PME system with earth rod aswell

[buzzlightyear]

I'm trying to think of something funny to say about all the new books etc I'll have to buy

yeah like the beano or dandy !

 

[static zap]

....Most of the rest of the world requires Earth electrodes on TN-C-S installations - it's about time JPEL/64 caught up.

We were a proud nation of Engineers ,
(I'll blame global warming making us all equal)

 

[buzzlightyear]

We were a proud nation of Engineers ,
(I'll blame global warming making us all equal)

is that boiling the kettle at the same time!

 

[Octopus]

Na their doing amendment 1 to the 18th now
Out 2020

Why can't they simply defer the 18th until 2020 ?

Save us all a lot of money....

 

[static zap]

Why can't they simply defer the 18th until 2020 ?

Save us all a lot of money....

Need to keep the printing industry alive , more regulations , Brexit red tape ..!

 

[buzzlightyear]

Need to keep the printing industry alive

yeah ,that's the Chinese has well.
they like coping regs has well .

 

[David M]

i know me and pete are both old coffin dodgers, but surely you can tell us apart. i'm the good looking one.

Sorry I had to disagree, all old people blend into the same look
I often see my old man knocking about, only to find its some other old geezer who looks like him

 

[frank rabbets]

Too many mirrors David.

This reminds me of a house I moved in to in 1975 built in 1936. After a few years I decided to check the earth out as I noticed we had 2 overhead wires + and -. There was no earth system at all so I
Bought an earth rod and wired it to the fuse box accordingly.
Then the MEB came and wired the earth to neutral WTF. If that had never been brought in would they allow that now?
I think they also used to use a 12" square galvanized plate buried in the ground. I've just dug one up here, house built in 1934.

 

[frank rabbets]

Too many mirrors David.

This reminds me of a house I moved in to in 1975 built in 1936. After a few years I decided to check the earth out as I noticed we had 2 overhead wires + and -. There was no earth system at all so I
Bought an earth rod and wired it to the fuse box accordingly.
Then the MEB came and wired the earth to neutral WTF. If that had never been brought in would they allow that now?
I think they also used to use a 12" square galvanized plate buried in the ground. I've just dug one up here, house built in 1934.

 

[frank rabbets]

Too many mirrors David.

This reminds me of a house I moved in to in 1975 built in 1936. After a few years I decided to check the earth out as I noticed we had 2 overhead wires + and -. There was no earth system at all so I
Bought an earth rod and wired it to the fuse box accordingly.
Then the MEB came and wired the earth to neutral WTF. If that had never been brought in would they allow that now?
I think they also used to use a 12" square galvanized plate buried in the ground. I've just dug one up here, house built in 1934.

 

[frank rabbets]

Too many mirrors David.

This reminds me of a house I moved in to in 1975 built in 1936. After a few years I decided to check the earth out as I noticed we had 2 overhead wires + and -. There was no earth system at all so I
Bought an earth rod and wired it to the fuse box accordingly.
Then the MEB came and wired the earth to neutral WTF. If that had never been brought in would they allow that now?
I think they also used to use a 12" square galvanized plate buried in the ground. I've just dug one up here, house built in 1934.

 

[telectrix]

and this week's prize for the most duplicate posts goes to..................................................................................................................................................................................................

the rabbit.

 

[frank rabbets]

Only pressed "post reply" once !!

 

[Toneyz]

Only pressed "post reply" once !!

This seems to be happening a lot.

 

[Midwest]

Only pressed "post reply" once !!

How hard though

 

[DPG]

So was that 4 earth rods?

 

[Deleted account]

Let’s open an old thread.

looking fo4 a brief answer. Wishful thinking.

on a pme system having an earth rod as an addition is perfectly ok in my opinion.


im working for and under a new electrician at work.
we have had a distribution board fitted by outside contractors. They have earthed via a 16 mm earth conductor within the 3 phase SWA supplied from a PME system. They have also popped an earth rod in at the new distribution board. We are going to run feeds of this board for various stuff.

the new electrician wants to convert to TT or get rid of the earth rod As he thinks it’s wrong because of “potential differences” I disagree.

Am I wrong? I’m willing to accept this If I am,

but I know earth rods where proposed as additions in PME in the 18th. So I’m sure it’s OK.

 

[DPG]

Let’s open an old thread.

looking fo4 a brief answer. Wishful thinking.

on a pme system having an earth rod as an addition is perfectly ok in my opinion.


im working for and under a new electrician at work.
we have had a distribution board fitted by outside contractors. They have earthed via a 16 mm earth conductor within the 3 phase SWA supplied from a PME system. They have also popped an earth rod in at the new distribution board. We are going to run feeds of this board for various stuff.

the new electrician wants to convert to TT or get rid of the earth rod As he thinks it’s wrong because of “potential differences” I disagree.

Am I wrong? I’m willing to accept this If I am,

but I know earth rods where proposed as additions in PME in the 18th. So I’m sure it’s OK.

If the rod is bonded to the distribution board earth then surely there can be no potential difference. Did he mention which two points he was thinking of the difference being across?

I agree with you and really can't see the problem here, but it will be interesting to hear other views.

 

[Deleted account]

If the rod is bonded to the distribution board earth then surely there can be no potential difference. Did he mention which two points he was thinking of the difference being across?

I agree with you and really can't see the problem here, but it will be interesting to hear other views.

Thanks for quick responce. My thoughts exactly. Just had to check in case I had got it wrong.


This new guy has much more experience with these types of systems than me or so he said at interview, coming from industrial and comercail instals, but I’m starting to suspect he’s been relying on others to design his jobs.

 

[DPG]

Thanks for quick responce. My thoughts exactly. Just had to check in case I had got it wrong.


This new guy has much more experience with these types of systems than me or so he said at interview, coming from industrial and comercail instals, but I’m starting to suspect he’s been relying on others to design his jobs.

To be honest I'm no expert either.

Be interesting seeing what else he says.