Discuss RCD Test on lighting circuit protected by RCBOs in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net
The cap pins fell off of my BC one, not happy considering the cost of the things!
i'm with spin on this. RCD might perform perfectly when loads are dissed, but a neutral fault somewhere on the installation could prevent it from operating. the whole purpose of a RCD is to protect against accidental touching of a live part anywhere on the installation. therefore it should be tested as a real life situation, not dissed from the circuits. that's like something working in the lab. but failing in service. tin hat, where art thou?
Just noting that for all the effort of getting the screw-ins it still means you have to access near live terminals. That said, it's a nightmare holding three leads in the air while pressing a button so those screw-ins are worth their weight.
Explain how?RCD might perform perfectly when loads are dissed, but a neutral fault somewhere on the installation could prevent it from operating
Agree with Tel, long story which I previously recounted (RB explained, I think) earth neutral fault, stopped RCD functioning.Explain how?
Can't see how. Also struggling to see the point in testing multiple circuits at the end of each when fed from a common RCD? I was always taught to test an RCD at the board, and have always done so.Agree with Tel, long story which I previously recounted (RB explained, I think) earth neutral fault, stopped RCD functioning.
When it comes to RCBO's it's also the case that some will not respond to a test direct to terminals for some obscure technical reason nobody understands.....these must be tested via the connected circuit,or a couple of short tails need to be connected.
It's because a few RCBOs have the current sense coil between the cable entry ports and the terminals (above the location of the terminal screws in conventional vertical orientation) and are sensing the current in the first few millimetres of wire outside the terminals. So if you put your test probes on the terminal screws, you're bypassing the coil. If you probe via the cable entry ports, it'll test OK, but this isn't usually possible due to the space available.
I think you will find nearly all rcds now sense AC and DC which is why the old style of loop tester like Robin (still using one) which used their DLoc technology not to trip the rcd rarely operate through rcds now, this technology used DC which most rcds basically didn't recognise. Modern loop testers use low current of around 10ma so as not to upset the rcd, a method which often supply gives inaccurate results.One of the things that will prevent an RCD operating is d.c. current.
This is how the 'no trip' function on MFTs works.
The MFT saturates the coil with d.c. current while it conducts the Zs test.
I don't know how it does, but it did in my case......keeping it short, connecting up CU & found neutral earth fault on a radial. Decided to investigate that later, and put offending cable to one side, except I didn't and mixed up with another circuit. Carried testing and connecting. Got to testing one of the RCD's & it would not trip under test nor via test button. After a lot of head scratching, went back to the beginning of testing again, but after a short while tested the single 'faulty' cable not connected & realised my mistake. Removed the actual faulty cable from CU, everything hunky dory. Not sure of the science, but that's the reality.Can't see how. Also struggling to see the point in testing multiple circuits at the end of each when fed from a common RCD? I was always taught to test an RCD at the board, and have always done so.
No, only 'B' type sense d.c. current, which is why they are used where there are solar panels.I think you will find nearly all rcds now sense AC and DC which is why the old style of loop tester like Robin (still using one) which used their DLoc technology not to trip the rcd rarely operate through rcds now, this technology used DC which most rcds basically didn't recognise. Modern loop testers use low current of around 10ma so as not to upset the rcd, a method which often supply gives inaccurate results.
Reply to RCD Test on lighting circuit protected by RCBOs in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net
We get it, advertisements are annoying!
Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.