Discuss Battery/UPS for home with leased solar PV, looking for hardware & installer in the Solar PV Forum | Solar Panels Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

piorunz

DIY
Reaction score
0
Hi all,

I am looking for battery/UPS system to install in my home, so I have power in sockets in the rooms when mains AC is off.

I have leased solar panels installation on the roof, it comes with inverter, smart meter etc., I can't modify their unit. But their power could re-charge battery/UPS very nicely. Problem is, solar panels don't work when mains AC is off (blackout). So I need some UPS system to tell solar panels "hey, there is electricity, keep working", so panels continue to power home and re-charge UPS during the day.
Also nice feature would be ability to run home on UPS during the night and re-charge again during the day with solar.

I am looking for installer to install UPS/battery system for me as described. I am in Bristol. Please PM.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You will really really struggle to keep the PV system running without a mains connection. The inverters, as a condition of being able to connect to the mains supply, MUST detect islanded operation and shut down. Islanded simply means that part of the distribution has become separated from the rest fo the grid (like an island) - that island could range in size from your own house to part of the town. It's to protect against having a significant embedded generation capacity continuing to power the grid when it should be off - with obvious dangers to anyone trying to work on it, or even just to other users.
So you would need to create a "hard" mains simulation in order to keep the voltage, frequency, and rate of change of frequency steady enough to avoid tripping the protection in the inverter - and without the mechanical inertia in the grid, I think you'll find that impractical.

Your best option would be to tap into the DC connection between panels and inverter, and charge the batteries from there. But that's one of the problems with a leased system - it's not yours to fiddle with, and TBH I'd not consider ever buying a house with such an arrangement due to this and a few other reasons (some lenders won't give a mortgage either). If you could do that, then you'd float the batteries normally, but run your house with a stand alone inverter powered from them. During a power cut, it would depend on the amount of sunshine and the loads you plug in as to whether the PV panels supply all the power or wether you run the batteries down as well - but in any case, you'd need the batteries to deal with (e.g.) a cloud passing over if you don't want everything going off intermittently.
Depending on conditions (size of batteries, load, amount of sunshine, frequency/length of power cuts) you may be able to recharge just from the PV panels, or you might need a mains powered charger to supplement them.
 
You will really really struggle to keep the PV system running without a mains connection. The inverters, as a condition of being able to connect to the mains supply, MUST detect islanded operation and shut down. Islanded simply means that part of the distribution has become separated from the rest fo the grid (like an island) - that island could range in size from your own house to part of the town. It's to protect against having a significant embedded generation capacity continuing to power the grid when it should be off - with obvious dangers to anyone trying to work on it, or even just to other users.
So you would need to create a "hard" mains simulation in order to keep the voltage, frequency, and rate of change of frequency steady enough to avoid tripping the protection in the inverter - and without the mechanical inertia in the grid, I think you'll find that impractical.

Your best option would be to tap into the DC connection between panels and inverter, and charge the batteries from there. But that's one of the problems with a leased system - it's not yours to fiddle with, and TBH I'd not consider ever buying a house with such an arrangement due to this and a few other reasons (some lenders won't give a mortgage either). If you could do that, then you'd float the batteries normally, but run your house with a stand alone inverter powered from them. During a power cut, it would depend on the amount of sunshine and the loads you plug in as to whether the PV panels supply all the power or wether you run the batteries down as well - but in any case, you'd need the batteries to deal with (e.g.) a cloud passing over if you don't want everything going off intermittently.
Depending on conditions (size of batteries, load, amount of sunshine, frequency/length of power cuts) you may be able to recharge just from the PV panels, or you might need a mains powered charger to supplement them.

Thanks for your reply.

I run some numbers:
PV stats
41586 hours, 20000 kWh, 1732.75 working days
11.5 kWh produced per day

My energy use at electric meter
17736 kWh, 1110 days
16.0 kWh used per day

So looks like, on average, with simple battery system, I can supply 70% of my electricity from solar panels, for like 17 hours a day. That's why I want to do it. Right now, when mains are off, I have 0% supply from solar panels. Upgrade from 0 to 70% is significant improvement. Let's say during cloudy days, winter, bad weather, I may have only 6 hours or even less, still that's better than zero.
I am aware of limitations of leased PV, thanks for pointing out more details. I can't modify it. What if I buy UPS battery system, install it, and just leave DC plug empty - to be connected only during blackout? That way, in normal operation I keep everything as it should be, but during blackout, I go to the loft, unplug DC cable from leased inverter and plug it in to UPS battery system, to charge it? This manual setup will not mess up with my leased equipment at all (no cutting wires, no changes), and leased inverter and power meter is offline during blackout anyway. When power is back, I would switch DC cable back to their inverter. What you think?

I encountered this UPS system:

9.6 kWh storage, if I understand correctly, on average, solar PV can charge it in full (as it averages out to 11.5 kWh per day). I think installing this, plus option of connecting DC cable from panels manually during blackout, could work. What is your opinion?
 
