Search the forum,

Discuss New stables behind house/garage in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Reaction score
8
Hi Ive been asked to fit some lights and a socket in a new stable yet to be built but its giving me a bit of a head ache. I haven't done a stable before so i just want to check with people in the know whats the best way of going about it. First of all there will be two stables sited in a paddock behind the customers house. They will sit directly behind a garage which will be converted to a tack room and storage room. The garage already has a supply fed by 2.5 SWA direct from the house CU (RCD protected side) on a 16A MCB. They have used a 16A because the run starts off as 2.5mm T&E buried in plaster and joins the 2.5mm SWA somewhere in the house. (This derates cable to 18.5A according to BGB) The garage has two strip lights and 4 double metalclad sockets on a ring. The house supply is TNC-S and is a good 25meteres maybe more from the garage. I measured the voltage in the garage and it was 239v, i checked the EFLI at a socket in the garage and i got 1.23ohms.

They want a light in each stable, a light in front of each stable, an outdoor socket near to them and the lights in the garage reconfiguring to accommodate the new layout. Im told the socket outside is for clippers and the sockets inside the garage will be for radio, battery charger or the like. Nothing major although they want an electric garage door at some point.

I cant see the load going over 16A at the moment although you never know in the future, They want to keep existing cable as its run underground and not easy to to run a new one to the stable, in fact it would be a real nightmare! I want to put a mini CU in the garage then have a DP main switch, two MCBs one for lights and one for sockets but this is where my problems begin, First of all i dont like it all being run off the RCD side of CU because if theres a fault in the garage or stable the whole house trips (although this is how it is set up now), secondly i can put a 6A MCB for lights but i cant put a 16A MCB for for sockets as there is already one at the other end. I thought about putting a 16A RCBO in the CU so at least if it tripped the rest of the house would be ok but what about the MCBs in garage?. The cable runs in the stable would be in plastic conduit and not near the horses i.e. up high and run outside. The customer wants to keep existing sockets in garage but they are just T&E clipped to the wall and i dont think they would last 5 minutes when the rats find them! I suggested just having a couple of sockets and changing to conduit. I'm also a bit worried about volt drop as its a long way to go in 2.5mm when you add on the circuits in garage and stables. My calculations dont add up to the 239volts i measured. It would all be protected by 30mA RCD or RCBO.

Any help and advise would be gratefully appreciated as its doing my head in trying to figure what to do for the best. If i could i would just run a new SWA cable from a new board but as i said its not really an option it involves going over a neighbors property, digging up landscaped gardens etc etc etc

Cheers in advance
Michael
 
just run what they want Let them no the shortcomings I.e loading and ensure cable is adequately protected. does 2.5 in plaster really derate to 18.5? surely thats method c, even with capping.
oh and make sure you run your wiring in something tough inside the stable as horses will chew it!
 
I would want to see that garage swapped to swa or tube as being a tack / store room , you are right in thinking about potential vermin issues .
You will also have to make those stables TT .
 
You are in a fortunate position to be consulted "early" in the process and I think you should be advising a solution that would be more appropriate for the new buildings and at the same time minimise inconvienence to those in the house:

1. Split talis in house
2. New submain to out building - 4 or 6mm SWA
3. New CU in stables with RCBO's

then circuits from there.

Got to be worth talking through with the client.
 
Hi, not sure what you mean by:
"My calculations dont add up to the 239volts i measured"
Use normal method of
cable length design current and mv/a/m from table

Hi thanks for reply, i did the mv/a/m calcs (roughly) for what is already there i.e. the cable run to garage and it already doesnt comply with volt drop limits for lighting, i realize when i tested voltage it wasnt under load so wasnt really a valid reading. I just dont want to end up with a 10% volt drop on the end of the circuit! Im not sure how else to check if there will be too much volt drop?
 
just run what they want Let them no the shortcomings I.e loading and ensure cable is adequately protected. does 2.5 in plaster really derate to 18.5? surely thats method c, even with capping.
oh and make sure you run your wiring in something tough inside the stable as horses will chew it!

Hi thanks for reply, yeah i think so thats why they have protected cable with a 16A MCB not a 20A method C is 27A which is a big jump! I will be keeping all conduit out of the way of the horses i can imagine they will just eat it.
 
