Discuss Sign off A.N.Other builders work in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Good evening gents,

Just to clear up a bit of confusion surrounding these proposed changes, there was a link to the changes on here a few weeks ago which a lot of us read.

You should NOT be asked to provide an EIC for any work that you have not carried out, the changes DO NOT allow for that.

You WILL be able to prepare, through prior arrangement with BC, an EICR within, I think 3 weeks, after completion of the work. This is, apparently, what BC will be happy with - bless their ill-informed hearts.

Hope this helps clear it up a little,

Chris
 
There are two ways of looking at this though, what if customer is a lovely genuine person and the builder disappeares for whatever reason (dispute/dies/taken seriously I'll etc) are some of you saying the customer should have the extention pulled down and started again because it is not possible to check his work to get certs required?
Or should there be something in place that a proffesional from a trade body should be able to check any works to make sure it complies to any regs, for a fee of course, and issue the appropriate paperwork?
 
There are two ways of looking at this though, what if customer is a lovely genuine person and the builder disappeares for whatever reason (dispute/dies/taken seriously I'll etc) are some of you saying the customer should have the extention pulled down and started again because it is not possible to check his work to get certs required?
Or should there be something in place that a proffesional from a trade body should be able to check any works to make sure it complies to any regs, for a fee of course, and issue the appropriate paperwork?

There was something in place - LABC will normally accept an EICR!

The problem is now the changes have "legitimised" the dodgy builder and the cowboy sparky who will sign off an EIC without even getting out his MFT!
 
Good evening gents

What about the females in the forum? I become Loretta at the weekends so im not sure what category I would fall into...
Yes its off topic but its Friday and ive just been paid.... Im happy.
 
Any females in the industry learn from day one they accept being part of the gents/lads etc or it won't work out. I find it a lot more awkward when people add 'oh and lady' at the end!!
 
earthstore a genuine customer will have notified building control who will have informed him/her that the electrics need inspecting at first fix so the council will no its safe. its the people that go for the cheapest quote that are the problem, they're happy as larry when the think they can save a few quid on employing an electrician so they can buy a new tv but when the builder buggers off and they realise they have no eic they want you to bend the rules for them. so yes pull it down.
 
There are two ways of looking at this though, what if customer is a lovely genuine person and the builder disappeares for whatever reason (dispute/dies/taken seriously I'll etc) are some of you saying the customer should have the extention pulled down and started again because it is not possible to check his work to get certs required?
Or should there be something in place that a proffesional from a trade body should be able to check any works to make sure it complies to any regs, for a fee of course, and issue the appropriate paperwork?

That's just a cop-out to be honest. Yes, there are nice customers who will have been taken for a ride by the builder, but let's face it, most of the "sign it off after with an EICR" brigade are builders who want to do it all on the cheap, then get someone registered to sort it all out afterwards.
It is the duty of the person ordering the work to ensure that whoever is carrying out the electrical work is either part P registered, or they should be notifying LBC in advance and doing it by the book.
I'm sick and tired of all this mamby pamby "turn a blind eye" rubbish which just makes our trade a laughing stock.
If the customer allows the builder to do the work to save money, then they are their own worst enemy, and I have no sympathy. If, on the other hand, the electrician has done a runner without issuing certs, there should be a thorough investigation involving checking of prescribed zones/junction boxes etc., which will allow for a "special" EICR also involving LBC to sort the situation out in exceptional circumstances. If this involves removing parts of walls or ceilings then so be it.
While you guys, along with LBC just say "oh well, let's just have a quick test of what Bob the builder has done", the trade will just keep going downhill!
 
I've GOT to come in on this!

You all NEED to go to the IET website and download a set of 17th edition amendment 1, forms. It's 400Kb in pdf format. AND FREE to use, just need paper and a printer to make them and they are perfectly legal and haven't been 'doctored' by any scheme operators to fit nicely on a page with room for their logo!

Periodic is no longer valid for Part P work, has to be an EICR. It's to replace the periodic AND to use to find the 'condition' of any installation apart from actually where the burried parts of the circuit run. (Periodics can still be used for commercial & industrial work)
But IF you do it thoroughly then it WILL be safe and with a RCD on EVERT circuit that has burried cables then anyone inadvertantly damaging them will be protected.

