires). He said the lights hadn't been done because he didn't know how high I wanted them. At no point during the day did he ring to ask

4) He had caused extensive damage to the redecoration. The paint and plaster around every plug socket needs repairing, for which he blamed the plaster. The paint on the sideboard was extensively scratched and there were scratches and marks all over the house. We'd just spent thousands on it. My partner was in tears when she saw it. There were even scratches and marks where no work had been done.

5) Probably most worrying, he had forgotten to attach the boiler in the loft (installed in the last few years) to the mains, or do any of the electrics in the loft. When confronted about this he said he didn't know where the boiler was. He'd been in the loft to do the lights and the boiler is the biggest thing in there. He said if I needed hot water right away I should run an extension cable up there. It's attached directly to the mains, there is no plug!

6) Several of the plug sockets in the house either do no work or would come off the wall if you pulled them

7) In his email telling me the 'all electrics complete, tested and certified' he said I owed him £420 for the work. He said the certificate was being reviewed by the other guy for 'human error' and would be provided to me once I paid the £420. We had already paid him the full amount for the job.

I contacted NIC EIC for advice and they said I should raise all the issues with him as the start of a formal complaints process. When I emailed him a list of the issues and with how upset I was, his response was apathetic. He offered no apology nor explanation, other than to say he forgot about the outbuilding. He now says he will come back with the same guy tomorrow to complete the work. When asked about the extra charge he said it had been "scrubbed" and "to be honest, I've lost track of this job".

I don't know what to do. In any other circumstances I wouldn't allow this man anywhere near my house ever again. But my understanding is that he is legally obliged to provide me with the certificate (and thus complete the job) and that I can't get someone else in to finish it off. I have no faith at all that he will do the work without causing any further damage. We've ploughed every penny we have into the house, and now I have no idea if the problems he's caused, especially with the boiler, are fixable without having to do major surgery that will require replastering and re-painting. I couldn't sleep last night for worrying about it.

At this point I plan to literally following him from room to room and Saturday and watch everything he does like a hawk, which I am dreading. Any advice anyone on here can give me about what I should do in this situation would be much appreciated. This this normal?

IMG_1368.JPG IMG_1382.JPG IMG_1356.JPG IMG_1378.JPG
 
My advice would be to get a second opinion ( from another electrician ) on the state of the installation before letting them back in. Then you can give him a full snagging list. I'd be wary of just letting him do further work until you have an expert opinion. As for damage to decor etc., you'd need to bill him for remedial works.
 
Agreed with above, what he did to your floor is outrageous. My sister in law has recently had a similar situation and I gave her a snagging list and met the electrician on site. The complaints procedure with all scheme providers such as the NICEIC is flawed whereby you have to engage the contractor first to rectify errors or problems which are their own doing.
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: Davisonp and DPG
so it was check a c**p you got this person off ,
He made a good impression and the price seemed good so I agreed.
what price was that ?
 
It's disappointing that you have been let down so badly by someone in our trade.
Did you have anything in writing about the nature, scope & timescale for the original job?

I agree with Telextric, and although not ideal, would get an experienced electrician ( perhaps one of the members here?) to carry out an EICR, making it clear to them why you are having it done. Use this report to give the original electrician the opportunity to make good ALL coded work, i.e. including Code 3's.
Do everything in writing & set defined timescales for remedial work to be completed. If he fails, advise NICEIC accordingly. Re decoration damage, get it sorted by a decorator and tell the original electrician that you hold him responsible for meeting your additional costs.
It probably won't work out as straightforward as above, but good luck.
 