I assume your idea will be to run most of your stuff off this all the time, powered from the mains. Then when the mains is off, connect the PV panels to it to extend the run time. And when the mains is back, return the PV panels to the leased inverter.
Well that would work. You could probably automate it as well - a box, suitable relay, some DC connectors, rig it up so that if the mains is off it automatically switches the PV DC connection over. If they come to service the system, just unplug your box and hide it away till they've gone.

BUT, will it actually pay for itself ? You're shelling out £2,200 plug whatever extras (cabling and connectors to connect to the PV system). How many power cuts do you normally get, and how long are they ? And do they tend to happen mostly in summer (long days, lots of sun) or winter (short days, little sun) ?
It's not clear from your numbers whether your usage takes account of the PV generation - are you using 16kWH or 4.5kWH of imported electricity ? Or put another way, are you using 16kWH total, of which 11.5 comes from the PV and 4.5 from the grid; or are you using 27.5kWH of which 11.5 comes from the PV and 16 comes from the grid ?

You need to work out :
How long, on average, you will actually be able to run on battery + solar. E.g. if you typically have a 4 hour power cut every week, and they are mostly in the middle of the day, then that's going to mean a daily average of 4/7th of an hour. If we take an "average" day of 12 hours, then you are producing less than 1kW, so you'll actually get to use in the order of 0.5kWH/day of solar via your system.
And what it's going to "earn" from your PV. At current prices, it's going to be in the order of £70 to £90/year. Doesn't seem like a good investment to me.
Of course, if having power through those power cuts is the difference between doing nothing and doing paid work, then you could value the system in terms of how many more billable hours you can do - in which case it might be worth it.

As for "use battery at night, recharge during the day", I suspect that you won't have enough margin of generation over consumption to be able to recharge from the PV most of the time. That will depend a lot on your usage profile. If you use your lecky over (say) a 16 hour day, and then are using little while you're asleep the other 8 hours, your usage is around 1kW average. During summer you may have enough margin to charge for a few hours mid-day, but most of the time you won't. But working all that out really means having a good idea of both your generation and usage profiles so you can work out how long you actually have excess PV production for.
And even if the figures say it'll work, you need something fairly advanced that can monitor your net lecky import/export so that you can charge the batteries at just the rate that will reduce your export to nothing - and use the charge in them to reduce your net import when you don't have excess PV production.
I could imagine that there are products out there that will do it - but I also suspect that they won't be cost effective, especially as you can't integrate your PV panels to your own system. Ideally the system would be one unit with mains, battery, and PV DC connections which manages it all itself - but that would require that you be able to remove the existing inverter.

And on that last bit, is there an option to buy out the lease so that you own the system and can then adapt it ? From what I've seen, these "rent a roof" schemes (which is what I assume you have) are generally not a good deal for the home owner other than not having to find the up-front capital to install the system.
 
Thanks for your reply!

I assume your idea will be to run most of your stuff off this all the time, powered from the mains. Then when the mains is off, connect the PV panels to it to extend the run time. And when the mains is back, return the PV panels to the leased inverter.
Well that would work.

Thanks. that's great news!
You could probably automate it as well - a box, suitable relay, some DC connectors, rig it up so that if the mains is off it automatically switches the PV DC connection over. If they come to service the system, just unplug your box and hide it away till they've gone.

Roger that.
BUT, will it actually pay for itself ? You're shelling out £2,200 plug whatever extras (cabling and connectors to connect to the PV system). How many power cuts do you normally get, and how long are they ? And do they tend to happen mostly in summer (long days, lots of sun) or winter (short days, little sun) ?

I need this to have peace of mind. I don't want to have blackout one day, for days when I have solar panels on the roof which could power me for 4, 6 or 8 hours every day, for free. I prefer to have a backup, independent from mains AC provider. That £2200 plus labour and some optional parts, is not much to spend, but a lot to gain.

It's not clear from your numbers whether your usage takes account of the PV generation - are you using 16kWH or 4.5kWH of imported electricity ? Or put another way, are you using 16kWH total, of which 11.5 comes from the PV and 4.5 from the grid; or are you using 27.5kWH of which 11.5 comes from the PV and 16 comes from the grid ?

You got me thinking, yes, my calculations were incorrect, thanks.

I use 16 kWh per day on my meter. But that excludes energy which flows through the house during the day hours, when PV generates their 11.5 kWh on their meter. I don't pay for that on my meter, PV gives that to me for free. If I don't use it, I see red LED on my meter and electricity is being exported to the grid.

So I must be using 16 kWh (imported) plus up to 11.5 kWh from solar. In reality, almost always I see red light during sunny days, meaning I don't use all solar generation and some of it is being exported. On cloudy days, I don't see red LED, so I must be using all PV generation at the time.

Realistically, I must be using between 25% and 75% of what solar generates. So I am using 16 kWh plus 2.875 or 8.625 = 18.9 kWh up to 24.6 kWh.

I think this is now more accurate number now.

You need to work out :
How long, on average, you will actually be able to run on battery + solar. E.g. if you typically have a 4 hour power cut every week, and they are mostly in the middle of the day, then that's going to mean a daily average of 4/7th of an hour. If we take an "average" day of 12 hours, then you are producing less than 1kW, so you'll actually get to use in the order of 0.5kWH/day of solar via your system.

