Discuss LED Strip Lighting Installation - Some Specific Queries in the Lighting Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Welcome to ElectriciansForums.net - The American Electrical Advice Forum
Head straight to the main forums to chat by click here:   American Electrical Advice Forum

The problem with having such a large power supply is if you get a short on the strip. The PCB tracks are nowhere near the 2.5mm you would probably need to safely carry that current. And due to the resistance of those tracks, a short wont always allow a high enough fault current to trigger the power supply overcurrent protection. So you could end up with 15A flowing through the strip, which can heat it enough to cause a fire. Also, its not easy to attach a cable that thick to the strip, so people tend to wire in in much thinner cable.

I have to disagree. As mentioned before all 20amps are not being forced from the power supply to the strip. The strip is drawing what power it needs from the power supply. So if this strip is only 3amps it draws that from the power supply. If the strip has a short circuit it will react the same on any power supply.
It you have 3amps worth of strip on a 3amp or 20amp power supply it doesn't affect the strip it just draws the 3amps.
The main thing that maybe you are thinking is that the whole 20amps is going to one strip, this wouldnt be the case, as how the stips would be wired is in parralel, so 4 x say 5amp strips wired into one receiver and one 20amp power supply.
 
I have to disagree. As mentioned before all 20amps are not being forced from the power supply to the strip. The strip is drawing what power it needs from the power supply. So if this strip is only 3amps it draws that from the power supply. If the strip has a short circuit it will react the same on any power supply.
It you have 3amps worth of strip on a 3amp or 20amp power supply it doesn't affect the strip it just draws the 3amps.
The main thing that maybe you are thinking is that the whole 20amps is going to one strip, this wouldnt be the case, as how the stips would be wired is in parralel, so 4 x say 5amp strips wired into one receiver and one 20amp power supply.
The strips would only draw 3amps under normal conditions, but a short circuit would behave in the same way as on any circuit, causing the resistance of the circuit to decrease and the current to increase.

Its exactly the same as a lighting circuit in your house. You could supply it from a 400A fuse and it would only draw an amp or 2 at most. But you need an OCPD to protect against a fault.
 
Im not sure what you mean by saying the 20amp is not safe on the 12v side?
So if you have 50w of LED strip on a 240w power supply the LED strip will draw the 50w from the power supply. Therefore not a constant 240w. Maybe i'm misunderstanding something? But ive never heard any of our electrician customers add fuses to LED strips for this very standard project requirement.

An unused supply with the capacity to deliver 20A is dangerous as it can deliver more current than an LED strip can safely handle.
If a short circuit were to occur at the far end of the strip then this could allow 20A to flow through the strip which is likely only designed to have around 3A flow through it, this prevents a risk of fire.
Not fusing LED loads fed from power supplies of this size is madness and very bad practice.
 
An unused supply with the capacity to deliver 20A is dangerous as it can deliver more current than an LED strip can safely handle.
If a short circuit were to occur at the far end of the strip then this could allow 20A to flow through the strip which is likely only designed to have around 3A flow through it, this prevents a risk of fire.
Not fusing LED loads fed from power supplies of this size is madness and very bad practice.
Thanks for the replies,
How about your thoughts on the project in the thread which is the actual common use.
So for example,
A 20amp power supply to power 4 x 5 amp led strip lengths ( 4 strips wired in parralel). Are you saying if one of the 5amp strips had a short circuit it would be receiving 20amps even though 15 amps are being used by the the other strips?
 
Thanks for the replies,
How about your thoughts on the project in the thread which is the actual common use.
So for example,
A 20amp power supply to power 4 x 5 amp led strip lengths ( 4 strips wired in parralel). Are you saying if one of the 5amp strips had a short circuit it would be receiving 20amps even though 15 amps are being used by the the other strips?

It would probably use close to 20A
A short will have a low resistance compared to the other loads and draw far more current
 
It would probably use close to 20A
A short will have a low resistance compared to the other loads and draw far more current

Just looking into this and the power supplies we have used have short circuit protection. Maybe this is why ive never heard of this being an issue
See image:LED Strip Lighting Installation - Some Specific Queries IMG-20190608-WA0028 - EletriciansForums.net
 
Thanks for the replies,
How about your thoughts on the project in the thread which is the actual common use.
So for example,
A 20amp power supply to power 4 x 5 amp led strip lengths ( 4 strips wired in parralel). Are you saying if one of the 5amp strips had a short circuit it would be receiving 20amps even though 15 amps are being used by the the other strips?