I would say you've got two options.
first is new supply from house and then they can have what ever they want.
or secondly redo your cable calcs to see if you can upgrade the circuit to 20A rcbo. 2 way board with 6a lighting and 16A radial. Let them know of the limitations regarding the power consumption of the sockets.
its upto the client, you give the options and prices and see what happens. I push for the new sub main better job.
as for the install defo conduit. The sables I have done have been galv cos of the horses booting and chewing everything but you could use heavy garage PVC if they can't get to it.
be interested in what the result is
 
Sorry, misread your original post.
Best to do the calculation and go with this.
If it is already over, then not much you can do but:
1. Lower load. Not possible.
2. Larger CSA cable. Possible
3. Move stables closer to house. Prob not possible.
 
You are in a fortunate position to be consulted "early" in the process and I think you should be advising a solution that would be more appropriate for the new buildings and at the same time minimise inconvienence to those in the house:

1. Split talis in house
2. New submain to out building - 4 or 6mm SWA
3. New CU in stables with RCBO's

then circuits from there.

Got to be worth talking through with the client.

Hi thanks for reply yeah this was my first thought but its just not possible without massive expense and hassle which they don't want
and neither do i! In the end it may be the only option though, i hate trying to comprimise everything just to keep costs to a minimum
 
Sorry, misread your original post.
Best to do the calculation and go with this.
If it is already over, then not much you can do but:
1. Lower load. Not possible.
2. Larger CSA cable. Possible
3. Move stables closer to house. Prob not possible.

LOL Yep hence the dilemma! cant change cable its buried under manicured lawns and flower beds. I wish i was a plumber
 
Hi thanks for reply yeah this was my first thought but its just not possible without massive expense and hassle which they don't want and neither do i! In the end it may be the only option though, i hate trying to comprimise everything just to keep costs to a minimum

Welll.... when the outbuildings are tripping the house they may see sense. If they've got money to build such buildings they need to budget to allow for a new cable.
 
I find the more they have the less they want to spend! I guess thats why they have so much money.

Send them a quote to do the job properly then walk away.

I see you are newly signed up with Elecsa and if you approach every job to penny pinch you could easily end up a busy fool. You are doing this to make a living, not work 40 hours a week to scrap by.
 
Send them a quote to do the job properly then walk away.

I see you are newly signed up with Elecsa and if you approach every job to penny pinch you could easily end up a busy fool. You are doing this to make a living, not work 40 hours a week to scrap by.

You couldnt be more right mate it seems that people just dont value electrical work though people just dont want to pay whats it worth. Everyones looking for a quick fix. I will quote what i want and i wont get the job so that will sort my dillema lol
 
haha awesome kit , especially the bigger remote control jobbies.
you need to do a cat scan first so you miss any buried services during the boring.

yours truely has done under a motorway with a mole ;-)

Biff , i could swap some stories that that would make your balls disappear .:uhoh2:
Even we have not gone under one of them yet , just to many variables that could end up in a disaster for me !
 
You couldnt be more right mate it seems that people just dont value electrical work though people just dont want to pay whats it worth. Everyones looking for a quick fix. I will quote what i want and i wont get the job so that will sort my dillema lol

when you send your quote, you know it may be more than they are expecting so make sure that they understand the "key" points of what you are suggesting....... maybe a few days sales training would help
 
Biff , i could swap some stories that that would make your balls disappear .:uhoh2:
Even we have not gone under one of them yet , just to many variables that could end up in a disaster for me !

its worth the risk for a highways dept , closing 1 mile of 1 lane of motorway costs several grand a day so a massive saving of tens of '000s.
me and my boss "observed" while the company operator demo'd the equipment , not knowing he was saving us a 3 day manual dig lol
 
I love the idea of trenchless technology! I'd never heard of it. There would still be problems in this case though its just a really awkwardly situated house and they have access issues etc plus id have to go up and over a garage and somehow over a conservatory lol. I might suggest solar panels!
 
its worth the risk for a highways dept , closing 1 mile of 1 lane of motorway costs several grand a day so a massive saving of tens of '000s.
me and my boss "observed" while the company operator demo'd the equipment , not knowing he was saving us a 3 day manual dig lol

