Global IR testing on RCBO populated CU

[pc1966]

EW - Hager 2 Pole 6kA B-6A 30mA A Class RCBO AD906J

Hager 2 Pole 6kA B-6A 30mA A Class RCBO AD906J for sale in stores and online from Electrical Wholesaler for 1 day delivery

www.electricalwholesaler.ie

That is an ROI site? As above, not UK available (to any sane definition of "available" without having currency conversion and import issues).

 

[Mike Johnson]

Luckily I bought all mine before Jan 1st so no duty, but a little research and: https://www.electricalwholesaler.ie...tbreakers/hagerrcbo2p1pn6kab6a30maaclassad906 available in the UK.

And: Chint Double Pole RCBO's - https://www.expertelectrical.co.uk/chint-nb1l-double-pole-rcbos

And: 40 Amp 30mA RCBO - Type A - B Curve - 2 Module - Contactum - https://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/CPBR402.html?

 

[pc1966]

Luckily I bought all mine before Jan 1st so no duty, but a little research and: https://www.electricalwholesaler.ie...tbreakers/hagerrcbo2p1pn6kab6a30maaclassad906 available in the UK.

And: Chint Double Pole RCBO's - https://www.expertelectrical.co.uk/chint-nb1l-double-pole-rcbos

And: 40 Amp 30mA RCBO - Type A - B Curve - 2 Module - Contactum - https://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Products/CPBR402.html?

Yes, but none of them fit a UK-style CU busbar arrangement do they?

We have never had problems getting DP RCBO as standard fitting for a caravan supply, the problem if finding RCBOs for a CU that are neutral switching, but thankfully now a few are (Wylex, Crabtree, Fusebox).

Doing away with flying leads and simply having a neutral busbar would be the answer, but that is not likely here for some time I suspect...

 

[nicebutdim]

Is a neutral busbar worth the additional space required for 2 module RCBOs?

Would those Hagar RCBOs have any benefit over Crabtree, Wylex or Fusebox 1P+N single module RCBOs in a domestic application, other than flylead?

 

[Mike Johnson]

Yes, but none of them fit a UK-style CU busbar arrangement do they?

Yes the do, and use a 13mm pitch dual busbar: A9XPH224 | Schneider Electric Acti 9 2 Phase Busbar, 24 Module, 415V, 18mm Pitch | RS Components - https://uk.rs-online.com/web/p/busbars/7762724/

 

[Mike Johnson]

Should have said 18mm pitch busbar.

 

[bigspark17]

Why not test N-earth and then test live - earth. What are you gaining/preventing by joining them together?

 

[mattg4321]

Yes the do, and use a 13mm pitch dual busbar: A9XPH224 | Schneider Electric Acti 9 2 Phase Busbar, 24 Module, 415V, 18mm Pitch | RS Components - https://uk.rs-online.com/web/p/busbars/7762724/
View attachment 64782

A wylex enclosure and main switch. Hager devices and Schneider bus bar!

Mixing and matching is not allowed here now.

As above, no major U.K. supplier has a CU with that sort of arrangement. Possibly SBS, but I’d rather use a manufacturer where parts will be more likely to be readily available long term and available locally on the shelf.

 

[pc1966]

Should have said 18mm pitch busbar.

Also that is for the Acti9 range of industrial enclosures, not the Easy9 range usually sold for domestic.

Sure it can be done, but it is not something you can just buy "off the shelf" in any real sense in the UK.

 

[pc1966]

Would those Hagar RCBOs have any benefit over Crabtree, Wylex or Fusebox 1P+N single module RCBOs in a domestic application, other than flylead?

For the typical UK case where N is very much at a low potential to E by design and installation verification, then no.

They seem to bo common in the EU where they have TT as the norm and perhaps traditionally did not have N as near Earth potential. Either as historically it was more like a split-phase supply taking 2 of a 3-phase line set, or for whatever reason they demanded over-current protection on the N side.

The "neutral switching" 1P+N RCBO you see here will detect and isolate an earth fault that happens via the N side, but they do not detect over-current on that side as that is not a UK requirement going back a long, long way. Even when the 13A plug design was introduced in the 40s it was line-side fuse only as installations could be trusted to have N approx E in potential.