Discuss Labour Manifesto in the Electricians Chat - Off Topic Chat area at ElectriciansForums.net
Firstly... can you please stop repeating that line about "jumping off cliffs" !!! It is simply highly emotive language used to scare people... that hasn't worked on most people, but seems to have scared you.I disagree
Thats like saying let's watch the rest of the UK jump off a cliff and see what happens
Northern Ireland voted to stay in the EU and are (rightly) getting a differential deal, Scotland voted by a larger margin to stay and are being draged out
This wait and see is in essence undemocratic- it is saying to te Scottish Parliament - you cannot decide if and when you can leave, sit down, shut up and know your place. Democracy is what Westminster says and Westminster can pick and choose which parts it uses.
There is a March for independence in Glasgow on 11th January, the last one had over 100,000 ( equivalent to 1m in London as Scots are less than 10% of the population) yet received little or no coverage in UK media and was on RT, France 24. Euronews, German TV etc.
Firstly... can you please stop repeating that line about "jumping off cliffs" !!! It is simply highly emotive language used to scare people... that hasn't worked on most people, but seems to have scared you.
Secondly... the EU referendum was for the whole of the UK... no option was given to have locally implemented results. So it doesn't matter what the vote was in Scotland, Salisbury, Scarborough or indeed St Albans. The latter, if you remember, has just elected a Lib Dem MP... on a mandate of cancelling Brexit. So do you now suggest that we build a 30' high fence around that city and allow them to declare their allegiance to Juncker and co. ??
And lastly... please do enjoy your march on Jan 11th. In case it wasn't explained to you properly... it's all irrelevant. You may have 100,000 attend but what about the 100,000 that don't attend ?? the ones that want to remain in the union ?? If you want to demonstrate the will of the people you need to organise a referendum. Oh, hang on you already have... and it said remain. When will the penny drop ??
You seem to be living in a parallel universe...Northern Ireland voted to stay in and are (rightly) staying so there is a locally implemented result there, if it is possible there it is possible in Scotland
Thank you for telling me democracy in Scotland is irrelevant my point is that the duly elected Scottish Parliament has voted for and requested a referendum
It's nice democracy where a country enters a union with a larger partner and can only leave when the larger 'equal' partner deems permission.
We had a referendum in 2014 and were told explicitly that if we voted NO to independence we would guarantee our place in the EU
I know you don't like the cliff scenario but that's a difference of opinion, Scotland and the rest of the UK are in a voluntary union and Scotland (through her parliament) has decided we want to put that choice to the people in 2020 (or the following year)
You are quite correct, NI is de jure staying in the UK customs union, however they will de facto be in the EU customs union and regulatorily aligned with all European laws.You seem to be living in a parallel universe...
NI are not staying in the EU... they will leave alongside Wales, Scotland and England. You might have confused yourself with the transition arrangements that have been constructed in such a way as to allow the EU to agree to remove the 'backstop'.
I have never said that democracy is irrelevant in Scotland... I said that the referendum was for the whole of the UK and that individual areas cannot elect for different treatment. (read back to my example of St Albans)
It would appear that you'd like to have a Scottish independence referendum every year until you get the result that you personally agree with. That's an odd kind of democracy !
It would be highly beneficial for the Scottish people, if the Scottish government used their authority to properly govern Scotland (in areas like education and health) rather than pursue the sole issue of a 'neverendum' ! Scotland have vast devolved powers, but have chosen to use very few of them.
Why doesn’t Scotland wait to see how Brexit pans out, then if it’s a disaster, have a indyref, leave and rejoin the EU?
So you agree with me to stay, see how things progress, if it’s pants have your vote then.
Why does the SNP want to do it the other way?
Fair enough, been nice knowing you.
Yep and that's fine - the UK can leave the EU, but Scotland can decide to go a different path- then we all get what we want.It was the United Kingdom that voted....not England not Scotland not wales and not northern island....the U.K. as a whole voted on brexit
That doesn't work. It's like the EU member states voting to keep the UK within the EU. It affects them too.Not while it’s part of the uk it can’t, surely we should ALL have a vote on who leaves and who stays then? After all it affects us all not just the Scottish....
I’m inclined to agree with that @rapparee, but this is effectively breaking up a countryThat doesn't work. It's like the EU member states voting to keep the UK within the EU. It affects them too.
That train of thought is very dangerous. Surely the idea of self declaration is safer.
I understand where you're coming from but I wouldn't worry about it.I’m inclined to agree with that @rapparee, but this is effectively breaking up a country
Reply to Labour Manifesto in the Electricians Chat - Off Topic Chat area at ElectriciansForums.net
We get it, advertisements are annoying!
Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.