OFTEN building work is taken on as a complete package INCLUDING being the customers agent for the B.C. so the customer never get to see anything to do with B.C.
Yes often the lowest price is accepted so builders get in cheap subbies and often go bust.

Do the EICR but charge for it as it'll take a day at least on a small property if you've done it right. There are several pages of specific question on the regulations so you will have lied if you tick the box and it doesn't comply.
BUT you can't do it unless your scheme operator has specifically approved you to do them as it does take experience and knowledge to check installations you never put in, (what a periodic was and I bet very few of them have EVER been done properly). Also you should have Proffessional Indemnity Insurance because you ARE giving a proffessional opinion on someone else's work so if after, someone gets hurt or killed then YOUR EICR will be investigated and it could be a very long time in goal for causing death or injury!

Ever since I've been Part P registered I've asked all concerned (had a long running discorse with a guy in the IEE about why they didn't have individual circuit test forms as well as the summary!!) WHERE do you record all the test results that you take IF you test by the regulations???
I have my own forms I use and they don't half help when you go into properties done by cowboys, all your results are neatly tabulated so you can easily see where bridges, bad connection, the CPC's have been used as the third core for two way or the neutral for a heating thermostat upgrade.
Not one person, experienced qualified sparks included, have EVER been able to tell me WHERE they record all the readings they SHOULD take! You'd need to be Mr Memory if you can remember which reading was the worst and at what point for a circuit that will need testing at twenty points or more, (usually a lot more as you have to TEST for circuit continuity and that INCLUDES the CPC and most of those end at a light switch so that has to come off and the CPC recovered as it's usually been cut off out of the way!

ANYONE can sign the form if qualified, Part P or formally qualified electricians but LOADS of both will just sign and hope.
Me, as a Part P'er, would like the continuation of needing fuller qualifications as Part P goes along as that way everyone in the trade will eventually be formally qualified, but the biggest jump will be when they stop anyone but qualified people actually buying the materials like in a lot of other civilised countries. (Gas should be the same).

So you lot, download and read the forms and the guidance notes, all very self explanitory.

I've had a couple of female trainees over the years, great, pick it up quick and like to do it right. (Please don't come back with the usual sexual inuendo's to this.)
 
I've GOT to come in on this!

You all NEED to go to the IET website and download a set of 17th edition amendment 1, forms. It's 400Kb in pdf format. AND FREE to use, just need paper and a printer to make them and they are perfectly legal and haven't been 'doctored' by any scheme operators to fit nicely on a page with room for their logo!

Periodic is no longer valid for Part P work, has to be an EICR. It's to replace the periodic AND to use to find the 'condition' of any installation apart from actually where the burried parts of the circuit run. (Periodics can still be used for commercial & industrial work)
But IF you do it thoroughly then it WILL be safe and with a RCD on EVERT circuit that has burried cables then anyone inadvertantly damaging them will be protected.

OFTEN building work is taken on as a complete package INCLUDING being the customers agent for the B.C. so the customer never get to see anything to do with B.C.
Yes often the lowest price is accepted so builders get in cheap subbies and often go bust.

Do the EICR but charge for it as it'll take a day at least on a small property if you've done it right. There are several pages of specific question on the regulations so you will have lied if you tick the box and it doesn't comply.
BUT you can't do it unless your scheme operator has specifically approved you to do them as it does take experience and knowledge to check installations you never put in, (what a periodic was and I bet very few of them have EVER been done properly). Also you should have Proffessional Indemnity Insurance because you ARE giving a proffessional opinion on someone else's work so if after, someone gets hurt or killed then YOUR EICR will be investigated and it could be a very long time in goal for causing death or injury!

Ever since I've been Part P registered I've asked all concerned (had a long running discorse with a guy in the IEE about why they didn't have individual circuit test forms as well as the summary!!) WHERE do you record all the test results that you take IF you test by the regulations???
I have my own forms I use and they don't half help when you go into properties done by cowboys, all your results are neatly tabulated so you can easily see where bridges, bad connection, the CPC's have been used as the third core for two way or the neutral for a heating thermostat upgrade.
Not one person, experienced qualified sparks included, have EVER been able to tell me WHERE they record all the readings they SHOULD take! You'd need to be Mr Memory if you can remember which reading was the worst and at what point for a circuit that will need testing at twenty points or more, (usually a lot more as you have to TEST for circuit continuity and that INCLUDES the CPC and most of those end at a light switch so that has to come off and the CPC recovered as it's usually been cut off out of the way!