The job came to £3,200 in total.
that's not expensive,definitely on the low side, depending on the scale of the job, of course. without knowing that, difficult to make a judgement, but it's quite possible that the price is below what it should have been and the electrician has cut corners to save money.
 
was a contract made before hand before the job was started.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: 1 person
That's one very sad story
Its annoying when these pretend sparks (who may very well be registered by one of these money grabbing schemes)they can cause all in the trade to become tarred by the same brush
Sorry to hear of your costs and your unfortunate experience
 
My advice would be to get a second opinion ( from another electrician ) on the state of the installation before letting them back in. Then you can give him a full snagging list. I'd be wary of just letting him do further work until you have an expert opinion. As for damage to decor etc., you'd need to bill him for remedial works.
What he said 6^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
 
Agreed with above, what he did to your floor is outrageous. My sister in law has recently had a similar situation and I gave her a snagging list and met the electrician on site. The complaints procedure with all scheme providers such as the NICEIC is flawed whereby you have to engage the contractor first to rectify errors or problems which are their own doing.
What he said as well^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
 
Looks like you have fallen foul of a Cowboy, I don't know the right procedure would be, but in the first instance I would contact "Check a trade" don't know what good that would do you, but it may stop this blighter from ripping anyone else off, NICEIC this was in my opinion a typical response, don't want to get involved.

These people are again in my opinion parasites certifying people to be able to work in peoples houses and when it goes wrong, any complaints fall on deaf ears.
Have to tried taking this bloke to court? a trip to the solicitors might help, trouble is that costs you more. It's a disgrace being treated like this both by the Electrician and the NICEIC, I feel for you Mate I really do.
 
some times it the other way round ,do a good job for a customer& don't get paid .
been their & brought the t shirt. try trade and standards they might help.
 
some times it the other way round ,do a good job for a customer& don't get paid .
been their & brought the t shirt. try trade and standards they might help.
 
Looks like you have fallen foul of a Cowboy, I don't know the right procedure would be, but in the first instance I would contact "Check a trade" don't know what good that would do you, but it may stop this blighter from ripping anyone else off, NICEIC this was in my opinion a typical response, don't want to get involved.

These people are again in my opinion parasites certifying people to be able to work in peoples houses and when it goes wrong, any complaints fall on deaf ears.
Have to tried taking this bloke to court? a trip to the solicitors might help, trouble is that costs you more. It's a disgrace being treated like this both by the Electrician and the NICEIC, I feel for you Mate I really do.
Just a thought before go any further, may seem a daft question, are you sure this Electrician is a paid up member of NICEIC? I only ask because they are the most well known of the Scams, and sometimes people, like yourself assume every Electrician is NICEIC registered.
 
Looks like you have fallen foul of a Cowboy, I don't know the right procedure would be, but in the first instance I would contact "Check a trade" don't know what good that would do you, but it may stop this blighter from ripping anyone else off, NICEIC this was in my opinion a typical response, don't want to get involved.

These people are again in my opinion parasites certifying people to be able to work in peoples houses and when it goes wrong, any complaints fall on deaf ears.
Have to tried taking this bloke to court? a trip to the solicitors might help, trouble is that costs you more. It's a disgrace being treated like this both by the Electrician and the NICEIC, I feel for you Mate I really do.
Just a thought before go any further, may seem a daft question, are you sure this Electrician is a paid up member of NICEIC? I only ask because they are the most well known of the Scams, and sometimes people, like yourself assume every Electrician is NICEIC registered.
 
Just a thought before go any further, may seem a daft question, are you sure this Electrician is a paid up member of NICEIC? I only ask because they are the most well known of the Scams, and sometimes people, like yourself assume every Electrician is NICEIC registered.
good point. if he's purporting to be when he's not, then maybe niceic could get off their fat arses and respond.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Rpa07 and Pete999
He said the certificate was being reviewed by the other guy for 'human error'
to be honest I do not think he is register reading between the lines.
 
good point. if he's purporting to be when he's not, then maybe niceic could get off their fat arses and respond.
Tried this recently they wanted photographic proof like their logo on a van, said this wasn't possible and they left it at that no further investigation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PEG
Although i wholeheartedly agree,with the sympathies expressed,it only strengthens my original belief,that relying on people guaranteed by an organisation,that is paid by said people,is flawed.....and the same is true,for checkatrader ;)

The painful truth is,that without any written schedule/contract or agreement,most of what has been described and shown,could easily be argued away,and the liability shifted.

If as described,your situation is worthy of sympathy,but aesthetics aside,i would be more concerned regarding other,more fundamental errors,hidden now,such as why there are nervous RCD's,etc.

As suggested,a recommended electrician,from out of the area,if needed,paid independently,to assess where you are at this point.
 
I'd volunteer, but it's 70 miles each way, so I'd need to charge additional to cover this. If OP is willing to pay a bit more, then I'm available to give an unbiased report.
 
some times it the other way round ,do a good job for a customer& don't get paid .
been their & brought the t shirt. try trade and standards they might help.

A pal set-up,SE,about four years back,and joined all those vacuous sales portals....at the time,i told him,he would be better off finding one,that cleared and recommended customers..."What yer on about?...i think you've got it backwards..." he replied.

A recent conversation with him,revealed he now knows "exactly" what i meant :cool:
 
  • Like
Reactions: DPG
I'd volunteer, but it's 70 miles each way, so I'd need to charge additional to cover this. If OP is willing to pay a bit more, then I'm available to give an unbiased report.

I would rate that as a generous and possibly economical offer.

At least the OP has the opportunity of researching Tel's input and history,and more confidence of being presented with an honest and realistic assessment.

....Just better check your history,Tel,see if you've ever cut an impromptu floor hatch,using a thermal-lance...;)
 
...Just better check your history,Tel,see if you've ever cut an impromptu floor hatch,using a thermal-lance...

thermal lance... too technical for me. semtex is easier. ;););):eek:
 
I could do it , but im on a another
Planet!
 
  • Funny
  • Like
Reactions: ruston and DPG
  • Like
Reactions: Dave OCD
I probably will need a tin hat, but I guess there's 2 sides to every story. Weve all had one of those clients.........
 
  • Like
Reactions: Octopus
I'd volunteer, but it's 70 miles each way, so I'd need to charge additional to cover this. If OP is willing to pay a bit more, then I'm available to give an unbiased report.


Very decent offer from the Mickey Mouser...... Pay him the money and get a decent assessment.
 
You are correct that the certificate should be issued to you irregardless of any payment due. Any electrician should know this, that they may not deny the certificate due to payment due. It is clear from the pictures that the work quality and other description of failure of circuits indicates that the level of competence is very low.
What can you do? Legal avenue? Lot of money and more stress with very low chance of satisfaction. Existing contractor performs contract fully, I don't think so I wouldn't let him near your house never mind mine. Apart from the poor workmanship there is very real danger of harm resulting from incorrect wiring. A couple of things you have said I find quite alarming. Perhaps speak with building control in the local council?
You will have to bite the bullet and get a contractor in to test existing wiring and rectify/finish work. Costly? yes but the alternatives are unthinkable (above) I am sad to say that failure of performance on contract/building work is endemic. The remedies poor and unsatisfactory. It would be most informative to examine the certificate when and if you get it though. This would tell us a lot lot more about your situation if you can possibly do that?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DPG
I don't want to sound trite but you did mention "on Checkatrade"..
You know that means he's paid best part of £1000 a year as a small business to get on their list? Bunch of leeches IMO. Their trading currency is the removal of genuine earned and voiced goodwill, in favour of a system which traders have to buy into or get left out in the cold.
I'm not biassed, of course not. Yes, what a marvelous organization... One day I may need to get sucked into the same pit of desperation if the work dries up (Many of my potential customers going straight to same expensive "Trusty Bloke" sites).
 
I could do it , but im on a another
Planet!
Deleted
I don't want to sound trite but you did mention "on Checkatrade"..
You know that means he's paid best part of £1000 a year as a small business to get on their list? Bunch of leeches IMO. Their trading currency is the removal of genuine earned and voiced goodwill, in favour of a system which traders have to buy into or get left out in the cold.
I'm not biassed, of course not. Yes, what a marvelous organization... One day I may need to get sucked into the same pit of desperation if the work dries up (Many of my potential customers going straight to same expensive "Trusty Bloke" sites).
I did mention earlier that as soon as I saw checkatrade my BP went up, post13, how right you are Justin.
 

Similar threads

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses Heating 2 Go Electrician Workwear Supplier
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Advert

Daily, weekly or monthly email

Thread Information

Title
Advice needed - problem electrician
Prefix
N/A
Forum
UK Electrical Forum
Start date
Last reply date
Replies
48

Advert

Thread statistics

Created
Garethspur,
Last reply from
Pete999,
Replies
48
Views
7,809

Advert