Can i legaly rip out the kitchen ring main and replace myself?

[rwhite2012]

lol u r proper bodge mate

 

[Current Affairs]

Interestingly I completed an EICR on a property that has just had an extension. The home owner rewired the whole house himself plus the new kitchen in the extension, unqaulified. He tells me he needs my cert to get building control to ok his building cert.
So it would seem part P & scammers are a complete waste of time when you can rewire & just pay for a PIR to get past building control

 

[Taylortwocities]

Interestingly I completed an EICR on a property that has just had an extension. The home owner rewired the whole house himself plus the new kitchen in the extension, unqaulified. He tells me he needs my cert to get building control to ok his building cert.
So it would seem part P & scammers are a complete waste of time when you can rewire & just pay for a PIR to get past building control

Now here is what you need to understand
EIC is an Eletectrical Installation Certificate. In this the person doing the work certifies that the work he has done complies with BS7671

A PIR (now a EICR) is a REPORT that says you have tested the installation against today's standards and it provides a note of where there is non-compliance.

Completely different things.

I agree that its a complete horlicks. Building Control should never accept an EICR as a get out clause. It should always be a proper test done by the householder who has done teh work as a DIYer. That is the intention of the legislation.

 

[ferg]

I guess the EICR get out clause is necessary to a degree.
What do you do if all wiring is done and dusted plastered and decorated then the Installer gets run over by a bus?
Rewire from scratch?
Same if Said installer goes bust or lied about registration.
Given that joe public is generally completely unaware of part P should BC demand the lot be ripped out and started again for the sake of an EIC?

 

[Knobhead]

You can’t knock the customer.

He’s found the way around the system, as I see it, all good. The system is so full of holes it deserves to sink.

 

[Guitarist]

You can’t knock the customer.

He’s found the way around the system, as I see it, all good. The system is so full of holes it deserves to sink.

It is an absolute joke when you can ignore an EIC and get an EICR done afterwards. I agree that in exceptional circumstances it may be a get-out-clause for those involved, but what do we see when people put up extensions without planning permission? The building often gets taken down is what, or at least looked at with a fine tooth-comb.

 

[RISElectrical]

Playing devils advocate here but what it said customer actually did a very very good job, maybe even better than most of the local sparks he could have employed... then gets an eicr done. He house technically then could be a lot safer and more compliant than a new build ( as discussed in another thread)

People on here argue in 1 thread that all works should be done by a registered spark, then in another thread say that registered sparks are largely under qualified Electrical Trainee and are bad at the job.

Go figure, its all a big mess if you ask me

 

[Current Affairs]

Now here is what you need to understand
EIC is an Eletectrical Installation Certificate. In this the person doing the work certifies that the work he has done complies with BS7671

A PIR (now a EICR) is a REPORT that says you have tested the installation against today's standards and it provides a note of where there is non-compliance.

Completely different things.

I agree that its a complete horlicks. Building Control should never accept an EICR as a get out clause. It should always be a proper test done by the householder who has done teh work as a DIYer. That is the intention of the legislation.

I fully understand they are different things, I did not do the install so cannot issue an EIC, hence the customer could only have an EICR from me, which is what he got. Based on this cert which can be issued by anyone not qualified he has passed building control!

and yes rise, other than a few loose cpc's on the ring final, a very good install. Well it aint rocket science after all

 

[1shortcircuit]

This is an interesting thread lol

My answer to the OP's question would be "Yes you can legally so long as you comply with the two options that will ensure the work remains safe and legal"

In my opinion if someone deems themselves competent then let them crack on. They could choose to seek any advice from a local spark beforehand OR involve Local Authority Building Control from the start and pay the fee.

DIY is a fact of life these days and I do not understand anyone who thinks that these people are taking money out of their pockets just because they are working in that specific trade. Just charge them more when you do get the call to go in and put it right or rip it all out and start again SIMPLE

I'm in the process of tiling my bathroom floor and by doing so taking money out of a trades persons pocket, do I care? do I hell lol The difference is I know my limitations and when I find something is beyond my capability I do without hesitation call in the experts and pay the price for it.

I think some people need to take a chill pill from time to time, this is a forum... take a breath and relax. If you don't like a post then go to another thread... it really is that simple

If this forum really was solely for electricians only then it would be set up accordingly so that members would have to prove their competence, that would be a real fun place to frequent wouldn't it lol. This should be an inviting place for the non electrically minded to come for advice. I'm afraid that after reading a lot of comments on here I would be of the opinion that nearly all electricians are jumped up little so and so's and would not like to deal with them if I had the choice. It's so easy to get the OP to post a location and get a member to pop around. This forum could generate a lot of work for certain members if the attitude was correct but as per usual in this day and age all most people seem interested in is whinging and whining about how unfair the world is treating them lol

****please note this has been posted lightheartedly****

 

[telectrix]

some goood points there s/c.

 

[Current Affairs]

2nd that, I service my own cars, do my own carpentry, plastering, plumbing, hell built my own Loft conversion. Its all simple stuff for manual minded people