ANYONE can sign the form if qualified, Part P or formally qualified electricians but LOADS of both will just sign and hope.
Me, as a Part P'er, would like the continuation of needing fuller qualifications as Part P goes along as that way everyone in the trade will eventually be formally qualified, but the biggest jump will be when they stop anyone but qualified people actually buying the materials like in a lot of other civilised countries. (Gas should be the same).

So you lot, download and read the forms and the guidance notes, all very self explanitory.

I've had a couple of female trainees over the years, great, pick it up quick and like to do it right. (Please don't come back with the usual sexual inuendo's to this.)
of course its free to use....theres no need to get sexual...
 
I've GOT to come in on this!

You all NEED to go to the IET website and download a set of 17th edition amendment 1, forms. It's 400Kb in pdf format. AND FREE to use, just need paper and a printer to make them and they are perfectly legal and haven't been 'doctored' by any scheme operators to fit nicely on a page with room for their logo!

Periodic is no longer valid for Part P work, has to be an EICR. It's to replace the periodic AND to use to find the 'condition' of any installation apart from actually where the burried parts of the circuit run. (Periodics can still be used for commercial & industrial work)
But IF you do it thoroughly then it WILL be safe and with a RCD on EVERT circuit that has burried cables then anyone inadvertantly damaging them will be protected.

OFTEN building work is taken on as a complete package INCLUDING being the customers agent for the B.C. so the customer never get to see anything to do with B.C.
Yes often the lowest price is accepted so builders get in cheap subbies and often go bust.

Do the EICR but charge for it as it'll take a day at least on a small property if you've done it right. There are several pages of specific question on the regulations so you will have lied if you tick the box and it doesn't comply.
BUT you can't do it unless your scheme operator has specifically approved you to do them as it does take experience and knowledge to check installations you never put in, (what a periodic was and I bet very few of them have EVER been done properly). Also you should have Proffessional Indemnity Insurance because you ARE giving a proffessional opinion on someone else's work so if after, someone gets hurt or killed then YOUR EICR will be investigated and it could be a very long time in goal for causing death or injury!

Ever since I've been Part P registered I've asked all concerned (had a long running discorse with a guy in the IEE about why they didn't have individual circuit test forms as well as the summary!!) WHERE do you record all the test results that you take IF you test by the regulations???
I have my own forms I use and they don't half help when you go into properties done by cowboys, all your results are neatly tabulated so you can easily see where bridges, bad connection, the CPC's have been used as the third core for two way or the neutral for a heating thermostat upgrade.
Not one person, experienced qualified sparks included, have EVER been able to tell me WHERE they record all the readings they SHOULD take! You'd need to be Mr Memory if you can remember which reading was the worst and at what point for a circuit that will need testing at twenty points or more, (usually a lot more as you have to TEST for circuit continuity and that INCLUDES the CPC and most of those end at a light switch so that has to come off and the CPC recovered as it's usually been cut off out of the way!

ANYONE can sign the form if qualified, Part P or formally qualified electricians but LOADS of both will just sign and hope.
Me, as a Part P'er, would like the continuation of needing fuller qualifications as Part P goes along as that way everyone in the trade will eventually be formally qualified, but the biggest jump will be when they stop anyone but qualified people actually buying the materials like in a lot of other civilised countries. (Gas should be the same).

So you lot, download and read the forms and the guidance notes, all very self explanitory.

I've had a couple of female trainees over the years, great, pick it up quick and like to do it right. (Please don't come back with the usual sexual inuendo's to this.)

You can also get editable versions of the BS7671 forms on the forum :)

http://www.electriciansforums.net/i...ations/29798-new-eicr-editable-pdf-certs.html

Useful if you want to fill it out on your iPad or something and print the cert out later on (no need for software either, just the pdf reader thing) :)
 
I've GOT to come in on this!

You all NEED to go to the IET website and download a set of 17th edition amendment 1, forms. It's 400Kb in pdf format. AND FREE to use, just need paper and a printer to make them and they are perfectly legal and haven't been 'doctored' by any scheme operators to fit nicely on a page with room for their logo!

Periodic is no longer valid for Part P work, has to be an EICR. It's to replace the periodic AND to use to find the 'condition' of any installation apart from actually where the burried parts of the circuit run. (Periodics can still be used for commercial & industrial work)
But IF you do it thoroughly then it WILL be safe and with a RCD on EVERT circuit that has burried cables then anyone inadvertantly damaging them will be protected.

OFTEN building work is taken on as a complete package INCLUDING being the customers agent for the B.C. so the customer never get to see anything to do with B.C.
Yes often the lowest price is accepted so builders get in cheap subbies and often go bust.

Do the EICR but charge for it as it'll take a day at least on a small property if you've done it right. There are several pages of specific question on the regulations so you will have lied if you tick the box and it doesn't comply.
BUT you can't do it unless your scheme operator has specifically approved you to do them as it does take experience and knowledge to check installations you never put in, (what a periodic was and I bet very few of them have EVER been done properly). Also you should have Proffessional Indemnity Insurance because you ARE giving a proffessional opinion on someone else's work so if after, someone gets hurt or killed then YOUR EICR will be investigated and it could be a very long time in goal for causing death or injury!

Ever since I've been Part P registered I've asked all concerned (had a long running discorse with a guy in the IEE about why they didn't have individual circuit test forms as well as the summary!!) WHERE do you record all the test results that you take IF you test by the regulations???
I have my own forms I use and they don't half help when you go into properties done by cowboys, all your results are neatly tabulated so you can easily see where bridges, bad connection, the CPC's have been used as the third core for two way or the neutral for a heating thermostat upgrade.
Not one person, experienced qualified sparks included, have EVER been able to tell me WHERE they record all the readings they SHOULD take! You'd need to be Mr Memory if you can remember which reading was the worst and at what point for a circuit that will need testing at twenty points or more, (usually a lot more as you have to TEST for circuit continuity and that INCLUDES the CPC and most of those end at a light switch so that has to come off and the CPC recovered as it's usually been cut off out of the way!

ANYONE can sign the form if qualified, Part P or formally qualified electricians but LOADS of both will just sign and hope.
Me, as a Part P'er, would like the continuation of needing fuller qualifications as Part P goes along as that way everyone in the trade will eventually be formally qualified, but the biggest jump will be when they stop anyone but qualified people actually buying the materials like in a lot of other civilised countries. (Gas should be the same).

So you lot, download and read the forms and the guidance notes, all very self explanitory.

I've had a couple of female trainees over the years, great, pick it up quick and like to do it right. (Please don't come back with the usual sexual inuendo's to this.)

Have you confused yourself?
 
I've GOT to come in on this!

You all NEED to go to the IET website and download a set of 17th edition amendment 1, forms. It's 400Kb in pdf format. AND FREE to use, just need paper and a printer to make them and they are perfectly legal and haven't been 'doctored' by any scheme operators to fit nicely on a page with room for their logo!

Periodic is no longer valid for Part P work, has to be an EICR. It's to replace the periodic AND to use to find the 'condition' of any installation apart from actually where the burried parts of the circuit run. (Periodics can still be used for commercial & industrial work)
But IF you do it thoroughly then it WILL be safe and with a RCD on EVERT circuit that has burried cables then anyone inadvertantly damaging them will be protected.

OFTEN building work is taken on as a complete package INCLUDING being the customers agent for the B.C. so the customer never get to see anything to do with B.C.
Yes often the lowest price is accepted so builders get in cheap subbies and often go bust.

Do the EICR but charge for it as it'll take a day at least on a small property if you've done it right. There are several pages of specific question on the regulations so you will have lied if you tick the box and it doesn't comply.
BUT you can't do it unless your scheme operator has specifically approved you to do them as it does take experience and knowledge to check installations you never put in, (what a periodic was and I bet very few of them have EVER been done properly). Also you should have Proffessional Indemnity Insurance because you ARE giving a proffessional opinion on someone else's work so if after, someone gets hurt or killed then YOUR EICR will be investigated and it could be a very long time in goal for causing death or injury!