And what it's going to "earn" from your PV. At current prices, it's going to be in the order of £70 to £90/year. Doesn't seem like a good investment to me.

As I mentioned, I am buying myself backup power source. I can't have PV and not use it, if there is a crisis and there is no power at all. That would be such a waste of solar panels ability to produce electricity. I would like to use it during blackout. And I do have some blackouts where I live and that's a pain. £220 system will give me total immunity from 1-4 hours blackouts.

Of course, if having power through those power cuts is the difference between doing nothing and doing paid work, then you could value the system in terms of how many more billable hours you can do - in which case it might be worth it.

As for "use battery at night, recharge during the day", I suspect that you won't have enough margin of generation over consumption to be able to recharge from the PV most of the time. That will depend a lot on your usage profile. If you use your lecky over (say) a 16 hour day, and then are using little while you're asleep the other 8 hours, your usage is around 1kW average. During summer you may have enough margin to charge for a few hours mid-day, but most of the time you won't. But working all that out really means having a good idea of both your generation and usage profiles so you can work out how long you actually have excess PV production for.
And even if the figures say it'll work, you need something fairly advanced that can monitor your net lecky import/export so that you can charge the batteries at just the rate that will reduce your export to nothing - and use the charge in them to reduce your net import when you don't have excess PV production.
I could imagine that there are products out there that will do it - but I also suspect that they won't be cost effective, especially as you can't integrate your PV panels to your own system. Ideally the system would be one unit with mains, battery, and PV DC connections which manages it all itself - but that would require that you be able to remove the existing inverter.

And on that last bit, is there an option to buy out the lease so that you own the system and can then adapt it ? From what I've seen, these "rent a roof" schemes (which is what I assume you have) are generally not a good deal for the home owner other than not having to find the up-front capital to install the system.

If we assume I use from 18.9 up to 24.6 kWh per day, and solar panels generate 11.5 kWh per day, I need extra 7.4 up to 13.1 kWh per day from battery, to run for entire day.

"UPS 5kW System with 9.6kWh Energy Storage" for £2200 won't cover that completely, but then it will re-charge next day, on average, to full capacity again, using 11.5 kWh which solar panels produce per day (if I don't use any electricity). I will have to cut electricity use drastically and I will, otherwise I won't charge battery at all as you said.

But still, ability to have some of electricity I need, thanks to ~£3k investment, is good enough option. Without UPS System I have 0 kWh to use. With UPS, I enable solar PV to work without mains, and I will have from like 1 kWh (very cloudy day) to 11.5 kWh (average). I'd like that.

For "use battery at night, recharge during the day", I can worry about that later. I will call PV company see what are my buyout options. If there is none, would you say "UPS 5kW System with 9.6kWh Energy Storage" for £2200 is best I can get, taking into account all limitations of this scenario?
Thanks for your time!
 
I wanted to do some edits to fix repetitions in my post, but exceeded 20 minutes allowed.

To sum up reasoning behind this:

Without ~£3k UPS investment, I have 0 kWh available from first minute of mains being switched off. Total blackout.


With ~£3k UPS investment, I am totally immune to typical 1-4 hours blackouts.
After 24h blackout, I will live - I'll have enough to run fridge, freezer, microwave and boiler. And charge my phone & laptop. I can turn everything else off. This is good enough!
 
I wanted to do some edits to fix repetitions in my post, but exceeded 20 minutes allowed.

To sum up reasoning behind this:

Without ~£3k UPS investment, I have 0 kWh available from first minute of mains being switched off. Total blackout.

With ~£3k UPS investment, I am totally immune to typical 1-4 hours blackouts.
After 24h blackout, I will live - I'll have enough to run fridge, freezer, microwave and boiler. And charge my phone & laptop. I can turn everything else off. This is good enough!
I've changed the time limit to 90 minutes. If you're quick, you'll be able to make your edits. :)
 
I would wait till you find if there is an option to buy out the lease - your options and "best" choice may change.
But with your current leasing arrangement, the option you've picked would work.
 

Reply to Battery/UPS for home with leased solar PV, looking for hardware & installer in the Solar PV Forum | Solar Panels Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

I am a Napit registered electrician and want to get into Solar PV and battery storage. I have boot camp booked in April but am not hearing good...
Replies
1
Views
350
Greetings, everyone, After dedicating over a month to researching Solar PV systems, I'm nearly ready to make a decision. I owe my progress to...
Replies
1
Views
903
  • Article
Electrical2Go - Green2go Launches for All Your Solar, EV Charging and Renewable Needs Green2Go - for All Your Solar, EV Charging and Renewable...
Replies
1
Views
293
Help please, this is my first post on this subject regarding solar panel / battery installation into house with 3 phase supply. I am a DIY level...
Replies
0
Views
1K
Hello fellow professionals, I'm currently facing a challenging scenario that involves the integration of solar photovoltaic (PV) systems on roofs...
Replies
1
Views
264

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock