Toying around with the 'reactions' (likes)

[Admin]

Would you prefer it how it is now. With Agree and Disagree instead of 'like' which is a bit facebooky?

 

[Lou]

Can have the heart eyes as like maybe?

 

[Pete999]

As long as you dis dislike.

 

[MJPD29]

I do like having a negative reaction on it such as dislike but as we have seen it can always be abused

 

[static zap]

We are proud of our English . Agree / Disagree ?
("Much liked" sound's so similar to a school report)
..am in agreement (Thumbs up/down International !)

 

[Admin]

It is currently set to -1 reaction score too so it can affect the new badge.

 

[Pete999]

I do like having a negative reaction on it such as dislike but as we have seen it can always be abused

What about, "Agree" and "Not sure about that" or "What you talking about Lewis" Different strokes, to much? thought so.

 

[pirate]

"Like" is nice..."agree" is nice too...
they are similar...
but if you don't like, you are left with one alternative, which is "dislike", which is rather negative...
Like
Love
agree
brilliant
That's amazing

let's have all degrees of nice-ness, and a couple of degrees of not liking, such as
"dislike"
"disagree"
"are you mad!"

we should have them all!

and I still want a "WTF!" button...

 

[Pete999]

"Like" is nice..."agree" is nice too...
they are similar...
but if you don't like, you are left with one alternative, which is "dislike", which is rather negative...
Like
Love
agree
brilliant
That's amazing

let's have all degrees of nice-ness, and a couple of degrees of not liking, such as
"dislike"
"disagree"
"are you mad!"

we should have them all!

and I still want a "WTF!" button...

You trying to cause a riot Mate, remember be nice, snowflakes beware.

 

[Pete999]

What about, "Agree" and "Not sure about that" or "What you talking about Lewis" Different strokes, to much? thought so.

Of course, you could always have, "Resistance is futile" for disagree and "Make it so" for Agree

 

[westward10]

I preferred the old system minus the dumb.

 

[Admin]

We have some more coming don't worry. Might change the agree to a tick again though.

 

[James]

We have some more coming don't worry. Might change the agree to a tick again though.

I like the agree button, it is unambiguous.

This is at times a highly technical forum with many different opinions.
I do like the subtle difference between like and agree.

for instance,

a new diy member joins and says,
help me, what is wrong with my fuse box, it is tripping RCD no2 every day shortly before I get up at 7am.
There will be the following reply's, amongst others.

what time is your heating / immersion heater set to come on in the morning?
(like)

Have you had any work done recently?
(like)

it sounds like your immersion heater may be the problem, suggest you get a spark in to check it out.
(like)

I think the best thing to do would be to turn the timer on the hot water to off before you go to bed and see if it happens in the morning. if it still happens, do the same with your heating system. also check that there are no other things that come on at a pre set time first thing in the morning and try to rule them out by turning them off.
(agree)

 

[HappyHippyDad]

Would you like to have the 'thanks' button back?

Go on then Dan, if you must

 

[Admin]

Totally agree. And I didn't need to type this as I said it with a click.

The aim is to cut down on replies just saying 'yeah me too' because Google is hammering a good thread and not ranking it well because the first post is huge, the second post answers it, and the next 20 on the page are all short posts.

The problem there is we have tags and usernames and avatars being displayed and repeated around just a couple of words.

So Google is like hmmmm that thread isn't unique it's the same as the other 10 created that day. Can't be important. Don't rank it well.

So I'm just trying to help the forum out long term kinda thing.
[automerge]1566678106[/automerge]

Go on then Dan, if you must

I can actually bring it back soon matey. Gimme a bit of time.

 

[DPG]

Personally I think the old system was better.

 

[davesparks]

The aim is to cut down on replies just saying 'yeah me too' because Google is hammering a good thread and not ranking it well because the first post is huge, the second post answers it, and the next 20 on the page are all short posts.

That's going to be pretty tough because we are all humans and react like humans expressing our opinions.
We lend weight to a valid post by posting our own reply agreeing with it because a click of a button doesn't feel right an dinky gets noticed by computers. Real people like to make and see real replies.

 

[static zap]

I've used Sad face for Dislike ,
(Disagree is getting as good as "Don't Do it" !)
( I still enjoyed handing out some Medals )

--Or should I not be trusted - (too generous)--?

 

[Admin]

Thread cleared up. Keep it on topic.

 

[Pete999]

Go on then Dan, if you must

Yes, really thank you very much Dan, this 5 words nonsense is annoying.

 

[Admin]

Yes, really thank you very much Dan, this 5 words nonsense is annoying.

Annoying but important. We need less one word replies. It does the forum harm with too many.

 

[Pete999]

Annoying but important. We need less one word replies. It does the forum harm with too many.

just kidding Dan a a a

 

[MDJ]

Prefer like than agree myself

 

[pirate]

I'm not going to rise to it this time...
Tel?

 

[telectrix]

I'm not going to rise to it this time...
Tel?

rise? your ship sunk again? down in Davy Jones's locker?

 

[pirate]

Ship's fine, Tel!
I meant the glaring grammar problem...

 

[Deleted account]

Personally I think the old system was better.

The old system was ok except the dumb and the dislike. It caused confrontation and bad feeling.

If you think the answer is dumb or disagree then you should state why and what you think rather than hide behind a tag.

A response feels more constructive than critical.

 

[DPG]

The old system was ok except the dumb and the dislike. It caused confrontation and bad feeling.

If you think the answer is dumb or disagree then you should state why and what you think rather than hide behind a tag.

A response feels more constructive than critical.

Yeah I agree about the dumb one.