A directional drill is the next one on my wish list , but at £15,000 for even a knacked at the end of its life one , i think it will be on the list for a bit yet !:bigcry:
 
and stuff needs to be securely fixed n all....as if the horse decides to scratch its arse up against it on a night.....

agreed , its gotta be steel conduit for the switch & skt drops.
and if these are expensive horses i'd be sourcing 10ma rcds for the stable cu , a human can take 30ma most animals wont.
 
agreed , its gotta be steel conduit for the switch & skt drops.
and if these are expensive horses i'd be sourcing 10ma rcds for the stable cu , a human can take 30ma most animals wont.
only thing here though Biff with using 10mA RCDs is the nuisance tripping...damp condidions + corrosive horse shyte...
 
Yard up the road from me lost 4 horses in one instance,drinkers in four seperate stables providing the input...Sounds like the customer has been given too much room to impart rules,if they don't like cable install costs,they are going to hate cost of new TD 300Ma rcd etc...Recommend they swap to hamsters...
 
Ive found recently that in life it's those that have little money are the most generous!
I can't (well I suppose I can) believe that a customer that can afford horses doesn't want to pay to have a job done properly! As others have said, price it properly, explain the reasoning and if required walk (trot) away.
 
At the end of the day all you can do is quote for the job (properly done) and leave it in their hands. If they don't want to do it then walk away, I wouldn't get involved in doing work I know to be crap.
 
and stuff needs to be securely fixed n all....as if the horse decides to scratch its arse up against it on a night....

Nevamind the horses doing it...................the stable lass on the farm where I go fishing could knock the Tx off the pole in the field with the size of her A........xx........e lol
 
Thanks for advice and comments, quote went in to customer with a full explanation and they said what with cost of stables they will leave the electrics for now! As mentioned in comments earlier they do have a few quid, i know brand new range rovers aren't cheap nor are 6 bed houses in private streets. I guess they just feel they are getting value for money with a nice new stable block but not with a few lights and sockets. Thanks again ill keep at it!
Michael
 
Thanks for advice and comments, quote went in to customer with a full explanation and they said what with cost of stables they will leave the electrics for now! As mentioned in comments earlier they do have a few quid, i know brand new range rovers aren't cheap nor are 6 bed houses in private streets. I guess they just feel they are getting value for money with a nice new stable block but not with a few lights and sockets. Thanks again ill keep at it!
Michael

Best thing about theses threads is the ability to learn for the next time.

If I were you I'd be working out an approx price for the job, so next time you are looking at something similar, you can "bounce" an approx price off the customer when you visit them and you can watch their reaction!
 
and stuff needs to be securely fixed n all....as if the horse decides to scratch its arse up against it on a night....

Nevamind the horses doing it...................the stable lass on the farm where I go fishing could knock the Tx off the pole in the field with the size of her A........xx........e lol
and does she have 4 points of contact Allan?....lol...
 

Reply to New stables behind house/garage in the UK Electrical Forum area at ElectriciansForums.net

Similar Threads

Hi, if getting back to the CU is not an option, instead of spurring off a socket via a Sfs putting the rating down to 13a. Could you spur off the...
Replies
43
Views
2K
Hey everyone, working on a new build house and outside garage is wired up like this, however customer wants a Garage Consumer Unit instead of the...
Replies
8
Views
373
Hi, just helping someone out and apologies for the long winded post. Would like install a couple of weatherproof double sockets on the patio. 1...
Replies
3
Views
779
Hello. I live in a new build house with a separate garage. The garage is connected to RCD in the house to a 16A circuit breaker. The cable from...
Replies
1
Views
269
Was having a poke around the old man's house today. Anyway. DB is under stairs (18th ed following a recent extension. Not done by me but it's...
Replies
7
Views
768

OFFICIAL SPONSORS

Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Electrician Courses Green Electrical Goods PCB Way Electrical Goods - Electrical Tools - Brand Names Pushfit Wire Connectors Electric Underfloor Heating Electrician Courses
These Official Forum Sponsors May Provide Discounts to Regular Forum Members - If you would like to sponsor us then CLICK HERE and post a thread with who you are, and we'll send you some stats etc

YOUR Unread Posts

This website was designed, optimised and is hosted by untold.media Operating under the name Untold Media since 2001.
Back
Top