Ever since I've been Part P registered I've asked all concerned (had a long running discorse with a guy in the IEE about why they didn't have individual circuit test forms as well as the summary!!) WHERE do you record all the test results that you take IF you test by the regulations???
I have my own forms I use and they don't half help when you go into properties done by cowboys, all your results are neatly tabulated so you can easily see where bridges, bad connection, the CPC's have been used as the third core for two way or the neutral for a heating thermostat upgrade.
Not one person, experienced qualified sparks included, have EVER been able to tell me WHERE they record all the readings they SHOULD take! You'd need to be Mr Memory if you can remember which reading was the worst and at what point for a circuit that will need testing at twenty points or more, (usually a lot more as you have to TEST for circuit continuity and that INCLUDES the CPC and most of those end at a light switch so that has to come off and the CPC recovered as it's usually been cut off out of the way!

ANYONE can sign the form if qualified, Part P or formally qualified electricians but LOADS of both will just sign and hope.
Me, as a Part P'er, would like the continuation of needing fuller qualifications as Part P goes along as that way everyone in the trade will eventually be formally qualified, but the biggest jump will be when they stop anyone but qualified people actually buying the materials like in a lot of other civilised countries. (Gas should be the same).

So you lot, download and read the forms and the guidance notes, all very self explanitory.

I've had a couple of female trainees over the years, great, pick it up quick and like to do it right. (Please don't come back with the usual sexual inuendo's to this.)

Right - if i need to be corrected then fair enough, i'll accept it.

But, im pretty sure you can't use Periodic Reports anymore - they were replaced by the EICR and as far as im concerned that is for all installations.
 
The way I read it on the IET site is that the only legally required forms are those required under Part P for Dwellings, BSen 7671 is the required standard under that legislation, like all the Building Reg's you can comply in many ways but the easiest and undisputable is via the approved documents and Part P uses 7671 as that approved document.
When the EICR came out it said on their site that it was to replace the Periodic as that was unsuitable for Part P (Dwellings) because of the need for uncertified work to be regularised, could be from a business going bust or a customer/contractor dispute (BUT not every Part P qualified competant person could fill them out, they have to have specific authority from their scheme operator to do it as you are testing third party work so need the skil and experience over and above that needed to pass your own work.
Periodics were still usable for commercial and industrial where a periodic inspection was due though the more thoriugh EICR could be used instead. I don't do any commercial or industrial so am not up on the legal side of it but I gather that there is no direct LEGAL requirement (like Part P of the building Reg's for dwellings as that only covers residential buildings) for qualified electricians to do the work or inspect/test it. I believe the need for qualifications comes from having to meet HSE, Electricity at Work and of course the businesses insurance companies requirements.

I thought the thread was started off about signing off other peoples work in relation to Part P.
 
Neither NAPIT or NICEIC allow me to use periodic reports for commercial/industrial. Has to be EICR.
NAPIT have an EICR form for 100a + to be used for commercial/industrial
NICEIC have different EICR forms for either commercial/industrial or domestic.
 

Reply to Sign off A.N.Other builders work in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

This is a strange one, my neighbour is a bit mad, he had a largish extension built in about 2015, the builder attempted to do everything including...
Replies
3
Views
958
Evening all. Is there a stigma of signing off someone else’s work? If you came out and tested and all was ok…are you happy to sign off...
Replies
34
Views
8K
Hi all Just qualified last Monday and I have completed both initial and periodic test and inspection courses. What is the process for joining the...
Replies
2
Views
1K
Hi guys got a question to ask: In Scotland for reference. My mate recently bought a house and he is wanting me to do an EICR, new Consumer Unit...
Replies
3
Views
1K
I really hope someone can help me. Last July I got an electricity bill showing an enormous rise in my kwh consumption of about 900% from what it...
Replies
11
Views
2K

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

Electrical Forum

Welcome to the Electrical Forum at ElectriciansForums.net. The friendliest electrical forum online. General electrical questions and answers can be found in the electrical forum.
This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by Untold Media. Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock