Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Jimmy you're in the clear man, you might get to laugh at him if he comes back with his tail between his legs if you're lucky.
I do want him to experience the real world prices of a spark, the only fear back in mind is that the only other out come is that it's a collection of the 3 circuits earth leakage and the cooker is the demand that is tipping The leakage, but like I said all the circuit were above 100. But I just didn't think that the cooker would trip out at 1 meg, so like I said to tell my critical thinking mind I come up with the theory that when it's heating up, it all expands creating the fault. I think I get to laugh anyway because I know I do him a good price and he'll realise that when needing a sparky next.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

I may be wrong as I trained under a previous version of the regs here but is it not a requirement that the testing includes a functional test? ie. turn it all on and make sure it works.

Or is it just me being daft by using common sense when I check that everything works as expected/intended after energising an installation or completeing all other tests on an EICR?

If I have read the OP correctly (not much chance with the state of the written english there) then the fault on the oven is occuring after it has been on for a while ie. its a faulty element which only shorts once it has warmed up a bit and everything has expanded. Basic oven element fault is that one, just test to make sure and then change the element, no need to go changing the whole appliance is there?

Did you even open the oven up to see if there was just a trapped neutral inside it? this is more common than you would think.
Don't understand that Dave. You are saying don't do I/R with loads connected as not in regs (but would really help) but are ok with taking oven apart which is definatly outside BS7671 scope and not his job to do. ?
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Never do financial favours in business... The favour should be in the form of the support and service... Lol
if there was no load equipment when you tested, have faith in your ability and if recalled when things have been connected, go straight to them and eliminate them first.
sounds like you're in the clear, so put it all down to experience ..
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

I may be wrong as I trained under a previous version of the regs here but is it not a requirement that the testing includes a functional test? ie. turn it all on and make sure it works.

Or is it just me being daft by using common sense when I check that everything works as expected/intended after energising an installation or completeing all other tests on an EICR?

If I have read the OP correctly (not much chance with the state of the written english there) then the fault on the oven is occuring after it has been on for a while ie. its a faulty element which only shorts once it has warmed up a bit and everything has expanded. Basic oven element fault is that one, just test to make sure and then change the element, no need to go changing the whole appliance is there?

Did you even open the oven up to see if there was just a trapped neutral inside it? this is more common than you would think.

i wasn't originally there to do the oven. I was there to actually do a EICR, he needed a satisfactory certificate. I said that it was in his best interest to upgrade the board rather than just souring certain certain circuits from the board on a RCD. I changed the board. When the tenant moved in all was good, the oven was on for about 20 minutes and then tripped. The board had already been upgraded, he wanted me to go back because he blamed the work that I had carried out - does this make sense.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Never do financial favours in business... The favour should be in the form of the support and service... Lol
if there was no load equipment when you tested, have faith in your ability and if recalled when things have been connected, go straight to them and eliminate them first.
sounds like you're in the clear, so put it all down to experience ..
Yer amen to that.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

I think what Dave means is that if you'd done a functional test on the oven you might have found it before all this but I have to say, if I'm doing a domestic EICR I don't go round checking the appliances so I'd have missed this one too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Of course, if it looked like a dodgy secondhand oven that's been stood dormant in a damp shed for years before the landlord bought it, I could suggest turning every element up to max, whipping out the earth conductor and standing well clear! Lol
after 5-10 mins the fault may clear... And at the worse there would be a bloody great hole in the faulty element or the remnants of a faulty stat controller splattered around the kitchen ;-)
..... But obviously that is well outside the scope of bs7671 ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Thanks meggerman need to refresh my knowledge of building regs then. Wasn't aware or the hob requirement, just the sink...
not the id have anything that close anyhow. :-)
As long as I don't see one directly behind the hob, I don't have a problem with it. The majority a directly to one side.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Has the oven been sat dormant for a while? Or is it a new oven with the protective element coating causing the issue?
Cookers are notorious for this... There are ways to confirm this and possibly rectify, but only experience will help you there...
I don't know, he simply argue that it was working before I changed the board.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Totally agree Trev about an EICR but we're talking about a db change here and the install of a RCD into the system. Common-sense would be to quickly test any loads before walking away.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Of course, if it looked like a dodgy secondhand oven that's been stood dormant in a damp shed for years before the landlord bought it, I could suggest turning every element up to max, whipping out the earth conductor and standing well clear! Lol
after 5-10 mins the fault may clear... And at the worse there would be a bloody great hole in the faulty element or the remnants of a faulty stat controller splattered around the kitchen ;-)
..... But obviously that is well outside the scope of bs7671 ...

That is so true!! I did similar once. Cooker had been left in garage for couple of years. Had to run it on non-RCD side for 20 minutes to "dry it out" before switching it back over :)
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Don't understand that Dave. You are saying don't do I/R with loads connected as not in regs (but would really help) but are ok with taking oven apart which is definatly outside BS7671 scope and not his job to do. ?

No I said testing of appliances is not part of installation testing but that appliance testing was as far as I know also mandatory for rented properties.

BS7671 does not define the role of an electrician! it is a set of regulations for electrical installations.
Appliance repairs, especially cookers, is a normal part of an electricians job is it not?
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Totally agree Trev about an EICR but we're talking about a db change here and the install of a RCD into the system. Common-sense would be to quickly test any loads before walking away.
Even then mate, I don't do it. Appliances are not my problem and I've always spelt that out.
Would you stick the washing machine of for a cycle? :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Yes, well there was a shower recently put in by whom I don't know, no RCD, there was also a alteration to the boiler circuit from a wart heater which was wired upstairs to a combi which is now wired downstairs no RCD.he had 2 sockets within 300mm in the kitchen to the hob and sink, I know this is just in the building regs, but in my opinion it wAs a better outcome to upgrade the board rather than spuring out in such a tight space as I could only fit a 6 way board In the cupboard where the board was located.

If I am wrong please explain, cos I thought any alteration to a circuit then the whole circuit had to be done to the current regulations.

What the hell is a "wart heater"??

I thought the treatment for warts is to freeze them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

I think what Dave means is that if you'd done a functional test on the oven you might have found it before all this but I have to say, if I'm doing a domestic EICR I don't go round checking the appliances so I'd have missed this one too.

Yeah thats about it.

I wouldn't check appliances on an EICR, but after changing a CU and adding RCD protection I do check that the important appliances all work without tripping RCD's, Fridges and freezers, oven, immersion, boiler, kettle (naturally the most important ;) )
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Even then mate, I don't do it. Appliances are not my problem and I've always spelt that out.
Would you stick the washing machine of for a cycle? :)

Not plug in appliances, no Trev.
like I say, I've just learnt the hard way, I always do a quick check on immersions, boilers, water heaters, ovens, hobs, showers etc. surprising how nanny faulty ones I've found, and always easier to explain to the customer on site rather than have a call back at my expense...
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Age of alterations is irrelevant as far as EICR coding goes. If the alterations have recently been carried out other than in accordance with the regulations then the owner of the property should take it up with the person who did the work for him.
Well I was under the impression you test to the age of the installation, ie both works were carried out and should of been put on an RCD. Also maybe I am wrong, but who puts satisfactory when there is an electric shower with no RCD, just sends a shiver up my spine. I thought at the end of the day it comes down to the testers professional look at the regs are a guide.

Could I have said satisfactory then you think?
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

I've always hated wart heaters too Jimmy, I always thought they had to be frozen off :)


Haha ..... Snap bonny lad!!

I posted the exact same thing before I saw yours!

Geordie humour eh?? ;)
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Yeah thats about it.

I wouldn't check appliances on an EICR, but after changing a CU and adding RCD protection I do check that the important appliances all work without tripping RCD's, Fridges and freezers, oven, immersion, boiler, kettle (naturally the most important ;) )
Maybe I should rethink my standards as I've always only checked the kettle :)
NB I'm not saying I use the kettle as an installation tester :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

I think what Dave means is that if you'd done a functional test on the oven you might have found it before all this but I have to say, if I'm doing a domestic EICR I don't go round checking the appliances so I'd have missed this one too.
Yer but who turns ovens on for 20 minutes to check lol I see what you are saying.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 people
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Of course, if it looked like a dodgy secondhand oven that's been stood dormant in a damp shed for years before the landlord bought it, I could suggest turning every element up to max, whipping out the earth conductor and standing well clear! Lol
after 5-10 mins the fault may clear... And at the worse there would be a bloody great hole in the faulty element or the remnants of a faulty stat controller splattered around the kitchen ;-)
..... But obviously that is well outside the scope of bs7671 ...
Haha that made me laugh.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Yer but who turns ovens on for 20 minutes to check lol I see what you are saying.

20mins is a bit long, if an element is going to go faulty when hot it usually shows itself within 2 minutes
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Yeah thats about it.

I wouldn't check appliances on an EICR, but after changing a CU and adding RCD protection I do check that the important appliances all work without tripping RCD's, Fridges and freezers, oven, immersion, boiler, kettle (naturally the most important ;) )
There was nothing there only the oven and it originally took 20 minutes to trip, would you have seriously stood there waiting for 20 minutes!
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

Well I was under the impression you test to the age of the installation, ie both works were carried out and should of been put on an RCD. Also maybe I am wrong, but who puts satisfactory when there is an electric shower with no RCD, just sends a shiver up my spine. I thought at the end of the day it comes down to the testers professional look at the regs are a guide.

Could I have said satisfactory then you think?


No you inspect and test to the current version of the regulations, and code accordingly. New works which don't comply receive the same codes as 30 year old installations with teh same non-compliances.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

No you inspect and test to the current version of the regulations, and code accordingly. New works which don't comply receive the same codes as 30 year old installations with teh same non-compliances.
So a shower just on a mcb you would code c3?
Looks like I am too harsh then.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

My mrs recently new bezzy girl mates partner has some property, my mrs said, " my hubby do it for ya at a good rate "

joy i think. I had this gut feeling, you know the one! My mrs and her mate have been looking to get us two men friends, there was even talks of going camping, err don't think that will be happening now. Lol


Anyway, I will refer to him as the landlord but least you now know the connections.

The landlord URGENTLY needed to get a EICR pass certificate, so that the council would let him rent his property to one of their tenants. It's the weekend and I said " ok, I'd do it."

After doing a test, the test failed and I said it was in his best interest to just upgrade the whole board. Nothing was on a RCD, he had an electric shower recently installed as well as a boiler upgrade converted from a water heater tank to a combi no RCD . I charged him 350 total, (I hate favours) this included changing to metal light fitting to pendants cos no earth just a flex visible, installing another 2 lights that were off the wall, replace two 1 gang sockets, clipping a twin earth to wall in the out house and Changing a pull cord. Bonding from 6 to 10 mm. Also after removing the cooker switch had to extend the cables.

Anyway the tenant moves in on the Monday, uses the oven and the RCD trips. Great, I just knew it! I went round there, I disconnect the oven re-check the insulation of the 6mm cable as I need to lengthen the cables of the cooker socket after removing it, could of be a fault there. It reads 216 meg ohms, I check the oven it reads 0.96meg at first and slowly goes up every time it recheck it. I tell him it's the oven. I put the oven back In as it reads 3 meg the time I last check. It tripped again after about 10 minutes. I was there 2 hours.

He is under the impression that it is to do with the work I done and said in the form of a text, "well I thought you passed this property and it was good to go." I then politely explained that I only checked the fixed wiring. I also I hinted that I wanted extra money.

After much explaining and explaining the difference between mcb and RCD I told him that he needed a new oven. There was many texts thrown backward and forwards.

I ended saying, " look ! Don't worry about paying me for this extra call, there's nothing more I can do, you need a new oven and find another electrician. I didn't end it to professionally I know, but man I thought I was the one doing the favour, I did get annoyed with he constant questioning as if I am trying to rip him off saying well it was working before. I would be interested what he would of been charged by going to a local firm. I did Explain well there wasn't an RCD before and push in mcbs don't pick up this kind of fault.

he then started saying well he finds it rather strange, the guy told me he had his part p so you would expect he would understand what I was explaining.

Anyway now it's playing on mind. I just want to know now, will he get a oven, will he get another electrician out. cos sure what of he does replace the oven and it does still trip. Arrrrh ! Give me comfort someone lol also how would you deal with this professionally because having to send texting explaining how an RCD works and the difference between an RCD and mcb just didn't do it for me.


thanks in advance for any replies


Jim


i dont know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 3 people
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

6 pages in an hour, rockin' it! Only Tuesday.
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

So a shower just on a mcb you would code c3?
Looks like I am too harsh then.
Up until a few years ago, showers on an RCD was just a recommendation by the manufacturers ...
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

People will have you working 24/7 for favours. I don't do "favours" for anyone apart from my closest family. Some people think you run a charity rather than make a living. :)

Although, It's probably the oven element, a quick check and offering a price to change the element out might have been an answer he would have accepted. Then again if he is as bigger idiot as you describe probably not.

Anyway we live and learn.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

The shower would depend on any supplementary bonding too... If there is bonding it's only a code3
 
Re: RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A r

So a shower just on a mcb you would code c3?
Looks like I am too harsh then.

I haven't seen the installation have I? was bonding up to scratch, did the circuit have any other problems?
 

Similar threads

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses Heating 2 Go Electrician Workwear Supplier
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Advert

Daily, weekly or monthly email

Thread starter

Joined
Location
Clacton

Thread Information

Title
RCD trip after board upgrade. Frustration who on my side? Who's on landlords? A rant!
Prefix
N/A
Forum
UK Electrical Forum
Start date
Last reply date
Replies
103

Advert

Thread statistics

Created
JiMMySnoW,
Last reply from
specs,
Replies
103
Views
10,139

Advert