It all depends on exactly how the power supply behaves in this situation, the resistance of the fault etc etc.
This is obviously very simplified and assuming the power supply has an output limited/fixed at 20A, but the majority of the 20A will flow via the fault in accordance with the bahaviour of resistances in parallel. Some current will continue to flow via the other loads, but most will flow through the fault.
I've installed a lot of LED strip and use one driver per strip or fuse each strip.
If I'm feeding multiple LED loads from one driver I usually fit it in a rittal box with fused din terminals to feed each load.
 
Just looking into this and the power supplies we have used have short circuit protection. Maybe this is why ive never heard of this being an issue
See image:View attachment 49902

That will only work if the short is a dead short, if the fault has some impedance the result will still be fire.
A elv supply such of this should be treated the same as at any other voltage as far as the provision of ocpds appropriate to the load is concerned.
 
Just looking into this and the power supplies we have used have short circuit protection. Maybe this is why ive never heard of this being an issue
See image:View attachment 49902

It doesn’t state how it deals with over current or short circuit protection.
I.e. is it current limiting and reducing the voltage to cap at 20A
Or a shutdown of psu until power cycled?
Or another method?

If it is capable of providing 20A then every part of the circuit after that point needs to be able to deal with carrying 20A without overheating.
 
As far as I know these PSUs just turn off their output if the load goes over 20 amps. A short at the end of a strip wont always exceed that current and so the PSU may well be seeing a load of 18 amps for example, which wont activate its protection. Someone made a youtube video where they measured the resistance of a 5m length of strip and the potential short circuit current if you shorted the end furthest from the PSU. This demonstrated on most strips that a high enough current to cause oveeheating/fire could be drawn, but not high enough to trip the PSU. I cant remember the exact values they used.

If, as in your example, you are running 4 strips from one 20A power supply, you can feed each one via a 5A fuse to protect them.
 
If it is capable of providing 20A then every part of the circuit after that point needs to be able to deal with carrying 20A without overheating.

Exactly, as in any other circuit design. You need to make sure the circuit (to the end of the strip) has a low enough impedance to activate the protective device (be that fuse or overload protection in the psu) before the strip catches fire.
 
One of the problems here, is the proposal to conceal some of the wiring in the wall.
LV (230V) wiring will need additional protection:
At a depth greater than 50mm.
Earthed sleeve.
Earthed containment.
Mechanical protection.
Or be run in a prescribed route and provided with RCD protection.

ELV (< 50V ac or 120V dc) will not required additional protection.
 
If anyone is interested, here's some pics:

The power supply remained unchanged (2.5MM fed), but is in an enclosure and i added a 3A fuse to the input cabling. The enclosure also dampened the sound to point it isn't discernible outside the loft space

The 2.5mm cabling is inside the wall (its deeper than 50 and in a proper protective conduit)

Used ScrewFix uplight coving as was vastly cheaper than anything else I found and looks far better than any of the polystyrene options (kind of like a picture rail)

Thanks to everyone for their input and help.
 

Attachments

  • LED Strip Lighting Installation - Some Specific Queries 20190606_193019 - EletriciansForums.net
    20190606_193019.jpg
    709.9 KB · Views: 8
  • LED Strip Lighting Installation - Some Specific Queries 20190606_205615 - EletriciansForums.net
    20190606_205615.jpg
    927.3 KB · Views: 11
  • LED Strip Lighting Installation - Some Specific Queries 20190606_205633 - EletriciansForums.net
    20190606_205633.jpg
    1 MB · Views: 8
  • LED Strip Lighting Installation - Some Specific Queries 20190606_205703 - EletriciansForums.net
    20190606_205703.jpg
    919.2 KB · Views: 10

Reply to LED Strip Lighting Installation - Some Specific Queries in the Lighting Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock